Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

player ratings

Sat Oct 06, 2012 6:57 pm

marshall 6
kev 5
hudson 7
connelly 9
taylor 7
noone 5
whitts 7
gunnersson 7
cowie 7
mason 4
helguson 8


conway 8
gestede 7

Re: player ratings

Sat Oct 06, 2012 7:00 pm

paulh_85 wrote:marshall 5
kev 4
hudson 6
connelly 6
taylor 4
noone 4
whitts 4
gunnersson 4
cowie 3
mason 3
helguson 6

conway 8
gestede 7


fixed it for you :lol: :ayatollah:

Re: player ratings

Sat Oct 06, 2012 7:02 pm

only a 6 for helguson???? i kjow u dont like him bit have to admit he played well surely?


connelly was pure class

Re: player ratings

Sat Oct 06, 2012 7:03 pm

paulh_85 wrote:only a 6 for helguson???? i kjow u dont like him bit have to admit he played well surely?


connelly was pure class

Oh give him 7 then he did score two tap ins :ayatollah:

Re: player ratings

Sat Oct 06, 2012 7:05 pm

Cowie 7? barely saw him all game just ran around doing f**k all :?

Re: player ratings

Sat Oct 06, 2012 7:06 pm

marshall 7- great shot stopper-
kev 7- His primary job is to defend- he does
hudson 9- Better ever y season- world class by the time he is 80 :D
connelly 9- Keeps turner on the bench, says it all
taylor 6- Not as good as he thinks he is going forward - just defend son
noone 4 - Not his day
whitts 7- Not a great game by his ridiculously highly standard
gunnersson 7 Dependable
cowie 6 Does the simple things well
mason 4 Not a good start of the season for Joe. out of position IMO
helguson 7 Took chances as he should. worked hard


conway 8- Changed game when he came on
gestede 7- great back up to the old man

Re: player ratings

Sat Oct 06, 2012 7:13 pm

paulh_85 wrote:marshall 6
kev 6
hudson 7
connelly 10*
taylor 7
noone 6
whitts 7
gunnersson 6
cowie 6
mason 5
helguson 10*


conway 8
gestede 7


It's Connolly, only because I'm one :ayatollah:

Re: player ratings

Sat Oct 06, 2012 7:26 pm

Marshall 6 - should have done better with the "goal"
Taylor 6 - gave the ball away far to often but linked well with Conway when he came on.
Hudson 9 - thought he was exceptional
Connolly 8 - should have done better with the goal, did well covering.
Kev 6 - usual
Noone 3 - awful, should have been taken off HT
Gunnarson 7 - thought he had a very good game, strong, covered a lot of ground
Cowie 6 - safe in the middle did his job
Witts 6 - calm in possession
Mason 4 - awful

Helguson 8 - two good goals, never gave up.

Ratings make us sound like we player better than we did but for me all the trouble we had in the first half were in the wide areas. Conway made a huge impact and even though Rudy isn't the best he gave them another option and asked Ipswich more problems.