Thu Oct 04, 2012 4:49 pm
Thu Oct 04, 2012 6:00 pm
Thu Oct 04, 2012 6:06 pm
swansealad69 wrote:But we aint saying we are a big club unlike you.
And what you have failed to mention is that you were in the champ alot longer then us and you had the fa cup final plus no end of play offs to build the fan base up!and also the bug name players comming to your club
All this wile we were shit and struggling.
So off course you built up a bigger fan base.
But your away support has gone down over the years wile ours has gone up (even before we got to the prem).
Thu Oct 04, 2012 6:08 pm
swansealad69 wrote:But we aint saying we are a big club unlike you.
And what you have failed to mention is that you were in the champ alot longer then us and you had the fa cup final plus no end of play offs to build the fan base up!and also the bug name players comming to your club
All this wile we were shit and struggling.
So off course you built up a bigger fan base.
But your away support has gone down over the years wile ours has gone up (even before we got to the prem).
Thu Oct 04, 2012 6:11 pm
scotsjack wrote:swansealad69 wrote:But we aint saying we are a big club unlike you.
And what you have failed to mention is that you were in the champ alot longer then us and you had the fa cup final plus no end of play offs to build the fan base up!and also the bug name players comming to your club
All part of our success as yours in the prem?
All this wile we were shit and struggling.
So off course you built up a bigger fan base.
But your away support has gone down over the years wile ours has gone up (even before we got to the prem).
All correct. In fairness to the OP though, I think he was responding to an endless list of attendance stats on another thread.
I see many a thread on here regarding Ninian Park vs CCS and we had a dip at the Liberty once a few people realised that it would never live up to the memories of the old Vetch. The first season novelty wore off soon enough, the Liberty has improved over the last few years, but at first it was dreadful.
Thu Oct 04, 2012 6:12 pm
SBF1 wrote:05-06 season Cardiff 11,720 (average attendance) Swansea 14,112 (new stadium year for jacks so expected)
06-07 Cardiff 15,223 Swansea 12,720
07-08 Cardiff 13,939 Swansea 12,993
08-09 Cardiff 17,474 Swansea 15,187
09-10 Cardiff 20,717 Swansea 15,407
10-11 Cardiff 23,194 Swansea 15,507
11-12 Cardiff 22,100 Swansea 19,946
http://stats.football365.com/
This is the link here, just click on previous seasons and then on the year you want. These are the official stats with the link provided.
On a level playing field (i.e. when we are in the same league) they are no match for us. (unless there is a new stadium year)
Even the year after they had the new stadium and we were still in Np they could not do better.
Please supply link to your figures.
Thu Oct 04, 2012 6:15 pm
Carpe Diem wrote:SBF1 wrote:05-06 season Cardiff 11,720 (average attendance) Swansea 14,112 (new stadium year for jacks so expected)
06-07 Cardiff 15,223 Swansea 12,720
07-08 Cardiff 13,939 Swansea 12,993
08-09 Cardiff 17,474 Swansea 15,187
09-10 Cardiff 20,717 Swansea 15,407
10-11 Cardiff 23,194 Swansea 15,507
11-12 Cardiff 22,100 Swansea 19,946
http://stats.football365.com/
This is the link here, just click on previous seasons and then on the year you want. These are the official stats with the link provided.
On a level playing field (i.e. when we are in the same league) they are no match for us. (unless there is a new stadium year)
Even the year after they had the new stadium and we were still in Np they could not do better.
Please supply link to your figures.
Doubt he will respond ad he rarely does when proved wrong, which happens a lot. We all know he is roath or whatever other aliases he has so just treat him like the court jester he is
Thu Oct 04, 2012 6:23 pm
Thu Oct 04, 2012 6:25 pm
scotsjack wrote:I actually signed up to this forum to reply to this topic:-
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=33315
Regarding the Swans attendances at the time, there were a couple of digs about the economy playing a part at the time but I see it on threads here regarding yourselves these days. And I stand by the Sousa comments, absolute dirge being served up week in week out... Absolute sh*te!
Thu Oct 04, 2012 6:27 pm
Carpe Diem wrote:scotsjack wrote:I actually signed up to this forum to reply to this topic:-
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=33315
Regarding the Swans attendances at the time, there were a couple of digs about the economy playing a part at the time but I see it on threads here regarding yourselves these days. And I stand by the Sousa comments, absolute dirge being served up week in week out... Absolute sh*te!
Out of interest where is Sousa now?
Thu Oct 04, 2012 8:00 pm
SBF1 wrote:05-06 season Cardiff 11,720 (average attendance) Swansea 14,112 (new stadium year for jacks so expected)
06-07 Cardiff 15,223 Swansea 12,720
07-08 Cardiff 13,939 Swansea 12,993
08-09 Cardiff 17,474 Swansea 15,187
09-10 Cardiff 20,717 Swansea 15,407
10-11 Cardiff 23,194 Swansea 15,507
11-12 Cardiff 22,100 Swansea 19,946
http://stats.football365.com/
This is the link here, just click on previous seasons and then on the year you want. These are the official stats with the link provided.
On a level playing field (i.e. when we are in the same league) they are no match for us. (unless there is a new stadium year)
Even the year after they had the new stadium and we were still in Np they could not do better.
Please supply link to your figures.
Thu Oct 04, 2012 8:08 pm
scotsjack wrote:Carpe Diem wrote:scotsjack wrote:I actually signed up to this forum to reply to this topic:-
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=33315
Regarding the Swans attendances at the time, there were a couple of digs about the economy playing a part at the time but I see it on threads here regarding yourselves these days. And I stand by the Sousa comments, absolute dirge being served up week in week out... Absolute sh*te!
Out of interest where is Sousa now?
Some team in Hungary I think? No idea tbh, he didn't even have the decency to hang around at Leicester long enough for us to play against him once he left
Thu Oct 04, 2012 8:38 pm
Thu Oct 04, 2012 9:07 pm
swansealad69 wrote:But we aint saying we are a big club unlike you.
And what you have failed to mention is that you were in the champ alot longer then us and you had the fa cup final plus no end of play offs to build the fan base up!and also the bug name players comming to your club
All this wile we were shit and struggling.
So off course you built up a bigger fan base.
But your away support has gone down over the years wile ours has gone up (even before we got to the prem).
Thu Oct 04, 2012 9:43 pm
cityone wrote:swansealad69 wrote:But we aint saying we are a big club unlike you.
And what you have failed to mention is that you were in the champ alot longer then us and you had the fa cup final plus no end of play offs to build the fan base up!and also the bug name players comming to your club
All this wile we were shit and struggling.
So off course you built up a bigger fan base.
But your away support has gone down over the years wile ours has gone up (even before we got to the prem).
I see you've been hitting your key board with your boxing gloves on again.
Thu Oct 04, 2012 11:25 pm
No Smoking wrote:SBF1 wrote:05-06 season Cardiff 11,720 (average attendance) Swansea 14,112 (new stadium year for jacks so expected)
06-07 Cardiff 15,223 Swansea 12,720
07-08 Cardiff 13,939 Swansea 12,993
08-09 Cardiff 17,474 Swansea 15,187
09-10 Cardiff 20,717 Swansea 15,407
10-11 Cardiff 23,194 Swansea 15,507
11-12 Cardiff 22,100 Swansea 19,946
http://stats.football365.com/
Swansea only spent 3 seasons in the championship and since then they have
hit capacity for every game since.... So the 3 years in the championship compared to our first three season at that level are incredibly similar. Swansea a little higher in fact averaging Round the mid 14,000 where as we were just under the 14,000 mark.
BOLLOCKS
Since then we have gone on to establish ourselves in the championship and they have been promoted to the prem and have had 22 consecutive sell outs.
That is not saying either team is bigger than the other, they are just the facts. When some of our fans take the piss when we have been exactly the same is a little cringeworthy.
Nope, only you are cringe-worthy.
Cardiff city ave attendance figures....
1999/00 (Division Two) - 6,895
2000/01 (Division Three) - 7,692
2001/02 (Division Two) - 12,522
2002/03 (Division Two) - 13,049
2003/04 (Championship) - 15,569
2004/05 (Championship) - 13,029
2005/06 (Championship) - 11,802
2006/07 (Championship) - 15,224
2007/08 (Championship) - 13,939
Thu Oct 04, 2012 11:31 pm
Thu Oct 04, 2012 11:40 pm
No Smoking wrote:I don't really understand what's confusing you.
Our first 3 seasons in the championship averaged 13,900. Swansea averaged 15,300.
This is a fact.
You seem to want to compare our 6th, 7th and 8th with their 1st, 2nd and 3rd...
Thu Oct 04, 2012 11:46 pm
SBF1 wrote:No Smoking wrote:I don't really understand what's confusing you.
Our first 3 seasons in the championship averaged 13,900. Swansea averaged 15,300.
This is a fact.
You seem to want to compare our 6th, 7th and 8th with their 1st, 2nd and 3rd...
No, I'm going on average when we were both in the same division given all being equal.
To be fair, their first three seasons were in a new stadium which had a massive effect on their numbers as did ours when we moved.
So to be on a level playing field and all things equal it is best to look at it that way.
Both in new stadiums, both in the championship. No contest.![]()
![]()
Thu Oct 04, 2012 11:59 pm
No Smoking wrote:SBF1 wrote:No Smoking wrote:I don't really understand what's confusing you.
Our first 3 seasons in the championship averaged 13,900. Swansea averaged 15,300.
This is a fact.
You seem to want to compare our 6th, 7th and 8th with their 1st, 2nd and 3rd...
No, I'm going on average when we were both in the same division given all being equal.
To be fair, their first three seasons were in a new stadium which had a massive effect on their numbers as did ours when we moved.
So to be on a level playing field and all things equal it is best to look at it that way.
Both in new stadiums, both in the championship. No contest.![]()
![]()
But it isn't equal. When they entered the championship we had already had chance to build our fanbase by playing at that level for so long, 2 years previous the jacks were in league 2. You don't go from 6,000 to 20,000 just because you get promoted as our trend in attendances has shown. Yes you do, the jacks did.![]()
![]()
If Swansea were averaging 15,300 in their first 3 seasons in the champ while we could only manage 13,100 in our first three seasons then it would only be fair to assume Swansea would have also built on that the longer they stayed there like we did.
Promotion got in the way of that however and they now sell out every game.
Fri Oct 05, 2012 12:48 am
Fri Oct 05, 2012 12:52 am
scotsjack wrote:Right, I'm suffering a bout of insomnia here so I'll try and give you as honest an insight into how things developed at the Swans over the past decade...(It might help me sleep, who knows?)
As I'm sure you are all aware, around 10 years ago, we were on our arse, a consortium of local businessmen had managed to get the club back off Tony Petty, but there was no money left. The short reign of Tony Petty had a positive effect in that it galvanised the supporters, our downtrodden club was about to turn things around and the fans, who for too long had neglected the club started paying attention again.
With the money problems at the club, at the end of the 2002/03 season, we found ourselves needing to beat Hull to stay in the football league, end result, the match was sold out! We won that day and kept our place in the league, by now, the supporters trust was gaining momentum and we wouldn't look back, I can remember at the time, buckets being handed round the back of the North Bank raising money to pay the players wages, then the buckets went round again collecting money for "The battle for Britton" as the club raised the money for Leon Brittons transfer fee.
It was with this bleak backdrop and bottom division football that the Liberty Stadium was given the go-ahead by the council, a 20,500 all seater stadium! At the time, more than enough.
What nobody could have guessed at the time, the club, the fans, the council, or anybody else, was that 8 years later, we would be promoted to the Premier league! 8 years!!!
In the short time we have been at the Liberty, the club have always run offers, kids for a quid, offers to schools etc. My boy used to regularly come home from school with a form where I would pay something like £10 and I could take 2 kids along with me for free, the Ospreys still do the same now. These offers would have bumped our attendances up a fair bit, but that wasn't what the club were trying to do, they were trying to get the kids going along. We have all been there at some point, that time where you go to your first game, it's magic when you are a kid and you finally get to see your first proper game.
During the close season this year, the Swans were given planning permission to expand the stadium, I might be wrong but I think I remember that eventually it could reach 30,000+, but this wont be done in one go, the plan is, that once Premier League football is guaranteed for next season, work will start on adding 5,000 seats in the first instance. The main priority as stated by Huw Jenkins in the Summer is to get these offers for the schools and kids back up and running A.S.A.P. And I think that is spot on.
As things stand at this moment in time, our club is run by a board of directors who once stood on the North Bank at the Vetch, they understand what the fans go through and I for one am very grateful for them, the supporters trust and all the other parties who contributed along the way, our attendances at the moment = Sold Out, every single week as far as the home section goes, sadly people do miss out because the stadium isn't big enough for the demand.
Sorry for the rant... Right, our attendances at the Liberty since we moved there, up until promotion to the Prem will have been boosted by the offers that the club used to run for kids, schools etc. I admire the fact that the club ran these offers and admire even more, the fact that if expansion goes ahead, these offers returning is a priority for the board.
You have higher attendances than us, no arguments from me, and as far as I'm aware, you can upgrade your stadium with far less fuss than we have had to go through.
So, just in theory, lets say 5 years from now and both clubs were established in the Premier League, I would take a guess that we would average around 26-28,000 and you could probably add another 4,000 to that over a season, once the novelty had worn off, sound about right?
Fri Oct 05, 2012 2:13 am
Fri Oct 05, 2012 2:39 am
No Smoking wrote:You agree with him?
So all this nonsense for 4,000 fans.![]()
Like it or not, both clubs attendances are very similar if compared to when each club was at a similar level, both in league and length of time in that league in order to build the fan base.
It's clear they need a ground increase so we will then have a greater indication of the demand for tickets, but considering they have had 23 consecutive sellouts before even reaching general release it's hard to doubt it.
Fri Oct 05, 2012 2:51 am
SBF1 wrote:No Smoking wrote:You agree with him?
So all this nonsense for 4,000 fans.![]()
Like it or not, both clubs attendances are very similar if compared to when each club was at a similar level, both in league and length of time in that league in order to build the fan base.
It's clear they need a ground increase so we will then have a greater indication of the demand for tickets, but considering they have had 23 consecutive sellouts before even reaching general release it's hard to doubt it.
But when at the same level they are not!!
You just don't get it do you, even he is saying we get bigger crowds.![]()
Show me where over the last ten years they average more than us regardless of division...(apart from the year they had the new stadium)
2003/04 (Championship) - 15,569 Swansea 6,856
2004/05 (Championship) - 13,029 Swansea 8,458
2005/06 (Championship) - 11,802 Swansea 14,112 (new stadium syndrome)
2006/07 (Championship) - 15,224 Swansea 12,720
2007/08 (Championship) - 13,939 Swansea 12,993
08-09 Cardiff 17,474 Swansea 15,187 CHAMPIONSHIP
09-10 Cardiff 20,717 Swansea 15,407 CHAMPIONSHIP
10-11 Cardiff 23,194 Swansea 15,507 CHAMPIONSHIP
11-12 Cardiff 22,100 Swansea 19,946
ONCE AGAIN HERE IS THE LINK>>>>> http://stats.football365.com/
The answer is....THEY DON'T!!!
Frigging troll!![]()
Over last 9 seasons Cardiff total average 160,097 divided by 9 = 17,788
Over last 9 seasons Swansea total average 121,186 divided by 9 = 13,465
Not similar at all, averaging 4,000 more per game over nine years, that is a big difference.![]()
![]()
![]()
Fri Oct 05, 2012 7:50 am
Fri Oct 05, 2012 8:07 am
Fri Oct 05, 2012 9:15 am
scotsjack wrote:Right, I'm suffering a bout of insomnia here so I'll try and give you as honest an insight into how things developed at the Swans over the past decade...(It might help me sleep, who knows?)
As I'm sure you are all aware, around 10 years ago, we were on our arse, a consortium of local businessmen had managed to get the club back off Tony Petty, but there was no money left. The short reign of Tony Petty had a positive effect in that it galvanised the supporters, our downtrodden club was about to turn things around and the fans, who for too long had neglected the club started paying attention again.
With the money problems at the club, at the end of the 2002/03 season, we found ourselves needing to beat Hull to stay in the football league, end result, the match was sold out! We won that day and kept our place in the league, by now, the supporters trust was gaining momentum and we wouldn't look back, I can remember at the time, buckets being handed round the back of the North Bank raising money to pay the players wages, then the buckets went round again collecting money for "The battle for Britton" as the club raised the money for Leon Brittons transfer fee.
It was with this bleak backdrop and bottom division football that the Liberty Stadium was given the go-ahead by the council, a 20,500 all seater stadium! At the time, more than enough.
What nobody could have guessed at the time, the club, the fans, the council, or anybody else, was that 8 years later, we would be promoted to the Premier league! 8 years!!!
In the short time we have been at the Liberty, the club have always run offers, kids for a quid, offers to schools etc. My boy used to regularly come home from school with a form where I would pay something like £10 and I could take 2 kids along with me for free, the Ospreys still do the same now. These offers would have bumped our attendances up a fair bit, but that wasn't what the club were trying to do, they were trying to get the kids going along. We have all been there at some point, that time where you go to your first game, it's magic when you are a kid and you finally get to see your first proper game.
During the close season this year, the Swans were given planning permission to expand the stadium, I might be wrong but I think I remember that eventually it could reach 30,000+, but this wont be done in one go, the plan is, that once Premier League football is guaranteed for next season, work will start on adding 5,000 seats in the first instance. The main priority as stated by Huw Jenkins in the Summer is to get these offers for the schools and kids back up and running A.S.A.P. And I think that is spot on.
As things stand at this moment in time, our club is run by a board of directors who once stood on the North Bank at the Vetch, they understand what the fans go through and I for one am very grateful for them, the supporters trust and all the other parties who contributed along the way, our attendances at the moment = Sold Out, every single week as far as the home section goes, sadly people do miss out because the stadium isn't big enough for the demand.
Sorry for the rant... Right, our attendances at the Liberty since we moved there, up until promotion to the Prem will have been boosted by the offers that the club used to run for kids, schools etc. I admire the fact that the club ran these offers and admire even more, the fact that if expansion goes ahead, these offers returning is a priority for the board.
You have higher attendances than us, no arguments from me, and as far as I'm aware, you can upgrade your stadium with far less fuss than we have had to go through.
So, just in theory, lets say 5 years from now and both clubs were established in the Premier League, I would take a guess that we would average around 26-28,000 and you could probably add another 4,000 to that over a season, once the novelty had worn off, sound about right?
Fri Oct 05, 2012 9:22 am
scotsjack wrote:Carpe Diem wrote:scotsjack wrote:I actually signed up to this forum to reply to this topic:-
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=33315
Regarding the Swans attendances at the time, there were a couple of digs about the economy playing a part at the time but I see it on threads here regarding yourselves these days. And I stand by the Sousa comments, absolute dirge being served up week in week out... Absolute sh*te!
Out of interest where is Sousa now?
Some team in Hungary I think? No idea tbh, he didn't even have the decency to hang around at Leicester long enough for us to play against him once he left
Fri Oct 05, 2012 11:14 am
cf63bluebirds wrote:Adam Morgan continuing this charade I see! Amazing what a bit of digging brings up...