Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

What is your formation & starting XI??

Sun Aug 26, 2012 12:58 pm

What would your formation and starting XI be if it was your choice??? And what sort of tactics would you go for?

Re: What is your formation & starting XI??

Sun Aug 26, 2012 1:06 pm

Marshal
mcnaughton turner hudson taylor or connelly
Gunnerson
Kimbo Whitts Bellamy

Mason Velikonja

Re: What is your formation & starting XI??

Sun Aug 26, 2012 1:12 pm

I would go for a 4-3-3 at home which reverts to a 4-5-1 when away.
Starting XI;

GK: Marshall

RB: Mcnaughton
CB: Hudson
CB: Turner
LB. Connolly

DM: Mcphail
CM: Whittingham
AM: Mason

RM: Kim
LM: Bellamy

ST: Helguson/Vilakonja

Sub;
Lewis
Taylor
Mutch
Gunnarson
Cowie
Helguson/Vilakonja
Smith

Re: What is your formation & starting XI??

Sun Aug 26, 2012 1:22 pm

4-5-1 for me
or maybe 4-4-1-1 Im still undecided on our best team myself, mainly because I havent seen enough of the newer players.
or even 4-2-3-1

In realist during a game all those formations boil down to the 4-5-1 and I like the formation just not the way the team is set up to play it at the moment. Certain players need to be allowed more freedom in games to join up with Helguson.

Re: What is your formation & starting XI??

Sun Aug 26, 2012 1:26 pm

Image

although if we could keep possession better I wouldn't mind seeing us be a little more unorthodox with something like

Image

But that won't happen.

Re: What is your formation & starting XI??

Sun Aug 26, 2012 1:28 pm

..............................................................MARSHALL...........................................................
McNAUGHTON................HUDSON..............................................TURNER...........................TAYLOR
.
.
.
.
.
.CONWAY.........................MUTCH.........................GUNNERSON...........................................BELLAMY
.
.
.
..............................................................WHITTINGHAM..........................................................
.
.
...............................................................MASON................................................................

Liked the look of Smith yesterday as well so would have him on the bench or would swap with Mason.

Re: What is your formation & starting XI??

Sun Aug 26, 2012 2:05 pm

4-1-2-1-2/ 4-1-3-2 more focus on attack than defense.( time to cash in on whitts IMO he's run his course with us)

marshall

mcnaughton turner hudson connelly/taylor

gunnerson

smith bellamy
kimbo

mason helguson

subs-lewis,connelly/taylor,cowie,mutch,conway,earnshaw,velikonja :ayatollah:

Re: What is your formation & starting XI??

Sun Aug 26, 2012 2:08 pm

4-1-2-3

Marshall
a new right back, Hudson, Turner, a new left back
Kiss
Whitts, Kimbo,
Bellamy, Mason, Smith

Re: What is your formation & starting XI??

Sun Aug 26, 2012 2:12 pm

I did say my team v Wolves would be

Marshall
Kev
Turner
Hudson
Taylor

Smith
Gunnarrson
Kiss
Witts

Bellamy

Helguson



another options would be
-------------------------Marshall
-----------Kev ----Hudson ----Turner-----Taylor
----------------------Gunnar Kiss
----------Kim ----------Witts -----------Smith
-------------------------Bellamy

Re: What is your formation & starting XI??

Sun Aug 26, 2012 2:30 pm

Formation: 4-1-2-1-2

GK: David Marshall
RB: Kevin McNaughton
CB: Mark Hudson
CB: Ben Turner
LB: Andrew Taylor
CDM: Aron Gunnarsson
RW: Kim Bo-Kyung
LW: Craig Bellamy
CAM: Peter Whittingham
ST: Tommy Smith
ST: Heidar Helguson

Subs: Joe Lewis, Matt Connolly, Don Cowie, Craig Conway, Jordon Mutch, Joe Mason, Etien Velikonja

Re: What is your formation & starting XI??

Sun Aug 26, 2012 4:22 pm

Marshall

Kev Hudson Turner Taylor

Smith Gunnar Whitts Kim

Bellamy Mason

Subs: Lewis Connolly Kiss Cowie Mutch Helguson Velikonja

If Malky deems that Kimbo should be eased into first team action via the bench I'd put Bellamy on the left and Velikonja up front with Mason. :ayatollah:

Re: What is your formation & starting XI??

Sun Aug 26, 2012 4:28 pm

--------------Marshall-------------

Kev---Hudson----Turner---taylor-

-------Gunnar---------Mutch------

--------------Whitts-------------

--Kim Bo--------------------Bellamy

----------------Velikonja-----------

If we get a new striker this week change for Velikonja..

Re: What is your formation & starting XI??

Sun Aug 26, 2012 5:01 pm

RFMH wrote:Image

although if we could keep possession better I wouldn't mind seeing us be a little more unorthodox with something like

Image

But that won't happen.

whitts out of position.... :?

Re: What is your formation & starting XI??

Mon Aug 27, 2012 9:43 am

......................................MARSHALL


.............................TURNER.............HUDSON


MCNAUGHTON........................................................CONNOLLY


............................GUNNARSSON..........MUTCH

KIM BO SLICE...........................................................BELLAMY


...........................VELIKONJA................MASON


Andrew Taylor seems to be getting done too often at left back. I'd give Whitts a rest to be honest.
perhaps? we need a more high tempo approach. Gunnarsson and Mutch will give us energy in the
middle of midfield and nobody will give us the run around. Bellamy and Kim Bo are self explanatory.
I think Velikonja and Mason (like the two lads in the centre of the park) will give us lots of movement.
Etien looks a good prospect and full of energy, will keep the opposition defence busy. Joe, i truly think
is the man who will get us goals this season. There is a lot of pace and most important of all, movement in
this line-up

Re: What is your formation & starting XI??

Mon Aug 27, 2012 9:46 am

vikinblue wrote:
RFMH wrote:Image

although if we could keep possession better I wouldn't mind seeing us be a little more unorthodox with something like

Image

But that won't happen.

whitts out of position.... :?


Whitts played deeper in midfield last season. Remind me who our top scorer was?

Two managers in a row have utilised him there which is enough. The problem is lack of form. Which some people seem to think means we should sell him...

Re: What is your formation & starting XI??

Mon Aug 27, 2012 10:49 am

..............................................................MARSHALL...........................................................
McNAUGHTON................HUDSON..............................................TURNER...........................TAYLOR
.
.
.
.
.
.SMITH.........................MUTCH.........................GUNNERSON......................................WHITTINGHAM.....
.
.
.
........................................................................................................................
.
.
.............................................BELLAMY..................MASON................

Re: What is your formation & starting XI??

Mon Aug 27, 2012 5:33 pm

......................................Marshall..................................

Cowie...............Hudson.......................Turner...............Kiss


.....................Gunnarsson...................Mutch....................


Kim Bo................................................................Bellamy

.....................Velikonja.................Mason.........................



Subs: Lewis, Whittingham, Connolly, Smith, Conway, Helguson, Gestede



Ideally I would have selected Whitts instead of Mutch in the middle, but his performances this season so far have been lackluster, he cannot tackle and gives possession away too easily. No one player is too good to start on the bench for a couple of games. May give him the kick up the arse he needs.