If we went in for one of them again, who would you prefer...

Who would you prefer to see here if Malky bid for one of them this summer?

craig noone

Craig Noone

If by bid you mean we're guaranteed to get them then I'd have to definitely say Phillips.


In reality though Noone is far more likely.

If we were guaranteed only 1 of them it would have to be Matt Phillips

Phillips over Noone for me,but what i don't understand is -

If we have this money,then why does'nt MM go and put in a bid and match what Bolton paid for SORDELL

Phillips over Noone for me,but what i don't understand is -

If we have this money,then why does'nt MM go and put in a bid and match what Bolton paid for SORDELL

God knows but i'm guessing with Bolton being relegated and Sordell having 3 years left on his contract there, I think he will be playing a lot more if not every game.

Matty Phillips every day. At least then he wouldn't be able to tear us apart twice a year

Phillips over Noone for me,but what i don't understand is -

If we have this money,then why does'nt MM go and put in a bid and match what Bolton paid for SORDELL

God knows but i'm guessing with Bolton being relegated and Sordell having 3 years left on his contract there, I think he will be playing a lot more if not every game.

I Can't recall him starting much last season for Bolton,but that's a good point you have made rhys with him starting more games in the championship - Apart from the money,i bet he never thought he would end up back in the same division

Phillips over Noone for me,but what i don't understand is -

If we have this money,then why does'nt MM go and put in a bid and match what Bolton paid for SORDELL

God knows but i'm guessing with Bolton being relegated and Sordell having 3 years left on his contract there, I think he will be playing a lot more if not every game.

I Can't recall him starting much last season for Bolton,but that's a good point you have made rhys with him starting more games in the championship - Apart from the money,i bet he never thought he would end up back in the same division

He only played 3 league games for Bolton, and I don't think he started any of them. Waste of a talent.

Happy we didnt sign Sordell a waste. We have Miller and Earnshaw. Suprised we didnt go for a target man in January.

Happy we didnt sign Sordell a waste. We have Miller and Earnshaw. Suprised we didnt go for a target man in January.

You would pick Miller and Earnie over Marvin Sordell?

Last edited by rhys1927ccfc on Wed Jun 27, 2012 11:34 pm, edited 1 time in total.

At the time we had them 2. Never said I wouldnt have Sordell. We needed a target man then not him.

At the time we had them 2. Never said I wouldnt have Sordell. We needed a target man then not him.

2 things we need, a target man who can hold the ball up well and a goal machine.

Last edited by rhys1927ccfc on Wed Jun 27, 2012 11:36 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Fuller done it for stoke?

Fuller done it for stoke?

The year Stoke went up he was outstanding, would take him here with open arms, bags of experience

I was on about back then. In Janaury when we was linked. Miller was doing good in January to be fair.