Who do you think is the most underrated and overrated

Cardiff players.

Id say super kev overrated

And Conway underrated (created a lot of goals for us when he has played)

Defo super kev. Passing and positional play are diabolical.
Under rated mcphail

Over....superkev, but to be fair he does he think he can shag everyone's missus

Under......in my eyes Earnie, and yeah conway

Over - Whitts
Under - Conway

Overated McNaughton, Ben Turner, Steve McPhail

Underated Don Cowie, Craig Conway, Filip Kiss

Overated - based on last years performance - McNaughton, Miller.

Underated - Conway, Ralls.

Over - Miller, Cowie and Miller again!

Under - Darcy Blake

over- gestede by a country mile
under- conway and maybe kiss

overrated - gunnarsson
underrated - Whittingham perhaps. Those who slate him have no idea how instrumental he is. Alternatively, Miller or Blake

Cardiff players.

Id say super kev overrated

And Conway underrated (created a lot of goals for us when he has played)

Underrated DEFINITELY Super Kev - because of the fact that his passing isn't the greatest, people seem to be blind to the fact that he is the best damn defender we've had at this club in years! the amount of goals he saves us with last-ditch challenges and clearances is unreal! and he never, NEVER gets taken on down his side! i do go on about this alot because i feel so passionately about it, and yeah i agree that he can't pass, but you won't find anybody that can defend as well as him at this level

Most overrated, i would have to go for Craig Conway i think... i just don't think he's good enough for this level unfortunately, in comparison to somebody like Chris Burke, but he does work hard to be fair to him

Cardiff players.

Id say super kev overrated

And Conway underrated (created a lot of goals for us when he has played)

Underrated DEFINITELY Super Kev - because of the fact that his passing isn't the greatest, people seem to be blind to the fact that he is the best damn defender we've had at this club in years! the amount of goals he saves us with last-ditch challenges and clearances is unreal! and he never, NEVER gets taken on down his side! i do go on about this alot because i feel so passionately about it, and yeah i agree that he can't pass, but you won't find anybody that can defend as well as him at this level

Most overrated, i would have to go for Craig Conway i think... i just don't think he's good enough for this level unfortunately, in comparison to somebody like Chris Burke, but he does work hard to be fair to him

Think you got all that arse backwards fella!

As much as I love Super Kev he is very over rated at times. His distribution is absolute shait at times. I don't really know how he got into the Championship Team of the Season. He is a club legend though and does a lot of other super stuff on the pitch.

Under rated? Possibly a fit Steve McPhail, the guy used to get a lot of stick but when he plays he gives Whitts a lot more time. Also I would honestly say Miller, yes he needs to score more, but it isn't easy playing upfront on your tod and the work rate he gets through is immense.

Overrated- Cowie. He charges around the pitch a lot- big deal that should be the minimum expected of a professional midfielder. Can't beat a man, doesn't score enough and goes sideways or backwards far too often.
If we have genuine expectations of going up this season Malky needs to drop his blue eyes. A master of no trades.

Underrated- Conway. Not quick quick but a fantastic crosser with both feet. A genuine targetman would have a field day with his delivery if he is on song. Confidence player, can't believe how many more games Cowie played wide when Conway was benched.

SUPER KEV OVER
WHITTS UNDER

over MILLER
under TURNER
most undapreciated considering what he's done for the club EARNIE

Over- miller, gestede
Under- darcy and mcphail,

Cardiff players.

Id say super kev overrated

And Conway underrated (created a lot of goals for us when he has played)

Underrated DEFINITELY Super Kev - because of the fact that his passing isn't the greatest, people seem to be blind to the fact that he is the best damn defender we've had at this club in years! the amount of goals he saves us with last-ditch challenges and clearances is unreal! and he never, NEVER gets taken on down his side! i do go on about this alot because i feel so passionately about it, and yeah i agree that he can't pass, but you won't find anybody that can defend as well as him at this level

Most overrated, i would have to go for Craig Conway i think... i just don't think he's good enough for this level unfortunately, in comparison to somebody like Chris Burke, but he does work hard to be fair to him

i genuinely didnt even notice i'd done the opposite of you

Over- Whitts
under- Cowie

Underrated - McPhail (although not so much last season)
Overrated - Earnshaw (if people still rate him)

Overrated - Andrew Taylor - Alot of our goals seem to come from his side.

Underrated - Darcy Blake - I'd have McNaughton at LB and Darcy at RB. The kid deserves a chance to show what he can do.

Over-rated McPhail by a country mile. Yes he has the nice flicks but is so easily beaten by opponents and simply cannot compete in midfield because he is so slow. He also cowardly shit out of tackles in both of our final home games in the regular season.

Under-rated Darcy Blake (the best centre-half at the club) and Andrew Taylor who has had to operate on the left-hand side alone for most of the season due to us playing so narrow.

Over-rated McPhail by a country mile. Yes he has the nice flicks but is so easily beaten by opponents and simply cannot compete in midfield because he is so slow. He also cowardly shit out of tackles in both of our final home games in the regular season.

Under-rated Darcy Blake (the best centre-half at the club) and Andrew Taylor who has had to operate on the left-hand side alone for most of the season due to us playing so narrow.

I'm starting to think your just not a mcphail fan

Over-rated McPhail by a country mile. Yes he has the nice flicks but is so easily beaten by opponents and simply cannot compete in midfield because he is so slow. He also cowardly shit out of tackles in both of our final home games in the regular season.

Under-rated Darcy Blake (the best centre-half at the club) and Andrew Taylor who has had to operate on the left-hand side alone for most of the season due to us playing so narrow.

I'm starting to think your just not a mcphail fan

He hates mcphail as much as I can't stand Gerrard!

Overrated - Gerrard.

Overrated - Gerrard.

Overrated - Miller and Gestede
Underrated - Conway

Overrated - Gerrard.

Overrated - Gerrard.

Someone's got to rate him for him to be overrated

Over - Hudson

Under - Darcy

Overrated - Gerrard.

Overrated - Gerrard.

Someone's got to rate him for him to be overrated

Hmmmm, wonder who that was? Even Hull wanted him to f**k off! so It couldn't have been them? I'm stumped now!

Over - Mcnaughton this season

Under - Blake, Conway, Keinan (always gives 100% and deserves first team football)

Over - Whitts, Turner, Gerrard, Miller, Earnie, Cowie, Conway, Gestede, Mcphail, Ralls, Mason and Mcnaughton

Under - Gunnerson