Malky has not played Earnie because.............

Could people please give me some theories on why Earnie has had no game time, because I haven't got a jar of glue.

People have been saying he is moving on to Shefeild Wednesday, and somebody else is coming in. This would be great as we are currently spunking £13,000 a week up the wall!

Based on what I have seen hes got the minerals to do a job for us, especially as he came on as captain and had a goal disallowed in the Wales v Costa Rica Tribute game recently. It seems pretty obvious he should have had a run out by now, fans can see he deserves a chance and have been screaming for it.

Miller hasnt scored since the Israelites were made to work as slaves, so for fecks sake whats going on? Looks like a new striker may be coming in on loan but why has he not played him? Theories below please.........

Earnie is selfish, no first touch, lost his pace, not a team player.

Any more?

Earnie is selfish, no first touch, lost his pace, not a team player.

Any more?

hes better than rudy. FACT.

Why the hell did we sign him if he is not good enough for the bench?

I cant see why if he has played selfishly that he couldn't be disciplined by being dropped for a couple of games, or things couldn't be looked at in training. Surly its Malkies job to get the best out of his players, not get nothing at all?

I agree with what your saying but I cant see that is enough on its own. He should still have been given more of a chance than he has been given, something not right about the situation.

Because maybe they are trying to force him out by pissing him off by not playing him?? £13000 a week is a decent amount to free up every week but earnie ain't complaining because he knows his next wage will be half that amount at most

He needs to try Earnie - MM is stubourn and proves points to the detriment of the team in my opinion

He needs to try Earnie - MM is stubourn and proves points to the detriment of the team in my opinion

FACT

I heard recently before the match this weekend there was training session cardiff A v cardiff B. the final score was 8-3 to the B team and earnie scored all 8 goals don't know how true this is.

Earnie played selfishly for us for YEARS! And became the clubs greatest ever striker? He deserves a chance definitely, but it seems there's more to this than meets the eye?

Earnie is selfish, no first touch, lost his pace, not a team player.

Any more?

hes better than rudy. FACT.

Parkin is better than Rudy.

Rudy will become better than Parkin I feel but at the moment Parkin is better.

Couple of points, firstly i agree earnie should be on the bench,he looked lively and did well against West Brom,scored and set up a goal
secondly i dont think malky is stubborn at all,hes open to new ideas and formations, how well is earnie doing in training? none of us on here can give that answer
thirdly, rudy is a squad player,not quite good enough to play week in ,week out but comparing him to parkin ,who was out of shape and lazy for the duration he was here is a bit harsh

Earnie is selfish, no first touch, lost his pace, not a team player.

Any more?

How do you know that - he hasnt played! ( and bear in mind 'King Kenny' couldn't score in a brothel ).

Earnie is selfish, no first touch, lost his pace, not a team player.

Any more?

How do you know that - he hasnt played! ( and bear in mind 'King Kenny' couldn't score in a brothel ).

Correct me if im wrong, although im not.....he began the season alongside miller......he was f*cking woeful.

Why the hell did we sign him if he is not good enough for the bench?

I cant see why if he has played selfishly that he couldn't be disciplined by being dropped for a couple of games, or things couldn't be looked at in training. Surly its Malkies job to get the best out of his players, not get nothing at all?

I agree with what your saying but I cant see that is enough on its own. He should still have been given more of a chance than he has been given, something not right about the situation.

Earnshaw was good enough to play for a decent notts forest side and finish 3rd in the table or 6th , its obvious he does a job at championship and he'd do better than gestede

Couple of points, firstly i agree earnie should be on the bench,he looked lively and did well against West Brom,scored and set up a goal
secondly i dont think malky is stubborn at all,hes open to new ideas and formations, how well is earnie doing in training? none of us on here can give that answer
thirdly, rudy is a squad player,not quite good enough to play week in ,week out but comparing him to parkin ,who was out of shape and lazy for the duration he was here is a bit harsh

He's big boned. Always been like that. I do not think that Gestede could score a goal like the one Parkin scored against Norwich on his debut.

Should have been kept around just as a back up.

maybe because hes welsh and welsh players dont get into the cardiff squad, maybe the goal against west brom ruined his chances (sarcasm) maybe because hes a passionate cardiff fan and loves the club

Earnie has had 10 starts and 2 as a sub. Scored 4 goals even though he has been taken off for the majority of the matches. As it happens he has a better strike rate than Miller or Rudy. He at least deserved a chance in our current dip in form.

Earnie has had 10 starts and 2 as a sub. Scored 4 goals even though he has been taken off for the majority of the matches. As it happens he has a better strike rate than Miller or Rudy. He at least deserved a chance in our current dip in form.

FACT

He needs to try Earnie - MM is stubourn and proves points to the detriment of the team in my opinion

FACT

AGREED

Malky has not played Earnie because..........
Earnie was signed by SB and that prat gethin jenkins two weeks before MM even come to us

Malky has not played Earnie because..........
Earnie was signed by SB and that prat gethin jenkins two weeks before MM even come to us

wrong

signed 3 weeks AFTER Malky become boss but dont let the facts get in the way dumbo

Malky has not played Earnie because..........
Earnie was signed by SB and that prat gethin jenkins two weeks before MM even come to us

wrong

signed 3 weeks AFTER Malky become boss but dont let the facts get in the way dumbo

I suggest you double check polo because earnie had agreed a pre contract before MM was here thats a cert, ive been out with him on nights out so see him on a reg basis, but do not let facts get in the way

friend to the stars

:lol: friend to the stars

No craig not really its callled living close and the same group friends you should try getting some it might help you in life or maybe your social skills even who knows

Malky joined on 17th June,Earnie signed on 6th July.If there were talks before this and Malky didn't want him he had the chance to call the deal off.

:lol: friend to the stars

No craig not really its callled living close and the same group friends you should try getting some it might help you in life or maybe your social skills even who knows

My social skills are fine, just dont use them towards you because you're a prat.

Malky has not played Earnie because..........
Earnie was signed by SB and that prat gethin jenkins two weeks before MM even come to us

wrong

signed 3 weeks AFTER Malky become boss but dont let the facts get in the way dumbo

I suggest you double check polo because earnie had agreed a pre contract before MM was here thats a cert, ive been out with him on nights out so see him on a reg basis, but do not let facts get in the way

I dont think earnie hangs around the gordon lennox butt

:lol: friend to the stars

No craig not really its callled living close and the same group friends you should try getting some it might help you in life or maybe your social skills even who knows

That explains why he isnt in the squad then. Malkys found out hes been sniffing glue with a load of dead beats.

Malky has not played Earnie because..........
Earnie was signed by SB and that prat gethin jenkins two weeks before MM even come to us

wrong

signed 3 weeks AFTER Malky become boss but dont let the facts get in the way dumbo

I dont think Malky had any say about Earnie joining, once the Bellamy deal never happened the board was allways going to sign Earnie to keep the fans happy, thats my opinion on it

so if miller and earnie did not work when played together and miller is not working now how come miller is not droped and earnie given a chance imo miller is the problem how much he on a week probably at least as much as earnie but probably more and he cost 850k earnie was free now do the maths and see who is the best value