Cardiff City's Best 5 Players

Cardiff City: Class of 2012

http://wp.me/p1kRcy-7U

I've assessed who our best players are ability wise, and also reviewed all our other players' performances this season. Obviously we all have our own opinions on who's our best players but hopefully you will agree with mine. Sorry that it's so long, but I just thought I'd put a lot of effort into this one seeing as Dudders is becoming so good lately!

Thanks for reading.

Interesting stuff. You put across a good argument for your choice.

For me, I'd say...

1. Peter Whittingham
2. Kenny Miller
3. Don Cowie
4. Ben Turner
5. Andrew Taylor

I feel Whittingham will be number 1 for everyone. Kenny Miller's goals and work rate up top have been second to none since we moved to the 4-5-1. Don Cowie covers every blade of grass and is just pure quality. Turner has definitely made a difference at the back and Taylor has made sure that a rejuvenated Naylor hasn't had a sniff which shows how solid that left side is now.

Interesting stuff. You put across a good argument for your choice.

For me, I'd say...

1. Peter Whittingham
2. Kenny Miller
3. Don Cowie
4. Ben Turner
5. Andrew Taylor

I feel Whittingham will be number 1 for everyone. Kenny Miller's goals and work rate up top have been second to none since we moved to the 4-5-1. Don Cowie covers every blade of grass and is just pure quality. Turner has definitely made a difference at the back and Taylor has made sure that a rejuvenated Naylor hasn't had a sniff which shows how solid that left side is now.

i would put gunnarson in there not sure where though probally for taylor maybe

Whitts
Miller
Gunnar
Cowie
Turner

Interesting stuff. You put across a good argument for your choice.

For me, I'd say...

1. Peter Whittingham
2. Kenny Miller
3. Don Cowie
4. Ben Turner
5. Andrew Taylor

I feel Whittingham will be number 1 for everyone. Kenny Miller's goals and work rate up top have been second to none since we moved to the 4-5-1. Don Cowie covers every blade of grass and is just pure quality. Turner has definitely made a difference at the back and Taylor has made sure that a rejuvenated Naylor hasn't had a sniff which shows how solid that left side is now.

i would put gunnarson in there not sure where though probally for taylor maybe

Yeah, I can understand that. My opinion is biased as a left back myself!

1. Aron Gunnarsson
2. Peter Whittingham
3. Kenny Miller
4. Don Cowie
5. David Marshall (Saves against West Ham and Leeds Utd )
6. Joe Mason
7. Rudy Gestede

Taylor's been great. I think including him in your top 5 isn't that outlandish.

I cannot believe nobody has mentioned Kevin McNaughton, would defo be in my list!

I cannot believe nobody has mentioned Kevin McNaughton, would defo be in my list!

His distribution has been close to dire this season. Great in every other aspect, though.

miller
whitts
cowie
turner
marshall

i wanted to put gurnarsson too, but i think marshall deserves a special mention after so many city fans write him off and said we need a new keeper

1. Whittingham
2. Miller
3. Cowie
4. Turner
5. Gunnarsson
6. Hudson

Good Read Well Done

Whitts
Hudson
Gunnarsson
miller
cowie/mason

Good read
1. Whitts
2. Gunnarsson
3. Miller
4. Cowie
5. Marshall
-----------------
6. McNaughton/ Turner/ Taylor/ Hudson