Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

POLO - GESTEDE

Sat Dec 31, 2011 4:56 pm

New Eddie is he???

Oh dearie dearie me, fickle fan.

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sat Dec 31, 2011 4:57 pm

Can we loan him out?

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sat Dec 31, 2011 5:06 pm

Why? What has he done exactly? Scored a hat trick?

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sat Dec 31, 2011 5:07 pm

polo wrote:Why? What has he done exactly? Scored a hat trick?

He had a great game today. All he got was praise

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sat Dec 31, 2011 5:09 pm

CantonJack wrote:
polo wrote:Why? What has he done exactly? Scored a hat trick?

He had a great game today. All he got was praise

I must have snoozed off cos 1st half it was all forest

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sat Dec 31, 2011 5:10 pm

polo wrote:
CantonJack wrote:
polo wrote:Why? What has he done exactly? Scored a hat trick?

He had a great game today. All he got was praise

I must have snoozed off cos 1st half it was all forest


Radio Wales said he was the only stand out player the first half?

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sat Dec 31, 2011 5:13 pm

On the bus on the way home from the game now and Rudy was the best player out there. He chased every ball, won his headers in the air and was very unlcuky not to get a goal. How you can comment on him when you didn't see the game is beyond me.

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sat Dec 31, 2011 5:31 pm

CCFC1990 wrote:On the bus on the way home from the game now and Rudy was the best player out there. He chased every ball, won his headers in the air and was very unlcuky not to get a goal. How you can comment on him when you didn't see the game is beyond me.

I havent commented anything based on todays game cos i wadnt there.

I will form my own opinions based on what i see myself not what i hear on the radio or read on a messageboard.

If rudy proves me wrong then great.

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sat Dec 31, 2011 5:39 pm

Reading that thread again unbelievable what him and Midfield General are saying, can't stand when people make judgements over no real knowledge.

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sat Dec 31, 2011 6:05 pm

CCFC 24 wrote:Reading that thread again unbelievable what him and Midfield General are saying, can't stand when people make judgements over no real knowledge.

Oh boo f*cking hoo we have a difference of opinion

just enjoy the win you f*cking bertie :roll:

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sat Dec 31, 2011 6:06 pm

polo wrote:
CCFC1990 wrote:On the bus on the way home from the game now and Rudy was the best player out there. He chased every ball, won his headers in the air and was very unlcuky not to get a goal. How you can comment on him when you didn't see the game is beyond me.

I havent commented anything based on todays game cos i wadnt there.

I will form my own opinions based on what i see myself not what i hear on the radio or read on a messageboard.

If rudy proves me wrong then great.


So a player is only good if he is good when you decide to go to games? :shock:

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sat Dec 31, 2011 6:13 pm

2blue2handle wrote:
polo wrote:
CCFC1990 wrote:On the bus on the way home from the game now and Rudy was the best player out there. He chased every ball, won his headers in the air and was very unlcuky not to get a goal. How you can comment on him when you didn't see the game is beyond me.

I havent commented anything based on todays game cos i wadnt there.

I will form my own opinions based on what i see myself not what i hear on the radio or read on a messageboard.

If rudy proves me wrong then great.


So a player is only good if he is good when you decide to go to games? :shock:

No ill only form MY opinion with what I see with MY own eyes

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sun Jan 01, 2012 2:05 am

polo wrote:
CantonJack wrote:
polo wrote:Why? What has he done exactly? Scored a hat trick?

He had a great game today. All he got was praise

I must have snoozed off cos 1st half it was all forest





you need to turn your radio UP then, Polo :lol:

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sun Jan 01, 2012 3:20 am

One good game doesn't make him a superstar, today and the set up for miller against west ham only things stands out for him, he's new and needs time and hopefully he can produce what he did today time and time again

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sun Jan 01, 2012 3:27 am

citybluechris wrote:One good game doesn't make him a superstar, today and the set up for miller against west ham only things stands out for him, he's new and needs time and hopefully he can produce what he did today time and time again


And his excellent performce and brilliant goal against Leicester that kept us in the carling cup????
A lot more positives than negatives but it's why we it's hard to bring people through at city as people would rather focus on his poor two sub appearances after coming bk from injury than all the good work.
It's not as if it's hard to believe a person coming from second division France on a free is the complete striker is it :roll:

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sun Jan 01, 2012 3:27 am

citybluechris wrote:One good game doesn't make him a superstar, today and the set up for miller against west ham only things stands out for him, he's new and needs time and hopefully he can produce what he did today time and time again


And his excellent performce and brilliant goal against Leicester that kept us in the carling cup????
A lot more positives than negatives but it's why we it's hard to bring people through at city as people would rather focus on his poor two sub appearances after coming bk from injury than all the good work.
It's not as if it's hard to believe a person coming from second division France on a free is the complete striker is it :roll:

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sun Jan 01, 2012 8:45 am

So pleased for rudy yesterday,won everything in the air and worked his arse off,all this while the forest players were kicking the crap out of him,usually directly in front of the referee
Did he whinge or complain though? no he worked even harder..French players have a reputation for being faeries but rudy is a tough cookie and tremendous battler-EXACTLY THE TYPE OF PLAYER WE NEED AT CARDIFF

Everyones entitled to their opinion but posts that crop up slating our players after one bad performance are pretty poor,miller-what a waste of money, rudy out on loan etc

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sun Jan 01, 2012 1:06 pm

It wasnt me who suggested he go out on loan :roll:

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sun Jan 01, 2012 2:04 pm

He has had a couple of bad performances when he didn't play the full match and I don't think full fitness after injury. Then people are saying to loan him out, why?! And loads of people were saying how good he is before his 2 bad games. This is the type of player we need strong, pacey and wins everything in the air! He was awesome yesterday, always caused problems and looked dangerous when he had the ball! And was there defend when needed to. Rudy, Rudy!! :ayatollah:

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sun Jan 01, 2012 3:46 pm

great, lets all slate polo because he has an opinion thats different from the "majority"

polo how dare you post an opinion on here.

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sun Jan 01, 2012 11:05 pm

2blue2handle wrote:
citybluechris wrote:One good game doesn't make him a superstar, today and the set up for miller against west ham only things stands out for him, he's new and needs time and hopefully he can produce what he did today time and time again


And his excellent performce and brilliant goal against Leicester that kept us in the carling cup????
A lot more positives than negatives but it's why we it's hard to bring people through at city as people would rather focus on his poor two sub appearances after coming bk from injury than all the good work.
It's not as if it's hard to believe a person coming from second division France on a free is the complete striker is it :roll:


^^^ This.

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Sun Jan 01, 2012 11:19 pm

He is big, raw and awkward, gives everything and is only going to get better. I bet there aren't many centre half's looking forward to play against him. I don't think he will be prolific, but he will free up space for the other lads. :old:

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Mon Jan 02, 2012 10:34 am

polo wrote:Why? What has he done exactly? Scored a hat trick?

Give the guy a chance! He's done great and has shown quality so far this year. English football is a big step from French football. He has had scenes of pure quality this year. Remember, without him, we wouldn't have beaten West Ham, would have lost to Leicester in the Carling Cup and would have lost to Ipswich. Give him more time to settle in more then he'll shine even more

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Mon Jan 02, 2012 12:23 pm

The games I saw rudy play he played we. West Ham for example. Great signing. :ayatollah:

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Mon Jan 02, 2012 1:06 pm

ok i really dont see what the fuss is about rudy
everyone goes on about how class he is, like the west ham game hahaha shows how little people watch the game, he had an assist and if you watch it carefully he didnt even pass it accurately
he was shocking against boro and did nothing much better at watford
i didnt go to forest but people should have their OWN opinions, judging on what ive seen hes nothing special
MY opinion

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Mon Jan 02, 2012 1:10 pm

bluebirdtom16 wrote:ok i really dont see what the fuss is about rudy
everyone goes on about how class he is, like the west ham game hahaha shows how little people watch the game, he had an assist and if you watch it carefully he didnt even pass it accurately
he was shocking against boro and did nothing much better at watford
i didnt go to forest but people should have their OWN opinions, judging on what ive seen hes nothing special
MY opinion


Each to their own.

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Mon Jan 02, 2012 1:25 pm

Each to their own.


definitely mate :ayatollah:

Re: POLO - GESTEDE

Mon Jan 02, 2012 7:06 pm

bluebirdtom16 wrote:ok i really dont see what the fuss is about rudy
everyone goes on about how class he is, like the west ham game hahaha shows how little people watch the game, he had an assist and if you watch it carefully he didnt even pass it accurately
he was shocking against boro and did nothing much better at watford
i didnt go to forest but people should have their OWN opinions, judging on what ive seen hes nothing special
MY opinion


He passed it to whitts WHU game...kenny just nicked it :lol: