Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 3:39 pm

a jack i spoke to reckons he heard we could be interested in him?
im not claiming anything just wondered if anyone else has heard something?

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 3:43 pm

Stephen dobbie. would welcome him. cracking footballer.

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 3:49 pm

polo wrote:Stephen dobbie. would welcome him. cracking footballer.


ok then stephen dobbie :lol: shows how much attention i pay to the twats down the road :ayatollah:

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 3:50 pm

jinks-rct wrote:a jack i spoke to reckons he heard we could be interested in him?
im not claiming anything just wondered if anyone else has heard something?


Apparently joining the Wurzels, not sure if it will be a loan or permanent move.

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 3:50 pm

Always like him even though he has plays for them down west, I for one would welcome hom here.He could play in the hole behind miller or alongside him. :ayatollah: :ayatollah:

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 4:11 pm

Just shows what a tw*t jones was letting Ross go for practically nothing.
That we could be looking at a similar player.

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 5:33 pm

He's a fat lazy c**t, overated in my opinion.

Dobie is also shit for what it's worth.

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 5:47 pm

Honestly don't know why people rave about Dobbie.

Loaned out by Jacks, Blackpool got promoted with him, sure, but he was overwhelmingly a sub.

Not been a regular for the Jacks.

If you want someone playing in the hole, why clamour for an average player when we've got Mason who can do that well plus has more upside?

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 5:50 pm

nerd wrote:Honestly don't know why people rave about Dobbie.

Loaned out by Jacks, Blackpool got promoted with him, sure, but he was overwhelmingly a sub.

Not been a regular for the Jacks.

If you want someone playing in the hole, why clamour for an average player when we've got Mason who can do that well plus has more upside?


Agreed. Can't see what all the fuss is about.

We need a big striker and some pace out wide, plus if posible a quality midfield playmaker.

I don't see where Dobbie fits in with these.

I'm sure Mackay will be casting his net much further than 40 miles down the road. Thanksfully.

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 6:12 pm

WHOSE FUSSING??????? :?

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 6:32 pm

Never ever. He is a Jack scum. :evil: :evil:

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 6:36 pm

adz-a32 wrote:Never ever. He is a Jack scum. :evil: :evil:

Did you think the same when we signed Andy Legg?

Thats if you was born.....

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 6:39 pm

Very average player if you ask me. Add the fact he's a Jack, No thanks.

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 6:46 pm

Are you seriously suggesting that Dobbie isn't good enough for you? :?

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 6:52 pm

NJ73 wrote:Are you seriously suggesting that Dobbie isn't good enough for you? :?


Im not I think he has the creative spark we lack

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 6:55 pm

Midfield general wrote:
NJ73 wrote:Are you seriously suggesting that Dobbie isn't good enough for you? :?


Yeah he's too average for my liking


In which may I suggest you need to start following another sport.

As Polo says below, he is a creative spark and him coming into our side in the second half of last season was one of the main factors in us getting promotion.

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 6:58 pm

NJ73 wrote:
Midfield general wrote:
NJ73 wrote:Are you seriously suggesting that Dobbie isn't good enough for you? :?


Yeah he's too average for my liking


In which may I suggest you need to start following another sport.

As Polo says below, he is a creative spark and him coming into our side in the second half of last season was one of the main factors in us getting promotion.

Dobbie strikes me as a player good enough for championship but not good enough for PL. I would say the final catalyst for your promotion was Borini. Him and Sinclair were class-without those 2 Swansea would have been 9th or 10th in my humble opinion

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 7:06 pm

polo wrote:Stephen dobbie. would welcome him. cracking footballer.




Promoted to the Premiership TWICE in the last TWO years (Blackpool and Swansea) and going for a hat-trick??


:ayatollah: ;) :ayatollah: ;) :ayatollah: ;) :ayatollah: ;) :ayatollah:

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 7:19 pm

Gareth (Wilts) wrote:
NJ73 wrote:
Midfield general wrote:
NJ73 wrote:Are you seriously suggesting that Dobbie isn't good enough for you? :?


Yeah he's too average for my liking


In which may I suggest you need to start following another sport.

As Polo says below, he is a creative spark and him coming into our side in the second half of last season was one of the main factors in us getting promotion.

Dobbie strikes me as a player good enough for championship but not good enough for PL. I would say the final catalyst for your promotion was Borini. Him and Sinclair were class-without those 2 Swansea would have been 9th or 10th in my humble opinion


It's difficult to comment on whether Dobbie is good enough for the Prem as he's had so little playing time, which is disappointing. Obviously the manager must feel he is lacking something at this level though.

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 11:00 pm

NJ73 wrote:Are you seriously suggesting that Dobbie isn't good enough for you? :?


Only Vorm, Graham, Dyer, Sinclair & Routledge from your outfit would fit in our current team. 4 out of 5 starters but thats only because we have no pace on the wings and lacking a target man. And Vorm has been your saving grace this year, without him you could easily be in the bottom 3.

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 11:02 pm

BlueWhite&Yellow wrote:
NJ73 wrote:Are you seriously suggesting that Dobbie isn't good enough for you? :?


Only Vorm, Graham, Dyer, Sinclair & Routledge from your outfit would fit in our current team. 4 out of 5 starters but thats only because we have no pace on the wings and lacking a target man. And Vorm has been your saving grace this year, without him you could easily be in the bottom 3.


To be fair mate Ashley Williams would walk into our team.

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 11:14 pm

jinks-rct wrote:a jack i spoke to reckons he heard we could be interested in him?
im not claiming anything just wondered if anyone else has heard something?


i Made the same mistake last week by calling this guy Scott :roll: - when i also heard we were interested in him :o

Scott - Steven or whatever...Not for me...as i think there are better players out there ( IMO ) :ayatollah:

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 11:16 pm

polo wrote:
BlueWhite&Yellow wrote:
NJ73 wrote:Are you seriously suggesting that Dobbie isn't good enough for you? :?


Only Vorm, Graham, Dyer, Sinclair & Routledge from your outfit would fit in our current team. 4 out of 5 starters but thats only because we have no pace on the wings and lacking a target man. And Vorm has been your saving grace this year, without him you could easily be in the bottom 3.


To be fair mate Ashley Williams would walk into our team.


Seriously?? Im not sure who's slower, Williams or Hudson? My personal opinion of Williams is that he is on par with Titus Bramble. Thats how low I rate him (Please dont tell me Bramble would walk into our side?)

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 11:17 pm

BlueWhite&Yellow wrote:
NJ73 wrote:Are you seriously suggesting that Dobbie isn't good enough for you? :?


Only Vorm, Graham, Dyer, Sinclair & Routledge from your outfit would fit in our current team. 4 out of 5 starters but thats only because we have no pace on the wings and lacking a target man. And Vorm has been your saving grace this year, without him you could easily be in the bottom 3.


As Polo says, Ashley Williams would walk into your team.

As would Caulker who although not ours as such, is still ours for this year and would walk into your team (He'll be in the Spurs first team next year).

And Joe Allen, who has set the Premier League alight and is currently linked with a move to Liverpool wouldn't get in your side? Bizarre. Also Neil Taylor is arguably the best young left back in the country. But hey, he wouldn't get in your side :shock:

Neither would Leon Britton apparently. You know, the guy with in the top 5 in Europe for pass completion. Granted he doesn't do much attacking wise but that's not his job. I suppose makelele wouldn't have got in your side either :lol:

And then there is Mark Gower. The guy who is in the top 5 for chances created in the top leagues in europe. Not good enough for you though.

:lol:

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 11:18 pm

BlueWhite&Yellow wrote:
polo wrote:
BlueWhite&Yellow wrote:
NJ73 wrote:Are you seriously suggesting that Dobbie isn't good enough for you? :?


Only Vorm, Graham, Dyer, Sinclair & Routledge from your outfit would fit in our current team. 4 out of 5 starters but thats only because we have no pace on the wings and lacking a target man. And Vorm has been your saving grace this year, without him you could easily be in the bottom 3.


To be fair mate Ashley Williams would walk into our team.


Seriously?? Im not sure who's slower, Williams or Hudson? My personal opinion of Williams is that he is on par with Titus Bramble. Thats how low I rate him (Please dont tell me Bramble would walk into our side?)


Ashley Williams slow?

Do you actually watch football at all? :?

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 11:21 pm

Fuxk no! He's a jack cun.t, not welcome here. Imagine how it would look if a Jack came to Cardiff, there would be no more rivalry between us, and whats the point in that? :ayatollah:

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 11:22 pm

CantonJack wrote:Fuxk no! He's a jack cun.t, not welcome here. Imagine how it would look if a Jack came to Cardiff, there would be no more rivalry between us, and whats the point in that? :ayatollah:


Have you seen that goal Alan Curtis scored for you in the Welsh cup final?

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 11:22 pm

NJ73 wrote:
BlueWhite&Yellow wrote:
NJ73 wrote:Are you seriously suggesting that Dobbie isn't good enough for you? :?


Only Vorm, Graham, Dyer, Sinclair & Routledge from your outfit would fit in our current team. 4 out of 5 starters but thats only because we have no pace on the wings and lacking a target man. And Vorm has been your saving grace this year, without him you could easily be in the bottom 3.


As Polo says, Ashley Williams would walk into your team.

As would Caulker who although not ours as such, is still ours for this year and would walk into your team (He'll be in the Spurs first team next year).

And Joe Allen, who has set the Premier League alight and is currently linked with a move to Liverpool wouldn't get in your side? Bizarre. Also Neil Taylor is arguably the best young left back in the country. But hey, he wouldn't get in your side :shock:

Neither would Leon Britton apparently. You know, the guy with in the top 5 in Europe for pass completion. Granted he doesn't do much attacking wise but that's not his job. I suppose makelele wouldn't have got in your side either :lol:

And then there is Mark Gower. The guy who is in the top 5 for chances created in the top leagues in europe. Not good enough for you though.

:lol:


I seriously woouldnt replace any of our current first 11 with any apart from the ones I already mentioned.

Im not surprised with what you said about Britton, anyone of your back 4 could easily get in the top 4 of passes completed. You said it yourself that he does do much going forward. I guess Britton just sits in front of the back 4 passing back all day long.

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 11:23 pm

CantonJack wrote:Fuxk no! He's a jack cun.t, not welcome here. Imagine how it would look if a Jack came to Cardiff, there would be no more rivalry between us, and whats the point in that? :ayatollah:



Andy Legg and Jason Bowen. Two "Jack Cnuts" who crossed the divide and did well for us. Legg become hero worshipped by the fans.

Re: SCOTT DOBBIE?

Thu Dec 29, 2011 11:23 pm

NJ73 wrote:
BlueWhite&Yellow wrote:
polo wrote:
BlueWhite&Yellow wrote:
NJ73 wrote:Are you seriously suggesting that Dobbie isn't good enough for you? :?


Only Vorm, Graham, Dyer, Sinclair & Routledge from your outfit would fit in our current team. 4 out of 5 starters but thats only because we have no pace on the wings and lacking a target man. And Vorm has been your saving grace this year, without him you could easily be in the bottom 3.


To be fair mate Ashley Williams would walk into our team.


Seriously?? Im not sure who's slower, Williams or Hudson? My personal opinion of Williams is that he is on par with Titus Bramble. Thats how low I rate him (Please dont tell me Bramble would walk into our side?)


Ashley Williams slow?

Do you actually watch football at all? :?


Iv seen milk turn quicker!!