My Player Ratings last night

if you agree then say, or ofcourse put your own up if you dont

Heaton: 8
Mcnaughton: 8
Gerrard: 7
Hudson: 8
Taylor: 7
Gunnarsson: 7
Whittingham: 8
Mcphail: 9
Cowie: 7
Conway: 7
Mason: 8

SPOT ON , THOUGHT MCPHAIL WAS TOP CLASS

good. i think my ratings were pretty fair

it reflected a good night for us

to be honest i didnt think mcnaughton played that well i though his distrubution was poor but just my opinion

How the hell does a player who gave the ball away time and again get 9???? when Mason who ran himself into the ground and scored the winner only gets 8

McPhail did f**k all last night apart from concede possession and trudge around so slowly that Hudson was stroming past him at one point. Chirst get those rose tinted glasses off and see him for what he is, an overrated lazy liability.

wow someone got out of the wrong side of the bed this morning

mcphail was outstanding last night,didnt try anything clever,kept possession and most importantly for me marshalled the midfield

It's all about opinions, but I feel these ratings are a bit closer to reality:-

http://www.walesonline.co.uk/footballna ... -29661905/

How the hell does a player who gave the ball away time and again get 9???? when Mason who ran himself into the ground and scored the winner only gets 8

McPhail did f**k all last night apart from concede possession and trudge around so slowly that Hudson was stroming past him at one point. Chirst get those rose tinted glasses off and see him for what he is, an overrated lazy liability.

I can't recall one instance where McPhail gave the ball away last night and you were the only one who thought McPhail was shit last weekend as well, so perhaps you need to look at him differently!

Even myself, who believes that Hudson is the weak point in defence, wouldn't attempt to crucify him, like you've attempted to do to McPhail in this thread and the weekend's thread!

Heaton 7
McNaughton 7
Hudson 7
Gerrard 8
Taylor 7
Whittingham 8
McPhail 9
Gunnarsson 6 (Lost the ball way too much and his first touch was awful)
Conway 7
Cowie 8
Mason 8

Heaton 7
McNaughton 7
Hudson 7
Gerrard 8
Taylor 7
Whittingham 8
McPhail 9
Gunnarsson 6 (Lost the ball way too much and his first touch was awful)
Conway 7
Cowie 8
Mason 8

gerrard was no where near an 8, closer to a 6 !!

Heaton 7
McNaughton 7
Hudson 7
Gerrard 8
Taylor 7
Whittingham 8
McPhail 9
Gunnarsson 6 (Lost the ball way too much and his first touch was awful)
Conway 7
Cowie 8
Mason 8

gerrard was no where near an 8, closer to a 6 !!

I meant to put a 7 on but i pressed 8 by accident