Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Earnshaw !

Sat Oct 22, 2011 4:42 pm

I came on here after the home loss to Brighton and basically said earnie wasn't the płayer he was and was no more than a bench player. I was basically shot down and told it was a knee jerk reaction to the Brighton loss. I just wondered if peoples opinions had altered.. Is he the goal scoring god that some make out or is he past his sell buy date and better off in league 1 ?

Re: Earnshaw !

Sat Oct 22, 2011 4:56 pm

boyosback wrote:I came on here after the home loss to Brighton and basically said earnie wasn't the płayer he was and was no more than a bench player. I was basically shot down and told it was a knee jerk reaction to the Brighton loss. I just wondered if peoples opinions had altered.. Is he the goal scoring god that some make out or is he past his sell buy date and better off in league 1 ?

Good impact sub but no more! Still a legend! :ayatollah:

Re: Earnshaw !

Sat Oct 22, 2011 5:19 pm

Cwmann_Bluebird wrote:
boyosback wrote:I came on here after the home loss to Brighton and basically said earnie wasn't the płayer he was and was no more than a bench player. I was basically shot down and told it was a knee jerk reaction to the Brighton loss. I just wondered if peoples opinions had altered.. Is he the goal scoring god that some make out or is he past his sell buy date and better off in league 1 ?

Good impact sub but no more! Still a legend! :ayatollah:


Agree Earnie is a sub now as he does not do enough all round to start! I was a little dissapointed at his effort when he came on, I was expecting non stop running and chasing back as he was on a short time. Joe Mason is showing a much better option that earnie, but he will always be a legend! :ayatollah: