JAMES MCFADDEN

noticing he is still a free agent, and not seen him recently linked to anyone, would he be a decent signing for us??

another scot who mm could have some influence over..

or is he not what we are looking for??


any thoughts??

or perhaps you think someone from this list might be a better catch!


http://www.givemefootball.com/pfa-trans ... ame&page=4

if hes the one that played for everton then sign him up

if hes the one that played for everton then sign him up

yep thats him


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_McFadden

if hes the one that played for everton then sign him up

yep thats him


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_McFadden

imo hes a great player...hed score for fun in the champ

Didnt realise Chris Brown was a freebie, i allways rated him highly. Could work well with Ernie.
Jon Carew, Eider Gudjohnsen and Giles Barnes would be great but think will want to much in wages
Rory Fallon (although hes ex jack) impressed against us with his strength.

And a Big No to McFadden for me, to many serious knee injuries

Didnt realise Chris Brown was a freebie, i allways rated him highly. Could work well with Ernie.
Jon Carew, Eider Gudjohnsen and Giles Barnes would be great but think will want to much in wages
Rory Fallon (although hes ex jack) impressed against us with his strength.

there are alot of players still available on that list... not sure about gudjohnsen, think he would be high wage and lack of effort..

think fallon is past it and dosnt offer any difference to parkin...

carew would be class , but he was on around 40k a yr at villa...

dont know much about chris brown to be honest?

Ben McCarthy is also available might be a cracking signing, but probably another Fowler

Ben McCarthy is also available might be a cracking signing, but probably another Fowler

def another fowler....

Chris Brown was the 1 that headed the 5th against us for Preston
Tall guy that seemed real good on the ball

Chris Brown was the 1 that headed the 5th against us for Preston
Tall guy that seemed real good on the ball

ah , tried to forget that one!!

McFadden has had serious knee injuries and hardly kicked a ball last year, the fact he is still available would suggest he is crocked. As for McCarthy he is a fat waste of space and i wouldnt touch him with a barge pole.

Chris Brown was the 1 that headed the 5th against us for Preston
Tall guy that seemed real good on the ball

I'm sure when Preston went down and I went on their boards they were glad he was gone so no thanks!

Rory Fallon mentioned not good enough for the Jacks or Plymouth definitely not good enough for us

no thanks injury prone i would never have Fallon here he's awful
maybe Chris Brown but he was bench all the time for PNE last season so not to sure
and god no to Benni McCarthy

Maybe McFadden quit the Brum to play prem football else were?

Surprised a team in the prem haven't signed him tbh.

Can play uptop and on the wing. Id take him!

briliant signing if he came

Nice player but injury prone.

No thank you to all others mentioned in this thread apart from John Carew, who I dont think we could afford anyway.

Maybe Kenny can persuade him to come?

They're probably still available for a reason. Injury problems, wage demands or attitude issues.