Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

CAN ANYONE DEFEND DAVE JONES

Thu May 05, 2011 7:56 am

serious question can anyone give me any name/s of any player DJ has bought from the lower leagues or teams below us and made a success out of forgetting the obvious roger johnson :ayatollah: :ayatollah:

Re: CAN ANYONE DEFEND DAVE JONES

Thu May 05, 2011 8:12 am

Would you count the SPL as lower? I know I would. So there's the scottish boys for a start.

Re: CAN ANYONE DEFEND DAVE JONES

Thu May 05, 2011 8:29 am

he signed goalkeeper Marshall from relegated League 1 side Norwich City , now look where they are 2 seasons later :lol:

Re: CAN ANYONE DEFEND DAVE JONES

Thu May 05, 2011 8:31 am

Yes JLS can, whoops just remembered he can't defend anything, so I guess the answer is no. ;)

Re: CAN ANYONE DEFEND DAVE JONES

Thu May 05, 2011 8:35 am

I think his biggest successes is making players out of under achievers/no-hopers :

Chops (up until recently)
Bothroyd (up until the England call-up)
Whitts
Oli
Hudson
Loovens
Keinan
Koumas (1st time and I still think he has a part to play in the next couple of games)
Burke
MacNaughton
McCormack (1st season before the booze kicked in)
Heaton
Quinn
+ others I will have forgotten

The main concern I have is whether he can maintain that improvement past the 1st couple of seasons. For players like Jay, Burke,etc. the jury is out until we see how the next few weeks pan out because performing under pressure is key.

Re: CAN ANYONE DEFEND DAVE JONES

Thu May 05, 2011 8:35 am

Mc Naughton's defending the 1st half on Monday was abysmal too and very costly ....... he took it out on the poor lino Miss Massey tho who incidently is doing the Jerks game on Saturday . She commented that she enjoyed Kev's stiff tackle :lol:

Re: CAN ANYONE DEFEND DAVE JONES

Thu May 05, 2011 10:09 am

beddau blue wrote:serious question can anyone give me any name/s of any player DJ has bought from the lower leagues or teams below us and made a success out of forgetting the obvious roger johnson :ayatollah: :ayatollah:


The only one from our current squad is Hudson.

I would also add that he has done good business with most of our Scottish players...

McNaughts is a CCFC Legend although he probably had his worst game in a Blue shirt on Monday

Burke has been a great servant and on his day is class, but only seen the best of him a few times this season.

Quinn has turned into a steady defender who hasnt ket us down over the last 15 games

Steve Thompson, good Championship player and good business.

Ross, great signing and fantastic 1st season then went on the Jon Parkin diet.

Gavin Rae has served us well as a steady Championship player, but not good enough for a top 6 team.

Neil Alexander is as good as any keeper we've had since.

Re: CAN ANYONE DEFEND DAVE JONES

Thu May 05, 2011 10:41 am

hudson should have returned to centre half and mcnaughton left back on sat samuel isnt any better than lee naylor :lol:

Re: CAN ANYONE DEFEND DAVE JONES

Thu May 05, 2011 10:58 am

ccfc_4_life wrote:hudson should have returned to centre half and mcnaughton left back on sat samuel isnt any better than lee naylor :lol:


In hindsight, I agree that Husdon should have been brought back in. However, that defence that performed so badly on Monday had only conceded 4 goals in the last 6 games and 50% of those goals were scored by the Championship Player of the Year.
So DJ would have been slated if he'd changed a winning team, we'd lost and Hudosn hadnt played very well. Dont forget Hudson's not match fit.

You cant legisalate for individual errors....Kevin and Keinan have been immense for us this season but they made basic defensive mistakes that they normally would deal with their eyes shut.

However JLS must now be dropped for Burnley.....he clearly looked like he couldnt give a sh1t. All 3 goals came from the left and he made no attempt to stop a cross or close his man down.
He has let DJ, his teammates and the fans down, although thats the risk you take with a loan player....

Re: CAN ANYONE DEFEND DAVE JONES

Thu May 05, 2011 11:55 am

JonesYrAderynGlas wrote:
ccfc_4_life wrote:hudson should have returned to centre half and mcnaughton left back on sat samuel isnt any better than lee naylor :lol:


Dont forget Hudson's not match fit.

thats why we should have had a reserve team :lol: :ayatollah:

Re: CAN ANYONE DEFEND DAVE JONES

Thu May 05, 2011 12:28 pm

Hudson should have been included in the first XI vs Middlesbrough providing he was sober, otherwise it wouldn't have made much difference...

Re: CAN ANYONE DEFEND DAVE JONES

Thu May 05, 2011 12:30 pm

ccfc_4_life wrote:
JonesYrAderynGlas wrote:
ccfc_4_life wrote:hudson should have returned to centre half and mcnaughton left back on sat samuel isnt any better than lee naylor :lol:


Dont forget Hudson's not match fit.

thats why we should have had a reserve team :lol: :ayatollah:



Totally agree

Re: CAN ANYONE DEFEND DAVE JONES

Thu May 05, 2011 12:31 pm

NO!