Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

What type of squad do you prefer?

You may select 1 option

5
26%
13
68%
1
5%
 
Total votes : 19
 

POLL: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Mon Nov 02, 2026 6:22 pm

Wondering what fans thoughts are and preferences on this .

Large squad .

Positives.

Injury & suspensions worries are less effected to a quality starting 11.

Rotation ,
of a large squad
Helps with less fatigue and burn out and competition for places.

Small squad

Positives

Easier managed a small squad.

A regular 11 who know each other inside out and how they play and become and play as 1 unit.

Negatives
Large squad

Players not getting regular game time , little clicks forming in a large squad causing maybe friction.

Negatives
Small squad

Injuries suspensions take there toll a weak bench and burn out.


My own personal would be a larger squad currently we are forced to have kids who have no experience of first team football let alone championship football on the bench plus a larger squad gives options for the manager to change it up and bring on quality from the bench.

Opinions are welcome to discuss .

Re: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Mon Nov 02, 2026 6:51 pm

Somewhere in the middle as we need a couple of signings & have since the window closed so hopefully we get them in the January window, but not a huge amount as you, monty, seem to be advocating for. Take the center back issue we have at the moment, without the injuries we currently have how many center backs would be enough for you and when do you stop adding players "just in case"?

Re: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Mon Nov 02, 2026 7:05 pm

Welshman in CA wrote:Somewhere in the middle as we need a couple of signings & have since the window closed so hopefully we get them in the January window, but not a huge amount as you, monty, seem to be advocating for. Take the center back issue we have at the moment, without the injuries we currently have how many center backs would be enough for you and when do you stop adding players "just in case"?


That's understandable regarding our back line we could have all 5 centre backs out to injury and suspensions that is a bit freaky i agree,
but wolves had 12 players out the weekend and put out a good starting 11 and a decent bench that's what a quality large squad brings

Re: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Mon Nov 02, 2026 7:17 pm

No issue with the youngsters on the bench, if they’re good enough or look like they can offer something, even if it’s a bit of raw energy when needed.

What we have is an ok starting 11, and a weak bench. I don’t mean weak in terms of the players on the bench aren’t as good, I mean they have the exact qualities that we already have in the first 11. There’s no alternative.

Small squad is my preference but our squad is difficult because our top earners are not starters and offer nothing different from the bench

Re: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Mon Nov 02, 2026 7:26 pm

Tuggi wrote:No issue with the youngsters on the bench, if they’re good enough or look like they can offer something, even if it’s a bit of raw energy when needed.

What we have is an ok starting 11, and a weak bench. I don’t mean weak in terms of the players on the bench aren’t as good, I mean they have the exact qualities that we already have in the first 11. There’s no alternative.

Small squad is my preference but our squad is difficult because our top earners are not starters and offer nothing different from the bench



We have kids on the bench who have not played first team football let alone championhip experiance

Re: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Mon Nov 02, 2026 7:38 pm

I know Monty, I was partially agreeing with you.

The youngsters we put on the bench aren’t there on merit, they’re there out of necessity.

That said, sometimes we just need to gamble. Cameron Jerome would not have got a chance if it wasn’t for desperation and he proved himself. Even then, he was behind Stuart Fleetwood in the pecking order, and was fortunate he got injured when given his chance to step in. Look how differently their careers ended up going.

The youngsters Annis has been highlighting lately might be worth taking a punt on. Not got much to lose

Re: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Mon Nov 02, 2026 7:48 pm

Tuggi wrote:I know Monty, I was partially agreeing with you.

The youngsters we put on the bench aren’t there on merit, they’re there out of necessity.

That said, sometimes we just need to gamble. Cameron Jerome would not have got a chance if it wasn’t for desperation and he proved himself. Even then, he was behind Stuart Fleetwood in the pecking order, and was fortunate he got injured when given his chance to step in. Look how differently their careers ended up going.

The youngsters Annis has been highlighting lately might be worth taking a punt on. Not got much to lose


I agree been forced pops up a gem now and again but they are few and far between .

Re: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Mon Nov 02, 2026 8:04 pm

montyblue wrote:
Welshman in CA wrote:Somewhere in the middle as we need a couple of signings & have since the window closed so hopefully we get them in the January window, but not a huge amount as you, monty, seem to be advocating for. Take the center back issue we have at the moment, without the injuries we currently have how many center backs would be enough for you and when do you stop adding players "just in case"?


That's understandable regarding our back line we could have all 5 centre backs out to injury and suspensions that is a bit freaky i agree,
but wolves had 12 players out the weekend and put out a good starting 11 and a decent bench that's what a quality large squad brings


So you think we should have a Premier league squad along with the cost that would entail? Again, when is enough enough and when do you stop saying "just in case"?

Re: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Mon Nov 02, 2026 8:09 pm

As time goes on and if we ever want to really challenge for top eight then we need a bigger squad than we have now, for sure.

But it has to be a squad of good players obviously. In the past we've had squads including players like Etete and others, pointless having that in the squad because they add little. Takes time to add that quality, but I would hope we have a lot more strength in depth by the end of next summer - especially with big earners leaving.

I'm not a fan of huge squads and wouldn't want a squad of 30. Problem with that is when everyone's fit, you can only pick 18 players in the squad (2 GKs) so 12 are left out completely.

But going forward, I would say a squad of 16/17 core players and another 8 or so in back up is needed.

Re: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Mon Nov 02, 2026 8:43 pm

Welshman in CA wrote:
montyblue wrote:
Welshman in CA wrote:Somewhere in the middle as we need a couple of signings & have since the window closed so hopefully we get them in the January window, but not a huge amount as you, monty, seem to be advocating for. Take the center back issue we have at the moment, without the injuries we currently have how many center backs would be enough for you and when do you stop adding players "just in case"?


That's understandable regarding our back line we could have all 5 centre backs out to injury and suspensions that is a bit freaky i agree,
but wolves had 12 players out the weekend and put out a good starting 11 and a decent bench that's what a quality large squad brings


So you think we should have a Premier league squad along with the cost that would entail? Again, when is enough enough and when do you stop saying "just in case"?


Do you think we did enough at the start of this season to enter the championship with hope, we where behind lincoln city in recruiting for this season,?do you think it is acceptable for us to have no experience of first team football let alone championship experience mostly on the bench .

Re: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Mon Nov 02, 2026 9:05 pm

I’m more than happy to support BBM and his preference for a small(er) interchangeable squad, full of players he feels he can work with and trust

Larger squads where (some) players aren’t fully invested into the storybook, and are less likely to play a full part, is a waste of time, money, and squad cohesion

We had a very large squad the season we last went down, which on paper at least, should have been a lot better than they proved to be. The squad was disjointed, I’ll-disciplined in parts, and certain players simply didn’t care whilst picking up very high (fir the Championship) wages

It’s a no-brained for me; support BBM and his choices, in the hope he can get a couple in this January to boost, but not demean, those he already has here! :ayatollah:

Re: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Mon Nov 02, 2026 9:39 pm

Sven wrote:I’m more than happy to support BBM and his preference for a small(er) interchangeable squad, full of players he feels he can work with and trust

Larger squads where (some) players aren’t fully invested into the storybook, and are less likely to play a full part, is a waste of time, money, and squad cohesion

We had a very large squad the season we last went down, which on paper at least, should have been a lot better than they proved to be. The squad was disjointed, I’ll-disciplined in parts, and certain players simply didn’t care whilst picking up very high (fir the Championship) wages

It’s a no-brained for me; support BBM and his choices, in the hope he can get a couple in this January to boost, but not demean, those he already has here! :ayatollah:


Sven

I am happy with how bbm wants to run his squad be it big or small but I bet he wished he had more than a bunch of kids without any first team experience on the bench let alone championship experience .

Re: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Mon Nov 02, 2026 9:52 pm

montyblue wrote:
Welshman in CA wrote:
montyblue wrote:
Welshman in CA wrote:Somewhere in the middle as we need a couple of signings & have since the window closed so hopefully we get them in the January window, but not a huge amount as you, monty, seem to be advocating for. Take the center back issue we have at the moment, without the injuries we currently have how many center backs would be enough for you and when do you stop adding players "just in case"?


That's understandable regarding our back line we could have all 5 centre backs out to injury and suspensions that is a bit freaky i agree,
but wolves had 12 players out the weekend and put out a good starting 11 and a decent bench that's what a quality large squad brings


So you think we should have a Premier league squad along with the cost that would entail? Again, when is enough enough and when do you stop saying "just in case"?


Do you think we did enough at the start of this season to enter the championship with hope, we where behind lincoln city in recruiting for this season,?do you think it is acceptable for us to have no experience of first team football let alone championship experience mostly on the bench .


When you answer my questions I put to you I will be more than happy to answer yours, even though I already have for the most part in my original post. This tit for tat when you ask a question & someone answers it but you don't like the answer so fire back with more questions without answering in the first place is getting tiresome. I thought we could have a decent convo about squad size but I guess I was wrong.

Re: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Mon Nov 02, 2026 10:19 pm

Welshman in CA wrote:
montyblue wrote:
Welshman in CA wrote:
montyblue wrote:
Welshman in CA wrote:Somewhere in the middle as we need a couple of signings & have since the window closed so hopefully we get them in the January window, but not a huge amount as you, monty, seem to be advocating for. Take the center back issue we have at the moment, without the injuries we currently have how many center backs would be enough for you and when do you stop adding players "just in case"?


That's understandable regarding our back line we could have all 5 centre backs out to injury and suspensions that is a bit freaky i agree,
but wolves had 12 players out the weekend and put out a good starting 11 and a decent bench that's what a quality large squad brings


So you think we should have a Premier league squad along with the cost that would entail? Again, when is enough enough and when do you stop saying "just in case"?


Do you think we did enough at the start of this season to enter the championship with hope, we where behind lincoln city in recruiting for this season,?do you think it is acceptable for us to have no experience of first team football let alone championship experience mostly on the bench .


When you answer my questions I put to you I will be more than happy to answer yours, even though I already have for the most part in my original post. This tit for tat when you ask a question & someone answers it but you don't like the answer so fire back with more questions without answering in the first place is getting tiresome. I thought we could have a decent convo about squad size but I guess I was wrong.


Sorry budd it was not intentional no i don' t think we should have spent enough for a prem squad but possibly done a bit more than the team we came up with from league 1 and we are the capital city of wales but we are way behind our rivals down the road who have recruited well and without spending a fortune,this is where I was hoping we would be in our approach.

Re: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Mon Nov 02, 2026 10:41 pm

montyblue wrote:
Sven wrote:I’m more than happy to support BBM and his preference for a small(er) interchangeable squad, full of players he feels he can work with and trust

Larger squads where (some) players aren’t fully invested into the storybook, and are less likely to play a full part, is a waste of time, money, and squad cohesion

We had a very large squad the season we last went down, which on paper at least, should have been a lot better than they proved to be. The squad was disjointed, I’ll-disciplined in parts, and certain players simply didn’t care whilst picking up very high (fir the Championship) wages

It’s a no-brained for me; support BBM and his choices, in the hope he can get a couple in this January to boost, but not demean, those he already has here! :ayatollah:


Sven

I am happy with how bbm wants to run his squad be it big or small but I bet he wished he had more than a bunch of kids without any first team experience on the bench let alone championship experience .

It’s clear you have an issue with the squad size versus quality, as you bring it up a lot, which is your prerogative, and I simply gave my own view on the question asked :thumbup:

I also created the poll, so others could show their stance in the simplest form, i.e. a vote :ayatollah:

Re: POLL: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Tue Nov 03, 2026 12:42 pm

I posted this as not just me but a lot are on the same hymn sheet as me and probably just as much you so thought it was worthy of discussion,and i have no prob with you deciding to put a poll out at the start of my Title.

Re: POLL: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Tue Nov 03, 2026 3:29 pm

montyblue wrote:I posted this as not just me but a lot are on the same hymn sheet as me and probably just as much you so thought it was worthy of discussion,and i have no prob with you deciding to put a poll out at the start of my Title.

Appreciate that. It’s all about opinion; and the poll was genuinely put up to help :ayatollah:

Re: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Tue Nov 03, 2026 5:35 pm

montyblue wrote:
Welshman in CA wrote:
montyblue wrote:
Welshman in CA wrote:
montyblue wrote:
Welshman in CA wrote:Somewhere in the middle as we need a couple of signings & have since the window closed so hopefully we get them in the January window, but not a huge amount as you, monty, seem to be advocating for. Take the center back issue we have at the moment, without the injuries we currently have how many center backs would be enough for you and when do you stop adding players "just in case"?


That's understandable regarding our back line we could have all 5 centre backs out to injury and suspensions that is a bit freaky i agree,
but wolves had 12 players out the weekend and put out a good starting 11 and a decent bench that's what a quality large squad brings


So you think we should have a Premier league squad along with the cost that would entail? Again, when is enough enough and when do you stop saying "just in case"?


Do you think we did enough at the start of this season to enter the championship with hope, we where behind lincoln city in recruiting for this season,?do you think it is acceptable for us to have no experience of first team football let alone championship experience mostly on the bench .


When you answer my questions I put to you I will be more than happy to answer yours, even though I already have for the most part in my original post. This tit for tat when you ask a question & someone answers it but you don't like the answer so fire back with more questions without answering in the first place is getting tiresome. I thought we could have a decent convo about squad size but I guess I was wrong.


Sorry budd it was not intentional no i don' t think we should have spent enough for a prem squad but possibly done a bit more than the team we came up with from league 1 and we are the capital city of wales but we are way behind our rivals down the road who have recruited well and without spending a fortune,this is where I was hoping we would be in our approach.


As I said I think we needed a couple of signings more & we would have been good to go but for whatever reason they didn't happen, I always have hope & believe we can win no matter who the opposition is or what common sense tells me. I just want the manager to have what he needs & the squad size is immaterial to that. As for the youngsters being on the bench, it's not ideal but there's just too many on the bench now anyway. It used to be 3 subs max & you go with what you have, now there's how many? 7? Which is just too many sometimes as you're not using them all anyway so why not throw in the odd youngster (15, 16 or 17) for a bit of first team experience and to learn how the first team works on match day.

BTW I like the poll being there as it will be interesting where it lands & how many actually vote as I think the majority don't have a view either way. I went for the last option before you ask.

Re: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Tue Nov 03, 2026 5:44 pm

Welshman in CA wrote:
montyblue wrote:
Welshman in CA wrote:
montyblue wrote:
Welshman in CA wrote:
montyblue wrote:
Welshman in CA wrote:Somewhere in the middle as we need a couple of signings & have since the window closed so hopefully we get them in the January window, but not a huge amount as you, monty, seem to be advocating for. Take the center back issue we have at the moment, without the injuries we currently have how many center backs would be enough for you and when do you stop adding players "just in case"?


That's understandable regarding our back line we could have all 5 centre backs out to injury and suspensions that is a bit freaky i agree,
but wolves had 12 players out the weekend and put out a good starting 11 and a decent bench that's what a quality large squad brings


So you think we should have a Premier league squad along with the cost that would entail? Again, when is enough enough and when do you stop saying "just in case"?


Do you think we did enough at the start of this season to enter the championship with hope, we where behind lincoln city in recruiting for this season,?do you think it is acceptable for us to have no experience of first team football let alone championship experience mostly on the bench .


When you answer my questions I put to you I will be more than happy to answer yours, even though I already have for the most part in my original post. This tit for tat when you ask a question & someone answers it but you don't like the answer so fire back with more questions without answering in the first place is getting tiresome. I thought we could have a decent convo about squad size but I guess I was wrong.


Sorry budd it was not intentional no i don' t think we should have spent enough for a prem squad but possibly done a bit more than the team we came up with from league 1 and we are the capital city of wales but we are way behind our rivals down the road who have recruited well and without spending a fortune,this is where I was hoping we would be in our approach.


As I said I think we needed a couple of signings more & we would have been good to go but for whatever reason they didn't happen, I always have hope & believe we can win no matter who the opposition is or what common sense tells me. I just want the manager to have what he needs & the squad size is immaterial to that. As for the youngsters being on the bench, it's not ideal but there's just too many on the bench now anyway. It used to be 3 subs max & you go with what you have, now there's how many? 7? Which is just too many sometimes as you're not using them all anyway so why not throw in the odd youngster (15, 16 or 17) for a bit of first team experience and to learn how the first team works on match day.

BTW I like the poll being there as it will be interesting where it lands & how many actually vote as I think the majority don't have a view either way. I went for the last option before you ask.


Would not have asked how you voted budd.

Re: POLL: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Tue Nov 03, 2026 6:00 pm

Everyone can see small squad not working

Re: POLL: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Tue Nov 03, 2026 6:02 pm

Let’s face it your skint and that’s why you have a small squad and are struggling. It does not work.

Re: POLL: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Tue Nov 03, 2026 6:08 pm

Ain’t going anywhere with a small squad FACT

Re: POLL: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Tue Nov 03, 2026 6:13 pm

Why is everyone under the impression that BBM wants a squad this size? If I said I'm happy with a small squad I'd be talking about the number we have plus about 5

Re: POLL: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Wed Nov 04, 2026 1:46 am

Proud Jack wrote:Let’s face it your skint and that’s why you have a small squad and are struggling. It does not work.

Oops! Here he comes! Some credit though, you only (usually) sing when you’re winning! :lol:

Bet you wish you’d waited until 90+8 minutes to post on a rival club’s Forum tonight, Proud Jack? :lol:

“1-1 and you mucked it up! 1-1 and you mucked it up!” :lol:

“We are too of the League, sing we are top of…oh, hang on!” :lol: :clap:

Re: POLL: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Wed Nov 04, 2026 9:37 am

Would I rather this tight nit squad over clowns like Miete/Collins etc - yes, every day of the week.

Stick behind BBM. He's improving us every 6 months; it may not be the rate some of you like, but I feel the same lot also then boot off that we're in serious debt.

Re: POLL: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Wed Nov 04, 2026 1:08 pm

Starvinmarvin wrote:Why is everyone under the impression that BBM wants a squad this size? If I said I'm happy with a small squad I'd be talking about the number we have plus about 5



Bringing in two genuine first team starters gives us a massive boost, though five would take us to another level. BBM has already said he wants a few more now.

Perspective is needed here: we are only in the initial stage of a two year Championship project under BBM. This current dip represents our absolute floor, driven entirely by an unprecedented pile up of injuries in one specific position on the pitch. Once that balances out, the schedule gets right back on track.

This season should be treated like Warnock's first rebuild season.

Re: POLL: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Thu Nov 05, 2026 8:59 am

If ever proof was needed that we need a bigger squad it was last night against west ham.

Re: POLL: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Thu Nov 05, 2026 9:03 am

And it seems like more fans would have preferred us playing with a larger quality squad ,and last nights west ham game showed that, despite all our great efforts last night.

Re: POLL: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Thu Nov 05, 2026 9:08 am

Larger squad with players of quality.

Wouldn't have done us much good last night if we had players like Etete or Kanga to bring off the bench. And unfortunately it takes time to add that quality, I doubt much can be done until the big earners are gone next summer.

Re: POLL: LARGER SQUAD& ROTATION OR SMALL SQUAD &SET TEAM

Thu Nov 05, 2026 9:45 am

worcester_ccfc wrote:Larger squad with players of quality.

Wouldn't have done us much good last night if we had players like Etete or Kanga to bring off the bench. And unfortunately it takes time to add that quality, I doubt much can be done until the big earners are gone next summer.

Absolutely! And that squad will cost money that we don’t (seem) to have; or are spending on those who are not currently playing! :ayatollah: