Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

TRY SALEC AND ROBINSON TOGETHER AGAINST NEWPORT

Sat Oct 04, 2025 7:15 pm

Might be a good time to try them together against Newport a chance to experiment . Any thoughts.

Re: TRY SALEC AND ROBINSON TOGETHER AGAINST NEWPORT

Sat Oct 04, 2025 7:22 pm

montyblue wrote:Might be a good time to try them together against Newport a chance to experiment . Any thoughts.



Monty,

I would love to start them together, but this is one game we should field our weakest team and should win comfortably

Re: TRY SALEC AND ROBINSON TOGETHER AGAINST NEWPORT

Sat Oct 04, 2025 7:49 pm

I agree and although we will probably play some youngsters we now have an international break where Salech and Robinson are not called up, Play them and keep them sharp.

Re: TRY SALEC AND ROBINSON TOGETHER AGAINST NEWPORT

Sat Oct 04, 2025 8:26 pm

Forever Blue wrote:
montyblue wrote:Might be a good time to try them together against Newport a chance to experiment . Any thoughts.


Understand i would not normally suggest in a micky mouse cup with risk of injury, but it would be good to try them especially after today even for 45 mins but understand it's a risk .


Monty,

I would love to start them together, but this is one game we should field our weakest team and should win comfortably

Re: TRY SALEC AND ROBINSON TOGETHER AGAINST NEWPORT

Sat Oct 04, 2025 8:28 pm

Forever Blue wrote:
montyblue wrote:Might be a good time to try them together against Newport a chance to experiment . Any thoughts.



Monty,

I would love to start them together, but this is one game we should field our weakest team and should win comfortably



I understand and would not normally suggest in a micky mouse cup with risk of injury,
it was just a chance to play them both together as an experiment even for 45 mins,
but understand it's a risk

Re: TRY SALEC AND ROBINSON TOGETHER AGAINST NEWPORT

Sun Oct 05, 2025 8:42 am

Most teams we have come up against defend heavily against us.
And a solo striker just can't break up their back line.
They just crowd the man up front out.
It's crying out for Salech and Robinson up front.
It will open up pockets and space for goals as we saw against Orient.
But this passing back when defending against attack needs to stop.
It got us in the poop too many times.
Kick it up pitch or into touch.
A more nonsense approach is needed.

Re: TRY SALEC AND ROBINSON TOGETHER AGAINST NEWPORT

Sun Oct 05, 2025 3:10 pm

Am I wrong in thinking that their is a rule in this cup where a minimum of 3 players ( 1st team) must start

Re: TRY SALEC AND ROBINSON TOGETHER AGAINST NEWPORT

Sun Oct 05, 2025 5:20 pm

gwentbluebirds wrote:Am I wrong in thinking that their is a rule in this cup where a minimum of 3 players ( 1st team) must start

4 outfield players who started the previous game or will start the next game is the rule

Re: TRY SALEC AND ROBINSON TOGETHER AGAINST NEWPORT

Sun Oct 05, 2025 5:25 pm

Couldn't agree more. Ditch the Pep ball straitjacket for once and ditch the laptops.

There's a reason why teams have played 442 for an eternity - it works and that is undeniable. You don't always need pretty patterns in midfield. Get the ball quickly to the wingers, get crosses into those 2 lads and we'll score loads of goals (as we did on Saturday after switching formation).

There's no real risk, we're at the international break.

Re: TRY SALEC AND ROBINSON TOGETHER AGAINST NEWPORT

Sun Oct 05, 2025 6:38 pm

At least 45 minutes to see if they gel together in readiness for our next league game home to reading that was my thinking you could include Kellyman as well
also put the game beyond first half.

Re: TRY SALEC AND ROBINSON TOGETHER AGAINST NEWPORT

Sun Oct 05, 2025 7:45 pm

A great game to ‘trial’ certain partnerships at the back, in midfield, and up front. Have a string(ish) bench and change things should the need arise

No offence to Newpot County, but they’re not on form right now, and if they get themselves ‘up’ just because they’re playing us, I’d be asking questions if I was an ‘Exiles’ supporter! :ayatollah:

Re: TRY SALEC AND ROBINSON TOGETHER AGAINST NEWPORT

Tue Oct 07, 2025 9:04 am

Definitely not.

Their fans are gonna be whipping that atmosphere up and get their players that same way. We do not want any injuries.

Re: TRY SALEC AND ROBINSON TOGETHER AGAINST NEWPORT

Tue Oct 07, 2025 11:05 am

Tuna Pasta Bake wrote:Couldn't agree more. Ditch the Pep ball straitjacket for once and ditch the laptops.

There's a reason why teams have played 442 for an eternity - it works and that is undeniable. You don't always need pretty patterns in midfield. Get the ball quickly to the wingers, get crosses into those 2 lads and we'll score loads of goals (as we did on Saturday after switching formation).

There's no real risk, we're at the international break.

Agree with this approach :bluescarf: