Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Today's player ratings

Sat Oct 04, 2025 5:30 pm

Today's player ratings, courtesy of FotMob:


Trott - 7.5
Kpakio - 7.5
Osho - 5.8
Lawlor - 8.4
Bagan - 6.2
Wintle - 6.8
J Colwill - 6.0
R Colwill - 8.3
Davies - 6.4
Willock - 8.0
Robinson - 8.7 (star man)

Salech - 7.5
Turnbull - 6.3
Kellyman - 6.0
Fish - N/A

Re: Today's player ratings

Sat Oct 04, 2025 5:43 pm

they done trott dirty there I know we conceded 3 goals but it would have been so many more if not for him

Re: Today's player ratings

Sat Oct 04, 2025 6:09 pm

Thought goal aside, lawlor was poor. Looked weak in every challenge.

Whole defence give the ball away constantly although Kpakio did improve 2nd half.

Disappointed Isaak Davies never got into the game at all, both full backs for Leyton Orient were poor. Kellyman changed the game and exposed the left back.

Trott despite conceding 3 made some huge saves.

Robinson took his goals well but didn't offer much else, doesn't press anywhere near as well as Salech

Re: Today's player ratings

Sat Oct 04, 2025 6:48 pm

KBK-13 wrote:Thought goal aside, lawlor was poor. Looked weak in every challenge.

Whole defence give the ball away constantly although Kpakio did improve 2nd half.

Disappointed Isaak Davies never got into the game at all, both full backs for Leyton Orient were poor. Kellyman changed the game and exposed the left back.

Trott despite conceding 3 made some huge saves.

Robinson took his goals well but didn't offer much else, doesn't press anywhere near as well as Salech


What game were you watching?- Lawlor was easily our best defender and got the goal as well. Wales Online gave him 9 out of 10 and rightly so in my opinion.

Re: Today's player ratings

Sat Oct 04, 2025 6:57 pm

I don't like these AI-generated stat's.

I think Trott, Lawlor and Rubin are levels above this. Rubin carries this team, Trott keeps us in the game with saves, those things that Alnwick rarely did, and Lawlor is improving every game. I doubt he'll be with us next season or if he is it will be on a season-long loan after a big club spends big on him.

Re: Today's player ratings

Sat Oct 04, 2025 7:03 pm

mugsy wrote:
KBK-13 wrote:Thought goal aside, lawlor was poor. Looked weak in every challenge.

Whole defence give the ball away constantly although Kpakio did improve 2nd half.

Disappointed Isaak Davies never got into the game at all, both full backs for Leyton Orient were poor. Kellyman changed the game and exposed the left back.

Trott despite conceding 3 made some huge saves.

Robinson took his goals well but didn't offer much else, doesn't press anywhere near as well as Salech


What game were you watching?- Lawlor was easily our best defender and got the goal as well. Wales Online gave him 9 out of 10 and rightly so in my opinion.


Being the best defender in a defence that gifted Leyton Orient chance after chance and made Aaron Connolly look like a world beater isn't an achievement.

Even BBM has said in his press conference it was a difficult afternoon for him.

Great goal yes, and on a few occasions he did well bringing the ball out but anytime there was a physical battle he would lose out.

Re: Today's player ratings

Sat Oct 04, 2025 7:22 pm

Osho has had three poor outings in a City shirt. One but almost two goals conceded today, if it were not for Trott pulling off a fine save. Have a penalty away the previous home match too. He’s not settled. Hope BBM picks Fish and Lawler. Osho needs to be given more time to settle. Think it’s taking time to come to terms with the pace following his holiday in French football.

Re: Today's player ratings

Sun Oct 05, 2025 1:05 pm

LittleBoyBlue wrote:Osho has had three poor outings in a City shirt. One but almost two goals conceded today, if it were not for Trott pulling off a fine save. Have a penalty away the previous home match too. He’s not settled. Hope BBM picks Fish and Lawler. Osho needs to be given more time to settle. Think it’s taking time to come to terms with the pace following his holiday in French football.

He was excellent at Wigan.

Re: Today's player ratings

Sun Oct 05, 2025 1:11 pm

bluebirdoct1962 wrote:
LittleBoyBlue wrote:Osho has had three poor outings in a City shirt. One but almost two goals conceded today, if it were not for Trott pulling off a fine save. Have a penalty away the previous home match too. He’s not settled. Hope BBM picks Fish and Lawler. Osho needs to be given more time to settle. Think it’s taking time to come to terms with the pace following his holiday in French football.

He was excellent at Wigan.


To be fair I think most of us could have done a job at Wigan. They offered very little

Re: Today's player ratings

Sun Oct 05, 2025 1:52 pm

Underhill1927 wrote:
bluebirdoct1962 wrote:
LittleBoyBlue wrote:Osho has had three poor outings in a City shirt. One but almost two goals conceded today, if it were not for Trott pulling off a fine save. Have a penalty away the previous home match too. He’s not settled. Hope BBM picks Fish and Lawler. Osho needs to be given more time to settle. Think it’s taking time to come to terms with the pace following his holiday in French football.

He was excellent at Wigan.


To be fair I think most of us could have done a job at Wigan. They offered very little

Fair point.
He’s made a few errors unfortunately but there’s deffo a player in there.

Re: Today's player ratings

Sun Oct 05, 2025 2:33 pm

Wha a load of nonsense those ratings are and just goes to show what drivel stat based analyses give. Willock getting a higher rating than Trott :lol: :lol: :lol:

To anyone who actually watched the game it was clear that Trott was outstanding and was man of the match (though some could argue for Robinson by vitrue of his 2 goals) Trott was literally the difference between the two sides. Had we swapped keepers at half time we would have lost about 7-3:

Re: Today's player ratings

Sun Oct 05, 2025 2:51 pm

JJ1927 wrote:Wha a load of nonsense those ratings are and just goes to show what drivel stat based analyses give. Willock getting a higher rating than Trott :lol: :lol: :lol:

To anyone who actually watched the game it was clear that Trott was outstanding and was man of the match (though some could argue for Robinson by vitrue of his 2 goals) Trott was literally the difference between the two sides. Had we swapped keepers at half time we would have lost about 7-3:

Trott was excellent and may well have been mom but I’d say that Willock was in the next group of players who did well.

Re: Today's player ratings

Sun Oct 05, 2025 6:38 pm

bluebirdoct1962 wrote:
JJ1927 wrote:Wha a load of nonsense those ratings are and just goes to show what drivel stat based analyses give. Willock getting a higher rating than Trott :lol: :lol: :lol:

To anyone who actually watched the game it was clear that Trott was outstanding and was man of the match (though some could argue for Robinson by vitrue of his 2 goals) Trott was literally the difference between the two sides. Had we swapped keepers at half time we would have lost about 7-3:

Trott was excellent and may well have been mom but I’d say that Willock was in the next group of players who did well.


Not saying Willock was bad but to put him above Trott is ridiculous.

Re: Today's player ratings

Sun Oct 05, 2025 7:06 pm

JJ1927 wrote:
bluebirdoct1962 wrote:
JJ1927 wrote:Wha a load of nonsense those ratings are and just goes to show what drivel stat based analyses give. Willock getting a higher rating than Trott :lol: :lol: :lol:

To anyone who actually watched the game it was clear that Trott was outstanding and was man of the match (though some could argue for Robinson by vitrue of his 2 goals) Trott was literally the difference between the two sides. Had we swapped keepers at half time we would have lost about 7-3:

Trott was excellent and may well have been mom but I’d say that Willock was in the next group of players who did well.


Not saying Willock was bad but to put him above Trott is ridiculous.

Fair enough mate :thumbup:

Re: Today's player ratings

Tue Oct 07, 2025 5:44 pm

KBK-13 wrote:
mugsy wrote:
KBK-13 wrote:Thought goal aside, lawlor was poor. Looked weak in every challenge.

Whole defence give the ball away constantly although Kpakio did improve 2nd half.

Disappointed Isaak Davies never got into the game at all, both full backs for Leyton Orient were poor. Kellyman changed the game and exposed the left back.

Trott despite conceding 3 made some huge saves.

Robinson took his goals well but didn't offer much else, doesn't press anywhere near as well as Salech


What game were you watching?- Lawlor was easily our best defender and got the goal as well. Wales Online gave him 9 out of 10 and rightly so in my opinion.


Being the best defender in a defence that gifted Leyton Orient chance after chance and made Aaron Connolly look like a world beater isn't an achievement.

Even BBM has said in his press conference it was a difficult afternoon for him.

Great goal yes, and on a few occasions he did well bringing the ball out but anytime there was a physical battle he would lose out.


I see Lawlor was named in the League 1 team of the week! I rest my case :)

Re: Today's player ratings

Wed Oct 08, 2025 1:42 pm

KBK-13 wrote:Thought goal aside, lawlor was poor. Looked weak in every challenge.

Whole defence give the ball away constantly although Kpakio did improve 2nd half.

Disappointed Isaak Davies never got into the game at all, both full backs for Leyton Orient were poor. Kellyman changed the game and exposed the left back.

Trott despite conceding 3 made some huge saves.

Robinson took his goals well but didn't offer much else, doesn't press anywhere near as well as Salech

Spot on.

Re: Today's player ratings

Wed Oct 08, 2025 1:43 pm

mugsy wrote:
KBK-13 wrote:
mugsy wrote:
KBK-13 wrote:Thought goal aside, lawlor was poor. Looked weak in every challenge.

Whole defence give the ball away constantly although Kpakio did improve 2nd half.

Disappointed Isaak Davies never got into the game at all, both full backs for Leyton Orient were poor. Kellyman changed the game and exposed the left back.

Trott despite conceding 3 made some huge saves.

Robinson took his goals well but didn't offer much else, doesn't press anywhere near as well as Salech


What game were you watching?- Lawlor was easily our best defender and got the goal as well. Wales Online gave him 9 out of 10 and rightly so in my opinion.


Being the best defender in a defence that gifted Leyton Orient chance after chance and made Aaron Connolly look like a world beater isn't an achievement.

Even BBM has said in his press conference it was a difficult afternoon for him.

Great goal yes, and on a few occasions he did well bringing the ball out but anytime there was a physical battle he would lose out.


I see Lawlor was named in the League 1 team of the week! I rest my case :)

Based off WhoScored player ratings...