Was it a penalty to Cardiff?

I believe it was:


Joel Colwill taken down in the box. Defender doesn't get near the ball. Somehow a goal kick.

You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Probably, but looks like linesman has decided the ball was out of play before the foul was committed.

The most obvious penalty I've ever seen. I'm absolutely stunned the ref missed it.

Probably, but looks like linesman has decided the ball was out of play before the foul was committed.

I said at time ball looked out so no pen...

My instant reaction was that it should have been a penalty.

Still think that after seeing the replay.

I reckon he would have given it if it was ten minutes later. They shouldn't think like it, but some referees don't like making big decisions early on.

Definitely a penalty.

Refs terrible league one level first thing I noticed

My instant reaction was that it should have been a penalty.

Still think that after seeing the replay.

I reckon he would have given it if it was ten minutes later. They shouldn't think like it, but some referees don't like making big decisions early on.

Ned that picture shows contact when ball clearly out of play! If lino sees that they can't give penalty ..... but ref crap again

My instant reaction was that it should have been a penalty.

Still think that after seeing the replay.

I reckon he would have given it if it was ten minutes later. They shouldn't think like it, but some referees don't like making big decisions early on.

Ned that picture shows contact when ball clearly out of play! If lino sees that they can't give penalty ..... but ref crap again

The tackle started way before that image.

My instant reaction was that it should have been a penalty.

Still think that after seeing the replay.

I reckon he would have given it if it was ten minutes later. They shouldn't think like it, but some referees don't like making big decisions early on.

Ned that picture shows contact when ball clearly out of play! If lino sees that they can't give penalty ..... but ref crap again

The tackle started way before that image.

but guess he thought contact was after ball was out play but who knows what the officials see?

Probably should have been a penalty say the radio Wales commentators.

Possibly another penalty in the 2nd half when Robinson had a shot blocked by a defender on the 6 yard box, when you consider the penalty given against the Everton defender yesterday.

Refs have been abysmal so far and it is by far the biggest drop in standards from Championship level.

How we didn't get a penalty for the push on Kpakio Saturday was mental. They're just scared to make any big decisions.

Possibly another penalty in the 2nd half when Robinson had a shot blocked by a defender on the 6 yard box, when you consider the penalty given against the Everton defender yesterday.

The fact their player was holding his face tells you he thought he was in trouble.

The ball wasn't anywhere near his head

We should have had 2 penalties refs are really poor in this league how did robbo miss that chance we got what we deserved though BLUEBIRDS

Clear penalty and could have had another . Dreadful officials again

Clear penalty and could have had another . Dreadful officials again

Agree .

My instant reaction was that it should have been a penalty.

Still think that after seeing the replay.

I reckon he would have given it if it was ten minutes later. They shouldn't think like it, but some referees don't like making big decisions early on.

Ned that picture shows contact when ball clearly out of play! If lino sees that they can't give penalty ..... but ref crap again

The tackle started way before that image.

I agree; that was just the end of it!

Wasn’t sure at the time, but on reflection, it was a penalty!

Refs have been abysmal so far and it is by far the biggest drop in standards from Championship level.

How we didn't get a penalty for the push on Kpakio Saturday was mental. They're just scared to make any big decisions.

Spot On .

My instant reaction was that it should have been a penalty.

Still think that after seeing the replay.

I reckon he would have given it if it was ten minutes later. They shouldn't think like it, but some referees don't like making big decisions early on.

Agreed it was too early otherwise given, there was a handball penalty shout too.