Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Player ratings for today

Sat Aug 02, 2025 3:10 pm

Turner 7.5
Solid, could see him shouting to his defenders

Kpakio 7.5
Really good goal, really good attacking, a little caught out at the end, all his throws were foul throws :)

Bagan 7.0
Solid as a rock, liked that from today

Fish 6.5
Gave the ball away a bit, gave a penalty away

Lawlor 6.5
Needed to be subbed, could have been sent off

Wintle 8.0
Glue that kept them together

Colwill, J 7.0
Ran a lot, improved a lot as the game went on

Colwill, R 8.5
Brilliant, looks like captaincy works for him

Ashford 6.0
Quiet, tried hard

Tanner 7.0
A bit erratic with some crosses but was always ready to take the ball

Salech 6.5
Should have scored the header, looked like a target man

Re: Player ratings for today

Sat Aug 02, 2025 3:14 pm

Wouldn't argue with that.

I thought Ashford and Fish were the weak links.

Hesitant to criticise Fish because I see a player there, but his passing wasn't at the same level of others.

Re: Player ratings for today

Sat Aug 02, 2025 9:02 pm

Ashford never looks interested, to me. No movement, only runs if the ball is at his feet.
Should been pulled well before half time.

Re: Player ratings for today

Sun Aug 03, 2025 9:21 am

I personally would of taken tanner and Ashford off halftime thought neither offered much. Ashford looked good cutting inside but missed so many opportunities to shoot or release pass and would run out of options. Tanner had a touch like John Leslie 1st half

Re: Player ratings for today

Sun Aug 03, 2025 9:26 am

gwentbluebirds wrote:I personally would of taken tanner and Ashford off halftime thought neither offered much. Ashford looked good cutting inside but missed so many opportunities to shoot or release pass and would run out of options. Tanner had a touch like John Leslie 1st half


Disagree with you on Tanner. Most of our attacking came down his side. Some players should have definitely finished from 1 or 2 of his crosses.

Re: Player ratings for today

Sun Aug 03, 2025 10:17 am

MorgCCFC wrote:
gwentbluebirds wrote:I personally would of taken tanner and Ashford off halftime thought neither offered much. Ashford looked good cutting inside but missed so many opportunities to shoot or release pass and would run out of options. Tanner had a touch like John Leslie 1st half


Disagree with you on Tanner. Most of our attacking came down his side. Some players should have definitely finished from 1 or 2 of his crosses.


2nd half he got better but 1st I thought he was poor apart from 1 or 2 crosses. His 1st touch and over run it few times

Re: Player ratings for today

Sun Aug 03, 2025 10:38 am

MorgCCFC wrote:
gwentbluebirds wrote:I personally would of taken tanner and Ashford off halftime thought neither offered much. Ashford looked good cutting inside but missed so many opportunities to shoot or release pass and would run out of options. Tanner had a touch like John Leslie 1st half


Disagree with you on Tanner. Most of our attacking came down his side. Some players should have definitely finished from 1 or 2 of his crosses.


Agree with this

Re: Player ratings for today

Sun Aug 03, 2025 11:39 am

maccydee wrote:
MorgCCFC wrote:
gwentbluebirds wrote:I personally would of taken tanner and Ashford off halftime thought neither offered much. Ashford looked good cutting inside but missed so many opportunities to shoot or release pass and would run out of options. Tanner had a touch like John Leslie 1st half


Disagree with you on Tanner. Most of our attacking came down his side. Some players should have definitely finished from 1 or 2 of his crosses.


Agree with this


I thought Tanner was very wasteful, kept his width and was always in acres of space but took the safe option every time apart from the cross he put onto Salechs head which he should have scored from.

Peterborough left full back was nowhere near him, would've liked to have seen him run at him and commit him more often instead of laying it back to Kpakio most times