Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Who stays who goes

Mon Apr 21, 2025 4:29 pm

What's your view obviously a big clear out if as it looks like we are going down.

Horvath/ Alnwick
NG/ Bagan
Fish/Daland/Chambers
Rinnamohta/Turnbull/Ramsay/ Ralls
Colwill/Robertson
Odowda/ Tanner/Willock/Ashford
Salech/Meite/ Simic/Etete

I haven't included Goutas he will be off
as will jamilu collins, plus the loans

Re: Who stays who goes

Mon Apr 21, 2025 4:34 pm

Bluebird 67 wrote:What's your view obviously a big clear out if as it looks like we are going down.

Horvath/ Alnwick - both to go
NG/ Bagan - get rid of both
Fish/Daland/Chambers - Fish remain, Daland not sure, Chambers got experience
Rinnamohta/Turnbull/Ramsay/ Ralls - keep Ramsay
Colwill/Robertson - keep both
Odowda/ Tanner/Willock/Ashford - Odowda and Ashford can stay
Salech/Meite/ Simic/Etete - Keep Salech

I haven't included Goutas he will be off
as will jamilu collins, plus the loans


MASSIVE CLEAR OUT OF THE RUBBISH

Re: Who stays who goes

Mon Apr 21, 2025 4:37 pm

Get rid of the lot and start again.

Re: Who stays who goes

Mon Apr 21, 2025 4:43 pm

The painter

Re: Who stays who goes

Mon Apr 21, 2025 5:22 pm

Nice to see the vultures picking scraps of the carcass of a team still alive

Re: Who stays who goes

Mon Apr 21, 2025 5:51 pm

pembroke allan wrote:Nice to see the vultures picking scraps of the carcass of a team still alive



Allan, there have been only a few fleeting moments when this team has been alive!

Re: Who stays who goes

Mon Apr 21, 2025 8:47 pm

Horvath/ Alnwick-Both Out
NG-Out,
Daland-Out
Chambers-50/50
Rinnamohta-Stay
Turnbull-Out
Ramsay-Out
Ralls-Out
Colwill-Out
Robertson-50/50
Odowda-stay
Tanner-Out
Willock-Out
Ashford-stay
Salech-Stay
Meite-Out
Simic-no idea havnt seen him
Etete-Out

Said same about Ebou Adams now look at him

Re: Who stays who goes

Mon Apr 21, 2025 9:10 pm

Horvath - Leave
Alnwick - Stay
NG - Stay
Fish - Stay
Daaland - Stay
Goutas - Leave (I'd keep if possible)
Bagan - Stay
Collins - Leave
Willock - Leave
Ashford - Stay
O'Dowda - Stay
Davies - Stay
Chambers - Leave
Turnbull - Stay
Robertson- Stay
Ralls - Stay
Ramsey - Leave
Colwill - Leave
Salech - Stay
Robinson - Stay
Meite- Leave
Tanner - Stay

I don't see many teams coming in for any of our players

Re: Who stays who goes

Mon Apr 21, 2025 9:40 pm

Meite, ElGarzi,Collins, Goutas, Ralls, Ramsey, Evans, Rinomhota all up this year I'd offer Rinomhota a deal, but he hasn't been treated well

for another season
Alnwick, Davies, NG, Bagan, Turner - Can't see any championship clubs in for those

2 seasons
Turnbull, Chambers, Robinson, Willock, Howeth, Tanner, Colwill, Ashford, Wintle, Tsoundo

3 seasons
Daland, Simic, Co'D, Robertson, Fish, Etete,

4 seasons
Salech


That 2-seasons group of Turnbull, Chambers, Robinson, Willock, Colwill, Ashford, Wintle may get inquired and we don't need to listen to offers about Salech unless they are big

Re: Who stays who goes

Mon Apr 21, 2025 10:10 pm

llan bluebird wrote:Meite, ElGarzi,Collins, Goutas, Ralls, Ramsey, Evans, Rinomhota all up this year I'd offer Rinomhota a deal, but he hasn't been treated well

for another season
Alnwick, Davies, NG, Bagan, Turner - Can't see any championship clubs in for those

2 seasons
Turnbull, Chambers, Robinson, Willock, Howeth, Tanner, Colwill, Ashford, Wintle, Tsoundo

3 seasons
Daland, Simic, Co'D, Robertson, Fish, Etete,

4 seasons
Salech


That 2-seasons group of Turnbull, Chambers, Robinson, Willock, Colwill, Ashford, Wintle may get inquired and we don't need to listen to offers about Salech unless they are big



Salech is ghe one asset that should not be sold under any circumstances if we are to recover from this seasons debacle.

Re: Who stays who goes

Mon Apr 21, 2025 10:15 pm

llan bluebird wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:Nice to see the vultures picking scraps of the carcass of a team still alive



Allan, there have been only a few fleeting moments when this team has been alive!



Agree but sorry . ...to say we can't win a game of football is nonsense no matter how bad we've been....and to get rid of players before we know where we are is speculation at best and picking the bones off a club still fighting if can call it that? :o

Re: Who stays who goes

Tue Apr 22, 2025 5:44 am

Allan I applaud your optimison I really doubt picking the bones of a club still fighting is a bit dramatic and since Xmas i haven't seen much fighting

Re: Who stays who goes

Tue Apr 22, 2025 12:07 pm

The way i feel about the losers all season i would get rid of all of them, i'm furious with the whole gutless squad.

Re: Who stays who goes

Tue Apr 22, 2025 1:18 pm

Bluebird 67 wrote:Allan I applaud your optimison I really doubt picking the bones of a club still fighting is a bit dramatic and since Xmas i haven't seen much fighting



As I said if thats what they call it? :laughing6:
Most fans start a season optimistic but it can soon fade obviously optimism under fiza vanished very quickly but with new manager needed optimism springs eternal. Again . :P

Re: Who stays who goes

Tue Apr 22, 2025 1:41 pm

It sums up this season when I’m having to wrack my brains to think of players I’d like to keep. The only player I’d be disappointed to lose is……

Salech

I honestly think that’s it. The rest I could easily let go.