Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Re: “ Timeo Whisker “

Fri Mar 15, 2024 6:31 pm

Tonteg Bluebird wrote:This is yet another example showing we are bringing good youngsters through. Unfortunately, all our best youngsters are currently getting poached.

Still, it's very unfair to criticise some of the academy scouts/coaching staff when we have had Man City and Man Utd poaching some of our best youngsters within the past 12 months.

There is nothing Darren Purse, Gavin Chesterfield etc can do about that, so they're left with working with the youngsters they have left.
totally agree ,I've been saying this for years .

Re: “ Timeo Whisker “

Sat Mar 16, 2024 9:18 am

So if we are a cat 1 academy. We not allow to seek players to other cat 1 academy’s?

Re: “ Timeo Whisker “

Sat Mar 16, 2024 11:15 am

He'll become a little fish in a big pond.
Look at the Man City guy on loan to us
Does anybody really think he break into the Man City first team?

Re: “ Timeo Whisker “

Sat Mar 16, 2024 12:05 pm

Iceblue wrote:So if we are a cat 1 academy. We not allow to seek players to other cat 1 academy’s?



No cannot just take a player from another cat 1 academy like man c done..... but you can sign a youngster from one if it is done for benefit of youngster education and well being but its very strict criteria...

Re: “ Timeo Whisker “

Sat Mar 16, 2024 12:10 pm

pembroke allan wrote:
Iceblue wrote:So if we are a cat 1 academy. We not allow to seek players to other cat 1 academy’s?



No cannot just take a player from another cat 1 academy like man c done..... but you can sign a youngster from one if it is done for benefit of youngster education and well being but its very strict criteria...


Cheers for that. So even if we were cat 1 we probably lose him anyway. Like some else said why wouldn’t he want to go to Man City?

Re: “ Timeo Whisker “

Sat Mar 16, 2024 12:10 pm

It's happening to Ipswich now they've got a wonder kid " silva mexex" who man u look like signing! but as attracted interest from every cat 1 academy in premier league who want him.....

Re: “ Timeo Whisker “

Sat Mar 16, 2024 12:19 pm

Iceblue wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:
Iceblue wrote:So if we are a cat 1 academy. We not allow to seek players to other cat 1 academy’s?



No cannot just take a player from another cat 1 academy like man c done..... but you can sign a youngster from one if it is done for benefit of youngster education and well being but its very strict criteria...


Cheers for that. So even if we were cat 1 we probably lose him anyway. Like some else said why wouldn’t he want to go to Man City?



Not unless there was a reason that outways him staying at city......like said there are very strict criteria and it doesn't happen that much no matter who the team is... a youngster wanting to join man c because they are big club is not enough reason for him to go there ... like said clubs been done man c real Madrid included for taking youngsters illegally ..... this is why cat 1 is essential but it is expensive 3m+ a season to run? Luckily city now have the facility to make it work successfully if done right.

Re: “ Timeo Whisker “

Sun Mar 17, 2024 11:27 am

Even cat 1 status you not safe leeds lost player to man c! Seems like man c and others are boasting of playing academy players when in fact they are stealing other clubs talent as their own .....

Re: “ Timeo Whisker “

Mon Mar 18, 2024 12:45 am

Man c are in process of getting a 14yr old wonder kid from usa! Rated best in world at age group Seems like they are scouring the world and sweeping up all the kids it can
Find for its academy... not sure what's happened to the laws on signing kids but looks like man c have found a way of getting these kids despite the rules to stop such practices....
Ps conspiracy pheory..... all sales of players brought through an academy are classed as 100% profit when sold..... clubs using them to help get around ffp.

Re: “ Timeo Whisker “

Mon Mar 18, 2024 6:47 am

pembroke allan wrote:Man c are in process of getting a 14yr old wonder kid from usa! Rated best in world at age group Seems like they are scouring the world and sweeping up all the kids it can
Find for its academy... not sure what's happened to the laws on signing kids but looks like man c have found a way of getting these kids despite the rules to stop such practices....
Ps conspiracy pheory..... all sales of players brought through an academy are classed as 100% profit when sold..... clubs using them to help get around ffp.


Sounds plausible. Think you’re on to something there.

Re: “ Timeo Whisker “

Mon Mar 18, 2024 11:28 am

Iceblue wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:Man c are in process of getting a 14yr old wonder kid from usa! Rated best in world at age group Seems like they are scouring the world and sweeping up all the kids it can
Find for its academy... not sure what's happened to the laws on signing kids but looks like man c have found a way of getting these kids despite the rules to stop such practices....
Ps conspiracy pheory..... all sales of players brought through an academy are classed as 100% profit when sold..... clubs using them to help get around ffp.


Sounds plausible. Think you’re on to something there.



Chelsea could fall faul of ffp unless they can offload few of their academy players and Chelsea have plenty.... what must remember most of these kids never get to 1st team but can demand fees of 15m+ in the overinflated premier league...