Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

UODATED: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Fri Nov 25, 2022 8:53 pm

After defeat for Wales v Iran, tonight's draw between England and USA leave Wales needing nothing but a win by two or more goals and USA to draw v Iran to have any chance of progressing from the group

A disappointing day but still something to fight for as it stands... :thumbup:

Note: My error: a single goal win will be enough...! :thumbup:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Fri Nov 25, 2022 8:57 pm

Sven wrote:After defeat for Wales v Iran, tonight's draw between England and USA leave Wales needing nothing but a win by two clear goals and USA to draw v Iran to have any chance of progressing from the group

A disappointing day but still something to fight for as it stands... :thumbup:



I thought that earlier but iran as got minus 2 we got minus 1 so if they draw it be same if we win be + or =goal difference?

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Fri Nov 25, 2022 8:59 pm

I’ve come on here tonight for this exact reason. So if Wales beat England and USA draw with Iran, that will put us second on GD behind England and ahead of Iran in 3rd. All teams on 4 points.

My question is what is the order for deciding teams on the same points? Is it GD (+ or -), then goals for, then if still equal, based on the head to head result?
Last edited by 103 Barmy Army on Fri Nov 25, 2022 9:00 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Fri Nov 25, 2022 9:00 pm

There is more chance of my hair growing back than there is of Wales beating England by 2 goals ( and I've been bald for 40 years )!

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Fri Nov 25, 2022 9:02 pm

103 Barmy Army wrote:I’ve come on here tonight for this exact reason. So if Wales beat England and USA draw with Iran, that will put us second on GD behind England and ahead of Iran in 3rd. All teams on 4 points.

My question is what is the order for deciding teams on the same points? Is it GD (+ or -), then goals for, then if still equal, based on the head to head result?



2022 World Cup group tiebreakers: What happens when teams are level on points
Grroup points.
Group goal difference. Unlike in UEFA competitions like the Champions League, head-to-head record isn't the next tiebreaker. ...
Group goals scored. ...
Head-to-head record. ...
Fair play record. ...
Drawing of lots.

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Fri Nov 25, 2022 9:03 pm

Right iran and Wales-2 goals if iran draw still-2 a win for us will give us at least -1 so we go through dont we? ... and way England played who knows.
Last edited by pembroke allan on Fri Nov 25, 2022 9:04 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Fri Nov 25, 2022 9:03 pm

Yes we need to beat England...

If we beat England and the others draw we're through on goal difference.

Otherwise we need to win by four goals, not sure if it is three because our goal difference with England will be the same.

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Fri Nov 25, 2022 9:06 pm

Einstein wrote:Yes we need to beat England...

If we beat England and the others draw we're through on goal difference.

Otherwise we need to win by four goals, not sure if it is three because our goal difference with England will be the same.



Think its 6 goals? They got +4 we got minus 2 6 nil we would win as scored 7 to their 6

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Fri Nov 25, 2022 9:45 pm

Let's not prolong the agony any further. We have no chance of winning against England. Page has messed up lost any Hooe of getting out of the group with his no idea of team selection wrong tactics and below average players. To think of all the work previous Managers have done to see it all ruined in 2 matches by a Manager who hasent a clue and a Dad's Army team. At the end of this world cup someone will get the Golden Boot award I hope another boot will be given to a certain Rob Page or Wales will go from bad to worse. Wales need to try and carry on what previous Managers have done and bring in young talent not rely on the old players some who Page thinks should still be in the team. Having to revert back to using players from the bottom ieague is a joke he is taking us backwards he needs to go after this world cup.

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Fri Nov 25, 2022 9:56 pm

put simply wales have no chance, they'll bang 4 or 5 past us, they knew what they were doing tonight pretending to be useless, we'll be mauled!

5 nil 50/1 and 4 nil 33/1 - little fiver and lots of money tuesday night for me

nice to make the finals but today was the day and they blew it

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sat Nov 26, 2022 12:55 am

Page isn't the best tactician but we're a small nation with an ageing side. Let's hope the Welsh F.A. have invested in the future. It could be a few barren years when Bale and Ramsey retire.

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sat Nov 26, 2022 11:10 am

Put simply- based on the last 2 performances Wales are out of the World Cup. It has been an amazing achievement and all credit to the team. Everyone enjoy the last game and be thankful for the experience. Wales need to continue building on our recent successes, rebuild with the youngsters and look towards the Euro's. Hopeful Page has learned a lot this time around and can take us forward? Bale/Ramsey/Allen future? Tbc. Good luck against England.

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sat Nov 26, 2022 11:28 am

FOOTSOLDIER wrote:Put simply- based on the last 2 performances Wales are out of the World Cup. It has been an amazing achievement and all credit to the team. Everyone enjoy the last game and be thankful for the experience. Wales need to continue building on our recent successes, rebuild with the youngsters and look towards the Euro's. Hopeful Page has learned a lot this time around and can take us forward? Bale/Ramsey/Allen future? Tbc. Good luck against England.



Allen and williams time is up.... rambo depends on what he does next? He needs game time at a club not bit part substitute appearances... bale let's wait see he as got pre season with LA to get properly fit... mls season starts feb before euros start in March ... neither are too old given the age of some of good players
in wc... but unless they stay fit and playing regularly we cannot carry them in upcoming campaign.

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sat Nov 26, 2022 11:46 am

MikeP wrote:Let's not prolong the agony any further. We have no chance of winning against England. Page has messed up lost any Hooe of getting out of the group with his no idea of team selection wrong tactics and below average players. To think of all the work previous Managers have done to see it all ruined in 2 matches by a Manager who hasent a clue and a Dad's Army team. At the end of this world cup someone will get the Golden Boot award I hope another boot will be given to a certain Rob Page or Wales will go from bad to worse. Wales need to try and carry on what previous Managers have done and bring in young talent not rely on the old players some who Page thinks should still be in the team. Having to revert back to using players from the bottom ieague is a joke he is taking us backwards he needs to go after this world cup.

"Having to revert back to using players from the bottom ieague is a joke "
You can citicize his team selection and tactics but everyone who started the game yesterday has played in the Premier League or a top European league in the last six months or so. I would expect such players to be able to put two passes together.

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sat Nov 26, 2022 7:59 pm

pembroke allan wrote:
Einstein wrote:Yes we need to beat England...

If we beat England and the others draw we're through on goal difference.

Otherwise we need to win by four goals, not sure if it is three because our goal difference with England will be the same.



Think its 6 goals? They got +4 we got minus 2 6 nil we would win as scored 7 to their 6


No if we score 4 that would make England plus 0 and us plus 1 not that we are likely to beat them by 4-0 though

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sat Nov 26, 2022 8:40 pm

rontom wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:
Einstein wrote:Yes we need to beat England...

If we beat England and the others draw we're through on goal difference.

Otherwise we need to win by four goals, not sure if it is three because our goal difference with England will be the same.



Think its 6 goals? They got +4 we got minus 2 6 nil we would win as scored 7 to their 6


No if we score 4 that would make England plus 0 and us plus 1 not that we are likely to beat them by 4-0 though



Take England out of equation.... iran minus 2 wales minus 2 if we win by 1-0 and iran draw it will
be 4pts each we'll have minus 1 to their minus 2
So we fo through.... 1-0 is not impossible :D

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sun Nov 27, 2022 12:06 am

pembroke allan wrote:
rontom wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:
Einstein wrote:Yes we need to beat England...

If we beat England and the others draw we're through on goal difference.

Otherwise we need to win by four goals, not sure if it is three because our goal difference with England will be the same.



Think its 6 goals? They got +4 we got minus 2 6 nil we would win as scored 7 to their 6


No if we score 4 that would make England plus 0 and us plus 1 not that we are likely to beat them by 4-0 though



Take England out of equation.... iran minus 2 wales minus 2 if we win by 1-0 and iran draw it will
be 4pts each we'll have minus 1 to their minus 2
So we fo through.... 1-0 is not impossible :D


Spot On ;)

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sun Nov 27, 2022 11:58 am

If people think its impossible for wales to beat England should take a look at Costa Rica as inspiration? Two games just one shot on target in 180mins but got 3 points
Beat Japan today despite conceding 7 against Spain in 1st game... :o

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sun Nov 27, 2022 12:51 pm

Sorry to say but it will be how many will england score love to see us finally beating england but they have a lot better team than us
quality and youth and the iceland video buzzing in there heads what do we have to motivate us
We stood a much better chance in the euros 2016 but that was a different team and so was england they have moved on with there youth players
has page and will he play the youth
and the 5 at the back is getting very boring dreading getting a hiding and if thats the case it should signal the end and on to the next page.

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sun Nov 27, 2022 1:10 pm

montyblue wrote:Sorry to say but it will be how many will england score love to see us finally beating england but they have a lot better team than us
quality and youth and the iceland video buzzing in there heads what do we have to motivate us
We stood a much better chance in the euros 2016 but that was a different team and so was england they have moved on with there youth players
has page and will he play the youth
and the 5 at the back is getting very boring dreading getting a hiding and if thats the case it should signal the end and on to the next page.




Costa Rica are the poorest side in WC yet they beat a team that would give wales at their best a game? you dont think wales can win but it is a case of How many England score? Okey!!

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sun Nov 27, 2022 2:12 pm

PEMBROKE ALLAN

sorry to be so negative allan but wish i could be more optimistic i teally do but if ever thete was a game we should hsve gone for heart and soul it was the iran game and the plauers manager system whatever we did not produce it and i don' t think we have the same heart in this team as in the euros and a lot of that is down to the manager he just seems to placid i like animated managers on the side line like warnock not some quite deep thinker who is frightened to tell 2 players that they have to do a lot better .

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sun Nov 27, 2022 2:40 pm

montyblue wrote:PEMBROKE ALLAN

sorry to be so negative allan but wish i could be more optimistic i teally do but if ever thete was a game we should hsve gone for heart and soul it was the iran game and the plauers manager system whatever we did not produce it and i don' t think we have the same heart in this team as in the euros and a lot of that is down to the manager he just seems to placid i like animated managers on the side line like warnock not some quite deep thinker who is frightened to tell 2 players that they have to do a lot better .



Monty I know what you mean .... and I've said long ago page is to defensively minded vin general... yes it's ok in those final games leading upto WC as results was the most important thing.... but to be like it against two sides that we had reasonable chance of beating is non sensicle in a WC with little margin for error ! Going on to bale Rambo its pages tactics that as caused them to look useless I always thought you play to strengths but page is doing opposite especially with Rambo....only comfort can take is playing England is better than playing a foreign team as styles more equal ...
Ps computer says we have 2% chance of winning 4-0 but 40% 1-0
Not given up yet but knowing our luck we win and the other game a team wins aswell .

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sun Nov 27, 2022 3:03 pm

Looking at some of the results this WC its quite extraordinary two teams concede 6 & 7 goals in opening game they then go on to win next game... result is 3 of europes best teams are in danger of going out at group stage with other big names at risk as well.. all because smaller nations go out and beat bigger teams.

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sun Nov 27, 2022 3:25 pm

mugsy wrote:There is more chance of my hair growing back than there is of Wales beating England by 2 goals ( and I've been bald for 40 years )!

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sun Nov 27, 2022 3:27 pm

Richy roofer ccfc wrote:
mugsy wrote:There is more chance of my hair growing back than there is of Wales beating England by 2 goals ( and I've been bald for 40 years )!



1 goal could do it ? :mrgreen:

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sun Nov 27, 2022 3:40 pm

Richy roofer ccfc wrote:
mugsy wrote:There is more chance of my hair growing back than there is of Wales beating England by 2 goals ( and I've been bald for 40 years )!

Bang on mate , as if we gonna beat them

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sun Nov 27, 2022 9:22 pm

pembroke allan wrote:
rontom wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:
Einstein wrote:Yes we need to beat England...

If we beat England and the others draw we're through on goal difference.

Otherwise we need to win by four goals, not sure if it is three because our goal difference with England will be the same.



Think its 6 goals? They got +4 we got minus 2 6 nil we would win as scored 7 to their 6


No if we score 4 that would make England plus 0 and us plus 1 not that we are likely to beat them by 4-0 though



Take England out of equation.... iran minus 2 wales minus 2 if we win by 1-0 and iran draw it will
be 4pts each we'll have minus 1 to their minus 2

Was not saying that it was impossible to beat England, but was just pointing out your maths are completely wrong
So we fo through.... 1-0 is not impossible :D

Re: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sun Nov 27, 2022 9:30 pm

rontom wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:
rontom wrote:
pembroke allan wrote:
Einstein wrote:Yes we need to beat England...

If we beat England and the others draw we're through on goal difference.

Otherwise we need to win by four goals, not sure if it is three because our goal difference with England will be the same.



Think its 6 goals? They got +4 we got minus 2 6 nil we would win as scored 7 to their 6


No if we score 4 that would make England plus 0 and us plus 1 not that we are likely to beat them by 4-0 though



Take England out of equation.... iran minus 2 wales minus 2 if we win by 1-0 and iran draw it will
be 4pts each we'll have minus 1 to their minus 2

Was not saying that it was impossible to beat England, but was just pointing out your maths are completely wrong
So we fo through.... 1-0 is not impossible :D



Yes the figures were wrong but not equation of one goal ? :mrgreen: 1 nil is feasible by anyones reckoning.. :malky:

Re: UODATED: PUT SIMPLY: WALES HAVE TO BEAT ENGLAND

Sun Nov 27, 2022 9:31 pm

It's a FA cup clash, but the underdogs never win by 4 goals.