Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 3:12 pm

I am worried with what hudson has which is a lack of experiance a team void of any fight a left back he keeps playing who is costing us points and hudson was morrisons defence coach


He says he and tan have a plan in January what about "now"

Hudson reminds me of neil harris a nodding dog to tan if you have a olan tell us january is a long time away nearly every fan kniws what we need ehich is 2 quality strikers which could cost 20 million plus is tan going to fork out that sort of money and would we attract anyone been in the bottom 5



I fear hudson is not going to demand an x ammount of money to be spent
and is very careful how he words things to fans so we are non the wiser to what is happening off the field and behind the scenes
I cannot see hudson getting us out of our postion


Burnley got rid of dyche and brought in quality manger in vincent company and bellers not a caretaker snd are top of the league

Norwich i understand are not happy with there manager and are looking to change even thought
tgey are 5th in the division
We are nearly 5th from bottom and we have just awarded our caretaker manager for the 2nd season running with a contract

We have a team of loans and a promise from tan and hudson that january we as fans are all going to be exited
a bit like what morrison said before he got the boot
The seasins are getting worse with no togetherness from owner board to fans no communication from manager to fans as to what we are to be exited about ?
At least tan witnessed what we have been looking at midweek another loss empty stadiums but does he feel the pain like us?

All i heard was a sarcky comment that we should come up with a welsh billionare to buy the club off him if you want to progress
thats going to pull us all together as a club

I fear hudson is not the man to tell tan how it is and should be


sorry for such a depressing outlook but a hope things change soon with owner board and manager somewhere along the lines of what wrexham are doing as a club togetherness exitment for the future in these very depressing times


football is supposed to be a release from day to day grind not adding to it.

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 4:06 pm

Yea I agree ,we got this new system of playing out from the back, but we don't seem to be very good at it sometime times on Saturday I just itched for our goalie to give it a good punt up the pitch ,,sorry

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 4:10 pm

Probably not right choice but there again any manager who came in would have same problem as Hudson scoring goals? We created the chances that is definite and yesterday was indicative of our season ... so will someone else do better ? Not sure they will as they can't make Harris ect score from the chances created.... despite the results it's the one problem putting us at the bottom and it's not defence is it?

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 4:11 pm

SCOULARMAN

Do you mean "hoofball"

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 4:25 pm

PEMBROKE ALLAN

Why do we see so many manager changes througout foitball and having the same players infront of them suddenly get a tune out of them is that down
all to luck then
or understanding and seeing with what is infront of them on the training ground i cannot for the life of me along with most fans see what hudson see' s in our left back as a defence coach?
The guy has been shocking as a defender worse i have seen that's why i suggested he would be a better winger
great going forward and taking on people
he reminds me of oumar niasse another sh.t product from everton and could not coordinate his legs

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 4:30 pm

no, he needed to be the assistant to an experienced guy. You just don't cut your teeth at a struggling club in the championship. I am so glad of this break, I think we all need it.

I think we will end up more a DJ team than Malky, we didn't toss around at the back then but we were hardly boring

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 4:37 pm

LLAN BLUEBIRD

Agree you mean like bellers at burnley under vincent company and are top of the championship.

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 4:38 pm

Jury is definitely out ,I just hope he's allowed to bring in players in January, 1 or 2 strikers ,a winger and a left back .we have been very wasteful in front of goal ,he sorts this out and we will climb the table rapidly, we've been competitive in all his games .

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 4:45 pm

WEZ 1927

I agree we have been competitive in all his games as manager
but tactically all over the place play great one half sh.t the 2nd half because of changes he' s made looked like a different team
or tactically sat back when we should be going forward
this imo is where he is going missing not so much what he has infront of him but tactics.

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 4:45 pm

Scoularman wrote:Yea I agree ,we got this new system of playing out from the back, but we don't seem to be very good at it sometime times on Saturday I just itched for our goalie to give it a good punt up the pitch ,,sorry


Strange you say that today. I thought we played more long balls yesterday than we have all season.
On Hudson, I’m not convinced tbh. Even though I want him or any other CCFC manager to succeed.
We seem to be suffering a game of two halves under both managers this season. Yesterday we were all over them 1st half. 2nd half was a completely different game.
We seem to have the ability to take on anyone, but then go to pot. It’s quite weird watching it happen.

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 4:49 pm

Yea that's it montyblue hoof ball ha

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 4:50 pm

SIMPLESIMON

This is what i just said to wez we are like 2 different teams changing things around for the worse not the better basically

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 4:54 pm

Not right appointment at all we all know and results and performances prove it

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 5:00 pm

wez1927 wrote:Jury is definitely out ,I just hope he's allowed to bring in players in January, 1 or 2 strikers ,a winger and a left back .we have been very wasteful in front of goal ,he sorts this out and we will climb the table rapidly, we've been competitive in all his games .



Yes probably another Watters and they will bullshit and say £1mill lol and another Etete who had not cost us a penny so far, only after 20 games we pay for him, but to me he’s a donkey

Do you honestly believe Tan will really back Mark Hudson ? With quality?

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 5:06 pm

Scoularman wrote:Yea I agree ,we got this new system of playing out from the back, but we don't seem to be very good at it sometime times on Saturday I just itched for our goalie to give it a good punt up the pitch ,,sorry

…to our one striker who stands 5,10. No thanks.

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 5:08 pm

FOREVER BLUE

I cannot see tan spending what we all know we need but equally i cannot see hudson demanding it and telling him there is only so much you can get out of some players and some sadly are not upto it
Watters should not be in the championship
Perhaps we should hang onto him though the way we are going we are not going to be in the championship either
Very depressing at the moment budd.

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 5:13 pm

montyblue wrote:PEMBROKE ALLAN

Why do we see so many manager changes througout foitball and having the same players infront of them suddenly get a tune out of them is that down
all to luck then
or understanding and seeing with what is infront of them on the training ground i cannot for the life of me along with most fans see what hudson see' s in our left back as a defence coach?
The guy has been shocking as a defender worse i have seen that's why i suggested he would be a better winger
great going forward and taking on people
he reminds me of oumar niasse another sh.t product from everton and could not coordinate his legs



Yes new manager can get a tune out of players that previous one couldn't.... but in citys case it's not the team or manager that's the problem it's the ability to take the chances created is the problem? .. we are more than competitive in games like yesterday so do you think if scored the two clear chances in 1st half there would have been different result? For this reason dont know how a different manager can make strikers score from chances created... luckily I have good vantage point st games and see the bigger picture on the game and tbh thetes not much wrong that a proper striker couldn't put right in regards to winning games.

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 5:22 pm

PEMBROKE ALLAN

I agree we could have had 2 1st half but my beef is with managers tactics changing anf looking like a completly different team from one half to the other we have dominated games in 1st half and changed tactics 2nd and fissled out of the game
If we kept playing against sheffield the same in the 2nd half we could have got something out of the game
Law of averages etc
Just glad we have this break to perhaps get some players back amd give hudson time to head scratch

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 5:29 pm

montyblue wrote:PEMBROKE ALLAN

I agree we could have had 2 1st half but my beef is with managers tactics changing anf looking like a completly different team from one half to the other we have dominated games in 1st half and changed tactics 2nd and fissled out of the game
If we kept playing against sheffield the same in the 2nd half we could have got something out of the game
Law of averages etc
Just glad we have this break to perhaps get some players back amd give hudson time to head scratch




Have said previously Hudson for whatever reason doesn't keep team playing same way throughout game.... his substitutions tend to be done but changing tactics doesn't go with changes ... I said halftime sheff will change tactics which they did we were ok until that mistake but our subs didn't do anything to change way game was going hence sheff controlled the game but we still made couple of excellent chances that maybe an instinctive striker would have taken at least one of them. Like I said despite what some say we are not far off being mid to higher end championship side unfortunately we lack the one thing to succeed in this.... a "striker "

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 7:07 pm

Forever Blue wrote:
wez1927 wrote:Jury is definitely out ,I just hope he's allowed to bring in players in January, 1 or 2 strikers ,a winger and a left back .we have been very wasteful in front of goal ,he sorts this out and we will climb the table rapidly, we've been competitive in all his games .



Yes probably another Watters and they will bullshit and say £1mill lol and another Etete who had not cost us a penny so far, only after 20 games we pay for him, but to me he’s a donkey

Do you honestly believe Tan will really back Mark Hudson ? With quality?

We will have to wait and see in January. He backed Morison with calum Robinson so hopefully yes.

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 7:31 pm

wez1927 wrote:
Forever Blue wrote:
wez1927 wrote:Jury is definitely out ,I just hope he's allowed to bring in players in January, 1 or 2 strikers ,a winger and a left back .we have been very wasteful in front of goal ,he sorts this out and we will climb the table rapidly, we've been competitive in all his games .



Yes probably another Watters and they will bullshit and say £1mill lol and another Etete who had not cost us a penny so far, only after 20 games we pay for him, but to me he’s a donkey

Do you honestly believe Tan will really back Mark Hudson ? With quality?

We will have to wait and see in January. He backed Morison with calum Robinson so hopefully yes.



You suspect it would depend on where city are come January?

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 7:36 pm

wez1927 wrote:Jury is definitely out ,I just hope he's allowed to bring in players in January, 1 or 2 strikers ,a winger and a left back .we have been very wasteful in front of goal ,he sorts this out and we will climb the table rapidly, we've been competitive in all his games .

^^^^THIS^^^^ :ayatollah:

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 8:29 pm

We’ll soon see. Come next January, when he (Hudson), recently said VT had a plan for our Club,,, and that he was “Very excited” about it,,, ?

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 9:33 pm

I'd guess Hudson will be backed the same way Morison was last January and allowed to bring in decent loans that should keep us clear of relegation.

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Sun Nov 13, 2022 10:22 pm

wez1927


Do you call a last minute deal for 1.5milliom for callum robinson who is not a striker backing from tan "give me a break"

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Mon Nov 14, 2022 12:49 pm

montyblue wrote:PEMBROKE ALLAN

I agree we could have had 2 1st half but my beef is with managers tactics changing anf looking like a completly different team from one half to the other we have dominated games in 1st half and changed tactics 2nd and fissled out of the game
If we kept playing against sheffield the same in the 2nd half we could have got something out of the game
Law of averages etc
Just glad we have this break to perhaps get some players back amd give hudson time to head scratch


Strikers who will gamble with the odd shot may help our scoring record?

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Mon Nov 14, 2022 9:21 pm

It lools like we are going to have to wait and see what the top secret plan Tan and hudson are going to reveal in Januaryand why we are going to be exited BALE.

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Mon Nov 14, 2022 9:38 pm

BC-CB wrote:
montyblue wrote:PEMBROKE ALLAN

I agree we could have had 2 1st half but my beef is with managers tactics changing anf looking like a completly different team from one half to the other we have dominated games in 1st half and changed tactics 2nd and fissled out of the game
If we kept playing against sheffield the same in the 2nd half we could have got something out of the game
Law of averages etc
Just glad we have this break to perhaps get some players back amd give hudson time to head scratch


Strikers who will gamble with the odd shot may help our scoring record?



A lot if time it's the decision making is the problem take the Robinson blocked shot after Harris balls up? We had a player couple yards from him in open space easier to pass to him and surely a goal but he shot with a block always likely... if you look at throughout games this kind thing happens s lot pass instead of shooting... shooting instead of passing no wonder poor goalscoring record..

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Mon Nov 14, 2022 10:03 pm

I really hope i am wrong but it a no from me.

Re: IS HUDSON THE RIGHT CHOICE GOING FORWARD

Tue Nov 15, 2022 12:18 am

Simply NO, we're hemmoriging points, Morrison was supposed to get players in but totally failed to get any half decent striker/s.
Hudson can't work with the players he has and I don't believe there's any money left in the kitty by Tan to get anyone decent in the January window.
We're going to be League one next season.