CRAIG BELLAMY V SCOTT SINCLAIR

http://forum.planetswans.co.uk/viewtopi ... =6&t=83914

How can you compare Sinclair with Bellamy FFS.

To say he is a better player is a joke to.

They dont really believe it but they want to believe it.
One worth 12m one worth 500k

He's scored more goals than him this season, but this is a joke. how many first team games did Sinclair have for chelsea?? and how many did Bellamy have for Man city.

They make me laugh fair play ?

At this moment and on the field, Sinclair is contributing more to Swansea's season than Craig is to ours.

Not sure how we can argue otherwise.

At this moment and on the field, Sinclair is contributing more to Swansea's season than Craig is to ours.

Not sure how we can argue otherwise.

Contribution wise yes i agree, but to compare Sinclair as a better player is a joke.

Bellamy's done it at the highest level, Champions League, Premier League. It was only his attitude that has alienated him from the managers and team-mates at the clubs he's been at. There's no doubting his ability, it's well proven. Sinclair was jettisoned from Chelsea and no Premiership club seemed to be prepared to take him on, either on loan or permanently. This seems to be his level.

However, I do agree that, on current form, Sinclair is contributing more to swansea than Bellamy is to us

Sinclair is an excellent signing for the pegsellers

I dont know why you continue to give them attention.

Personally I always thought Trevor Sinclair was a waste of money.

rofl

Personally I always thought Trevor Sinclair was a waste of money.

Personally I always thought Trevor Sinclair was a waste of money.

lol, sorry bro!

Personally I always thought Trevor Sinclair was a waste of money.

lol, sorry bro!

ive changed the thread title now.

At this moment and on the field, Sinclair is contributing more to Swansea's season than Craig is to ours.

Not sure how we can argue otherwise.

Totally correct. In the treatment room Bellamy ain't worth jot. Sinclair has had a bigger impact on Swansea's season than Bellamy has had on ours thus far.

http://forum.planetswans.co.uk/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=83914

How can you compare Sinclair with Bellamy FFS.

To say he is a better player is a joke to.

thats the jacks for you, talk utter nonsense.

i cant face talking to the fuckers in work most of the time.

A Jack just trying to make the comparison on the real sports phone in

Not worth talking about to be honest. Sinclair is a good player young too a real good signing for the Jacks but Bellamy could have gone to most Prem teams as he has proved he is prem class so see where Sinclair is in a couple of years.

The way I see it is Bellamy has nothing to prove to anyone, he's done and seen it all and is vastly experienced.

Sinclair has plenty yet to prove and is beginning to show what a talent he is now that he is getting regular football.
Let's face it you would have to be an absolutely incredible player to get in the current starting line up at Chelsea right now - they look like a team from another planet and Scott would never get into that team.

But after watching Sinclair the last few games he won't be long at Swansea as the vultures will soon be circling from the premiership. Great pace on the boy and he likes a dip at goal too. The John Barnes type mazy run from halfway against Scunthorpe was a joy to watch, it was if the opposition wasn't there and the keeper had to make a good save. (You can see this on the BBC highlights on the BBC Sport website).

So really the only edge Sinclair has on Bellamy is youth and fitness. And at 500k he is looking a steal!

The way I see it is Bellamy has nothing to prove to anyone, he's done and seen it all and is vastly experienced.

Sinclair has plenty yet to prove and is beginning to show what a talent he is now that he is getting regular football.
Let's face it you would have to be an absolutely incredible player to get in the current starting line up at Chelsea right now - they look like a team from another planet and Scott would never get into that team.

But after watching Sinclair the last few games he won't be long at Swansea as the vultures will soon be circling from the premiership. Great pace on the boy and he likes a dip at goal too. The John Barnes type mazy run from halfway against Scunthorpe was a joy to watch, it was if the opposition wasn't there and the keeper had to make a good save. (You can see this on the BBC highlights on the BBC Sport website).

So really the only edge Sinclair has on Bellamy is youth and fitness. And at 500k he is looking a steal!

HAVE TO SAY GOOD POST

I would have liked Scott Sinclair myself at CCS, and I have to confess to a hint of envy when he went to swansea. However, a few days later and my envious thoughts were allayed as we signed Bellamy. Mind you, I wish that we could guarantee to get as many games from Bellers as swansea will get from Sinclair

I was surprised when he joined the jacks, coming from a glamorous west end club to a town like swansea which nothing of any interest happens in that awful place and has as much character as a public toiler floor.

I was surprised when he joined the jacks, coming from a glamorous west end club to a town like swansea which nothing of any interest happens in that awful place and has as much character as a public toiler floor.

Tbh and most Jacks would agree with me on this but Swansea is a stepping stone for the likes of Sinclair. He was never going to break into the first team at Chelsea with their policy of buying the best. Therefore he had to look further afield and I believe ended up at Plymouth before moving to Swansea.

I agree with Bloo here that Sinclair will move on to a premier side who will gamble on him. He is in the shop window now and will get noticed. If we go up it would not surprise me if we make a bid for him.

I was surprised when he joined the jacks, coming from a glamorous west end club to a town like swansea which nothing of any interest happens in that awful place and has as much character as a public toiler floor.

Tbh and most Jacks would agree with me on this but Swansea is a stepping stone for the likes of Sinclair. He was never going to break into the first team at Chelsea with their policy of buying the best. Therefore he had to look further afield and I believe ended up at Plymouth before moving to Swansea.

I agree with Bloo here that Sinclair will move on to a premier side who will gamble on him. He is in the shop window now and will get noticed. If we go up it would not surprise me if we make a bid for him.

I'm not sure I agree with this. He's been out on loan for ages now and nobody in the prem has yet taken a gamble on him. He's not an unknown quantity anymore

Sinclar I'd say.When will me see Craig again.
Whats the betting we'll herr "He's offto the USA to sort out his knee.
Next thing he'll be landing in Queensland.
Good day to you Robbie.

Nice hat trick tonight. I think hes scored 7 in 7 competitive games now! And to think we had butler/gower/van der gun there last year!
Another swans target Henri Lansbury scored for Arsenal tonight as well. The deal cooled when he got injured but i would be gobsmacked if we got him!

Amazing signing for Swansea, I wish we'd signed him.

Depends how many games we can get out of Bellamy, not looking good.

Craig Bellamy is better than Scott Sinclair right now. There isn't any doubt about it.

Obviously, Sinclair is a lot younger. It's to be expected that a seasoned pro is better than a youngster.

There's nothing to say that Sinclair won't be better. However, nothing is a certainty until it has happened, so he could easily flop at any time. It's as simple as that.

Let's be fair though Sinclair's been the signing of the summer.

Probably on a 1/4 of Bellamy's wages and he actually f*cking plays.

I can honestly see Craig being out for over half this season.

One's scored 12 goals in 16 appearances

The other is a clumsy tw*t who kicked the ball straight at Dorus De Vries.