Mon May 24, 2021 1:04 pm
Mon May 24, 2021 1:31 pm
Mon May 24, 2021 1:46 pm
Mon May 24, 2021 1:51 pm
Mon May 24, 2021 1:52 pm
Mon May 24, 2021 1:56 pm
bluesince62 wrote:Cant argue with most of that, but one question, apart fom the colour fiasco, what other glaring mistakes has tan made?
It seems to me the very fans who seem to hate tan, are the ones who loved sam,so if sam can be forgiven imho so tan deserves the same? I will never forget whst he did, but have forgiven him, after all it has been reversed.the badge? Well both have been guilty of changing that.
Would I have sam back? Yeah, but not as sole owner,as I dont think he has the same clout financially as our current owner,but have to say, im happy for tan to remain here for the time being too.
Mon May 24, 2021 1:57 pm
Mon May 24, 2021 2:00 pm
mjw6150 wrote:I think in the 21 years since the takeover someone else would have gambled on investing in this club, or we would have found a managerial gem who would have done a Martinez with us. No way we would still be League Two now. Huge potential and still is in CCFC.
Mon May 24, 2021 2:01 pm
mjw6150 wrote:I think in the 21 years since the takeover someone else would have gambled on investing in this club, or we would have found a managerial gem who would have done a Martinez with us. No way we would still be League Two now. Huge potential and still is in CCFC.
Mon May 24, 2021 2:06 pm
Loyal Blue wrote:bluesince62 wrote:Cant argue with most of that, but one question, apart fom the colour fiasco, what other glaring mistakes has tan made?
It seems to me the very fans who seem to hate tan, are the ones who loved sam,so if sam can be forgiven imho so tan deserves the same? I will never forget whst he did, but have forgiven him, after all it has been reversed.the badge? Well both have been guilty of changing that.
Would I have sam back? Yeah, but not as sole owner,as I dont think he has the same clout financially as our current owner,but have to say, im happy for tan to remain here for the time being too.
Mate i was at the Valley Rams meeting in Porth and every single fan there voted for the new badge and asked Sam to put the ST Davids flag on it. Sam was doing what he thought the fans wanted.
Tan was changing us for himself not for the fans.
Amazing times under Sam, thank you![]()
Mon May 24, 2021 2:12 pm
TheHangedMan wrote:Nice one Keith.![]()
Whilst there were, shall we say, shady sides of Sam.....the bottom line is without his enthusiam, vigour and determintion, equalled by his passion for our club, there is no way we would be in the relatively comfortable position we are now.
There are always moaners, and also always fans that look at the structure and will criticise. Damned if you do and damned if you don't.
The days under Sam were probably the best I have experienced as a loyal City fan.....every day was a rollercoaster and therein lies the joy.
Was he perfect? of course not, am I perfect probably....![]()
Mon May 24, 2021 2:18 pm
bluesince62 wrote:Loyal Blue wrote:bluesince62 wrote:Cant argue with most of that, but one question, apart fom the colour fiasco, what other glaring mistakes has tan made?
It seems to me the very fans who seem to hate tan, are the ones who loved sam,so if sam can be forgiven imho so tan deserves the same? I will never forget whst he did, but have forgiven him, after all it has been reversed.the badge? Well both have been guilty of changing that.
Would I have sam back? Yeah, but not as sole owner,as I dont think he has the same clout financially as our current owner,but have to say, im happy for tan to remain here for the time being too.
Mate i was at the Valley Rams meeting in Porth and every single fan there voted for the new badge and asked Sam to put the ST Davids flag on it. Sam was doing what he thought the fans wanted.
Tan was changing us for himself not for the fans.
Amazing times under Sam, thank you![]()
Then perhaps sam could have asked ALL fans? I am not saying their werent "good times" under sam, same as there have been during tans time here? Only one eyed fans can answer no to that surely? I have said I would have sam back in some capacity, but apart from the colour, I cant see many other glaring mistakes from tan personally, but read quite often he has made them? In an ideal world, the two of them together would be something,sam for his knowledge of football(and finances) and tan for his business brain(and again finances) will never happen of course!
Mon May 24, 2021 2:30 pm
Forever Blue wrote:bluesince62 wrote:Loyal Blue wrote:bluesince62 wrote:Cant argue with most of that, but one question, apart fom the colour fiasco, what other glaring mistakes has tan made?
It seems to me the very fans who seem to hate tan, are the ones who loved sam,so if sam can be forgiven imho so tan deserves the same? I will never forget whst he did, but have forgiven him, after all it has been reversed.the badge? Well both have been guilty of changing that.
Would I have sam back? Yeah, but not as sole owner,as I dont think he has the same clout financially as our current owner,but have to say, im happy for tan to remain here for the time being too.
Mate i was at the Valley Rams meeting in Porth and every single fan there voted for the new badge and asked Sam to put the ST Davids flag on it. Sam was doing what he thought the fans wanted.
Tan was changing us for himself not for the fans.
Amazing times under Sam, thank you![]()
Then perhaps sam could have asked ALL fans? I am not saying their werent "good times" under sam, same as there have been during tans time here? Only one eyed fans can answer no to that surely? I have said I would have sam back in some capacity, but apart from the colour, I cant see many other glaring mistakes from tan personally, but read quite often he has made them? In an ideal world, the two of them together would be something,sam for his knowledge of football(and finances) and tan for his business brain(and again finances) will never happen of course!
Paul,
I can answer some of this, I hated the new badge, was away when Sam went to a big meeting up the Valleys and was told the Valley Rams were our main stronghold and Sam came back and I told Sam that he should not do this, Sam said are they not the backbone of our club and the Valleys are Wales,every fan voted for it and the main organisers in fact designed it.
I said yes they are part of it, but not all.
Sam said he was doing it for them and Wales, I never once bought anything with the badge on, yet I could see what what he felt, he was putting Wales more on the Cardiff City badge and pleasing our fans.
But for me their was only one badge.
Your 100% right, Sams Knowledge of football is up there with the best![]()
![]()
![]()
Mon May 24, 2021 2:39 pm
bluesince62 wrote:Forever Blue wrote:bluesince62 wrote:Loyal Blue wrote:bluesince62 wrote:Cant argue with most of that, but one question, apart fom the colour fiasco, what other glaring mistakes has tan made?
It seems to me the very fans who seem to hate tan, are the ones who loved sam,so if sam can be forgiven imho so tan deserves the same? I will never forget whst he did, but have forgiven him, after all it has been reversed.the badge? Well both have been guilty of changing that.
Would I have sam back? Yeah, but not as sole owner,as I dont think he has the same clout financially as our current owner,but have to say, im happy for tan to remain here for the time being too.
Mate i was at the Valley Rams meeting in Porth and every single fan there voted for the new badge and asked Sam to put the ST Davids flag on it. Sam was doing what he thought the fans wanted.
Tan was changing us for himself not for the fans.
Amazing times under Sam, thank you![]()
Then perhaps sam could have asked ALL fans? I am not saying their werent "good times" under sam, same as there have been during tans time here? Only one eyed fans can answer no to that surely? I have said I would have sam back in some capacity, but apart from the colour, I cant see many other glaring mistakes from tan personally, but read quite often he has made them? In an ideal world, the two of them together would be something,sam for his knowledge of football(and finances) and tan for his business brain(and again finances) will never happen of course!
Paul,
I can answer some of this, I hated the new badge, was away when Sam went to a big meeting up the Valleys and was told the Valley Rams were our main stronghold and Sam came back and I told Sam that he should not do this, Sam said are they not the backbone of our club and the Valleys are Wales,every fan voted for it and the main organisers in fact designed it.
I said yes they are part of it, but not all.
Sam said he was doing it for them and Wales, I never once bought anything with the badge on, yet I could see what what he felt, he was putting Wales more on the Cardiff City badge and pleasing our fans.
But for me their was only one badge.
Your 100% right, Sams Knowledge of football is up there with the best![]()
![]()
![]()
Thanks for clarifying that Annis, I too didnt like the badge,and I dont get the line of the valleys is wales personally, yes we draw a lot of much appreciated support from up there, but cardiff is as much wales as the valleys imho.perhaps a fanbase vote could have involved more people from the full spectrum of city supporters,rather than one supporters group?? As you rightly told him, they are definitely a part, but not all.
Shame the two(tan & sam) dont get on, as I believe if they could work together, we could really get established in the prem.
Mon May 24, 2021 3:05 pm
Loyal Blue wrote:bluesince62 wrote:Cant argue with most of that, but one question, apart fom the colour fiasco, what other glaring mistakes has tan made?
It seems to me the very fans who seem to hate tan, are the ones who loved sam,so if sam can be forgiven imho so tan deserves the same? I will never forget whst he did, but have forgiven him, after all it has been reversed.the badge? Well both have been guilty of changing that.
Would I have sam back? Yeah, but not as sole owner,as I dont think he has the same clout financially as our current owner,but have to say, im happy for tan to remain here for the time being too.
Mate i was at the Valley Rams meeting in Porth and every single fan there voted for the new badge and asked Sam to put the ST Davids flag on it. Sam was doing what he thought the fans wanted.
Tan was changing us for himself not for the fans.
Amazing times under Sam, thank you![]()
Mon May 24, 2021 3:22 pm
Mon May 24, 2021 3:26 pm
Mon May 24, 2021 3:34 pm
Nin Ian wrote:One thing you can not question is Sam's enthusiasm for and commitment to the club and fans.
Shortly after he took over the club we played a preseason friendly in Aberystwyth. Living close by at the time, I went to see the game and was surprised to see Sam there watching the game. Also surprised that, when I went to shake his hand and welcome him, he had time for a chat with me and my then young boys.
Mon May 24, 2021 4:06 pm
Mon May 24, 2021 4:16 pm
maccydee wrote:Loyal Blue wrote:bluesince62 wrote:Cant argue with most of that, but one question, apart fom the colour fiasco, what other glaring mistakes has tan made?
It seems to me the very fans who seem to hate tan, are the ones who loved sam,so if sam can be forgiven imho so tan deserves the same? I will never forget whst he did, but have forgiven him, after all it has been reversed.the badge? Well both have been guilty of changing that.
Would I have sam back? Yeah, but not as sole owner,as I dont think he has the same clout financially as our current owner,but have to say, im happy for tan to remain here for the time being too.
Mate i was at the Valley Rams meeting in Porth and every single fan there voted for the new badge and asked Sam to put the ST Davids flag on it. Sam was doing what he thought the fans wanted.
Tan was changing us for himself not for the fans.
Amazing times under Sam, thank you![]()
Tan wanted to change for himself. When the move was announced it was rescinded and Tan said he wouldn’t invest as planned. There were a lot of fans who made it known they wanted the investment and would support Red for the investment. There was an echo poll which was in support of the rebrand. That is no more unofficial than the Rams one about the badge.
Tan went ahead with the rebrand and there was minimal actual discontent. 50 fans returned season tickets. There were clearly more who were unhappy but the majority were happy while we were spending big and winning championships.
So what you wrote is not strictly true as Tan thought it is what the fans wanted.
The OP is excellent.
Without Sam we wouldn’t be anywhere near where we are.
He may have got us heavily in debt but the raising of our profile covered that debt many times over in my opinion.
History should look fondly on Sam as an owner of Cardiff City. Had we got into the premier league when he was still on top form and he was able to deliver the stadium and retail park this club would have been very different in the years that followed him leaving.
Mon May 24, 2021 4:19 pm
Mon May 24, 2021 4:30 pm
Mon May 24, 2021 4:32 pm
bluesince62 wrote:Cant argue with most of that, but one question, apart fom the colour fiasco, what other glaring mistakes has tan made?
It seems to me the very fans who seem to hate tan, are the ones who loved sam,so if sam can be forgiven imho so tan deserves the same? I will never forget whst he did, but have forgiven him, after all it has been reversed.the badge? Well both have been guilty of changing that.
Would I have sam back? Yeah, but not as sole owner,as I dont think he has the same clout financially as our current owner,but have to say, im happy for tan to remain here for the time being too.
Mon May 24, 2021 4:34 pm
Mon May 24, 2021 4:42 pm
skidemin wrote:maccydee wrote:Loyal Blue wrote:bluesince62 wrote:Cant argue with most of that, but one question, apart fom the colour fiasco, what other glaring mistakes has tan made?
It seems to me the very fans who seem to hate tan, are the ones who loved sam,so if sam can be forgiven imho so tan deserves the same? I will never forget whst he did, but have forgiven him, after all it has been reversed.the badge? Well both have been guilty of changing that.
Would I have sam back? Yeah, but not as sole owner,as I dont think he has the same clout financially as our current owner,but have to say, im happy for tan to remain here for the time being too.
Mate i was at the Valley Rams meeting in Porth and every single fan there voted for the new badge and asked Sam to put the ST Davids flag on it. Sam was doing what he thought the fans wanted.
Tan was changing us for himself not for the fans.
Amazing times under Sam, thank you![]()
Tan wanted to change for himself. When the move was announced it was rescinded and Tan said he wouldn’t invest as planned. There were a lot of fans who made it known they wanted the investment and would support Red for the investment. There was an echo poll which was in support of the rebrand. That is no more unofficial than the Rams one about the badge.
Tan went ahead with the rebrand and there was minimal actual discontent. 50 fans returned season tickets. There were clearly more who were unhappy but the majority were happy while we were spending big and winning championships.
So what you wrote is not strictly true as Tan thought it is what the fans wanted.
The OP is excellent.
Without Sam we wouldn’t be anywhere near where we are.
He may have got us heavily in debt but the raising of our profile covered that debt many times over in my opinion.
History should look fondly on Sam as an owner of Cardiff City. Had we got into the premier league when he was still on top form and he was able to deliver the stadium and retail park this club would have been very different in the years that followed him leaving.
you honestly think Tan thought we wanted to be in red ?
he might have been of the opinion or told it would be tolerated or accepted...but that WE wanted it ?
if the fans wanted to be red , we would still be red..
the poll....was not simply red with investment or blue with investment .
ive always maintained we as a fan base folded to easy...no real protests and your points about how few STs being returned and an initial absence of distain for the change is valid { but that went hand in hand as part of a trade off } ... but happy and wanted it.....your having a laugh...
Mon May 24, 2021 5:53 pm
Mon May 24, 2021 6:02 pm
:clap:TheHangedMan » Mon May 24, 2021 4:32 pm
bluesince62 wrote:
Cant argue with most of that, but one question, apart fom the colour fiasco, what other glaring mistakes has tan made?
It seems to me the very fans who seem to hate tan, are the ones who loved sam,so if sam can be forgiven imho so tan deserves the same? I will never forget whst he did, but have forgiven him, after all it has been reversed.the badge? Well both have been guilty of changing that.
Would I have sam back? Yeah, but not as sole owner,as I dont think he has the same clout financially as our current owner,but have to say, im happy for tan to remain here for the time being too.
I think you make a very valid point here. It is never black and white, thank God!, so with that in mind you don't have to side with one owner or the other.
Sam was the cannon that shot CCFC away from mediocrity and possibly oblivion, we aimed for the stars and ended up close to the moon. Unfortunately he couldn't get the stadium over the line and things ended a bit sour. That said, he was the man who gave us hope, gave us a dream, followed it up with money and desire and he should always be remembered and respected for this.
Tan came along with much more financial clout and did many good things for our club. Unfortunately he made a very big error in judgemnet and that has been well documented. Since then he has converted debt to equity and achieved two promotions to the PL.
I have total respect and admiration for both of these great guys........without Sam (1st off) and then Tan (picking up the batton), where would we be now?
Mon May 24, 2021 6:10 pm
skiprat wrote:Sam definitely re ignited the club which was virtually dead for 20 years. But nobody knows if someone else would have come and established us in the top flight and put trophies in the cabinet.As it stands we are no further forward than 2003 when were were promoted to this level.just deeper in debt.
Mon May 24, 2021 6:37 pm
maccydee wrote:skiprat wrote:Sam definitely re ignited the club which was virtually dead for 20 years. But nobody knows if someone else would have come and established us in the top flight and put trophies in the cabinet.As it stands we are no further forward than 2003 when were were promoted to this level.just deeper in debt.
Really?
Weren’t we at Ninian Park then? Now our stadium is used for Wales games.
Could only dream of a player like Bellamy being at our club. It happened.
Two premier league seasons.
Training facilities were shocking.
The club has moved forward massively since 2003 and in fact under Tan.
Mon May 24, 2021 6:45 pm
skiprat wrote:maccydee wrote:skiprat wrote:Sam definitely re ignited the club which was virtually dead for 20 years. But nobody knows if someone else would have come and established us in the top flight and put trophies in the cabinet.As it stands we are no further forward than 2003 when were were promoted to this level.just deeper in debt.
Really?
Weren’t we at Ninian Park then? Now our stadium is used for Wales games.
Could only dream of a player like Bellamy being at our club. It happened.
Two premier league seasons.
Training facilities were shocking.
The club has moved forward massively since 2003 and in fact under Tan.
2003 in the championship 2021 in the championship yes plenty of improvements but not established in the premier league no trophies on the cabinet.