Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

My player ratings today

Sat Sep 11, 2010 7:09 pm

Marshall 7 Good handling
McNaughton 9 Superb. Real attacking threat and unlucky not to score
Naylor 7. Solid. Looks like a gd signing.
Hudson 7. Good game. Looked a little suspect when Simpson came on but overall did well
Gypes 7. Good in air. 1 cock up which he got away with.
Oli 8. Man mountain. Awesome player. Hope his injury is just a bump
Whitts 7 good game with some great touches
McPhail 7. Tidy performance. Should have scored.
Koumas 7. Glimpses of real class. Drifted in and out.
Burke 8. Played well with some great runs.
Keogh 7. Needs time to bed in but will be a real assett.

Rae did well when he came on and well done Gavin for answering yr critics.

Re: My player ratings today

Sat Sep 11, 2010 7:13 pm

Gareth (Wilts) wrote:Marshall 7 Good handling
McNaughton 9 Superb. Real attacking threat and unlucky not to score
Naylor 7. Solid. Looks like a gd signing.
Hudson 7. Good game. Looked a little suspect when Simpson came on but overall did well
Gypes 7. Good in air. 1 cock up which he got away with.
Oli 8. Man mountain. Awesome player. Hope his injury is just a bump
Whitts 7 good game with some great touches
McPhail 7. Tidy performance. Should have scored.
Koumas 7. Glimpses of real class. Drifted in and out.
Burke 8. Played well with some great runs.
Keogh 7. Needs time to bed in but will be a real assett.

Rae did well when he came on and well done Gavin for answering yr critics.



McNaughton got skinne din the first few minutes. I'd give him an 8, and the 2 centre halfs won everything, often stepping in front of Fagan to rob hi - they both deserve 8's IMHO.

I though Whitts wasted a lot of passes and would only give him a 6.

Pretty much agree with the rest.

Re: My player ratings today

Sat Sep 11, 2010 7:13 pm

Can't disagree with any of that.

Re: My player ratings today

Sat Sep 11, 2010 7:45 pm

Marshall 7 - Solid

Naylor 7 - Got forward well and defended well, a solid LB
Gypes 8 - Didnt really think he put a spe wrong today although Hull offered little upfront.
Hudson 6 -against better teams he could have costed us on several occasions, got away with a lot today IMO.
McNaughton 8 - excellent game and got forward with great effect

Koumas 6 - started and stopped throughout, moments of class followed by a bad touch. Looks a bit of his best but it will come with games
Witts 7 - I think he offers so much more in the middle of a three, good passing and got about well.
Olly 9 - everything you want from a defensive midfielder, covered the defence and scored from a set peice.
McPhail 8 - passed well, tackled well, kept things going
Burke 8 - ran and ran and had the beating of his man, failed with some crossing but glad he is in our team.

Keogh 7 - He isnt a target man but I thought he led the line very well, worked hard, brought others into play. He hasnt started a game for a year

Rae 7 - done ok and got the goal
Wildig 6 - not on long but look comfortable.