Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 5:32 pm

Scans today have shown that Joe Bennett sustained an anterior cruciate ligament injury in his right knee during City’s match with Derby County on Tuesday night. He will now be referred to a specialist.

Looks like out injured for 6months :cry:

We're all with you, Joe!
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 5:37 pm

worcester_ccfc wrote:Scans today have shown that Joe Bennett sustained an anterior cruciate ligament injury in his right knee during City’s match with Derby County on Tuesday night. He will now be referred to a specialist.


Looks like out injured for 6months :cry:



We're all with you, Joe!




him being stretchered off could well be the last time we will see him in a Cardiff shirt....

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 5:52 pm

skidemin wrote:
worcester_ccfc wrote:Scans today have shown that Joe Bennett sustained an anterior cruciate ligament injury in his right knee during City’s match with Derby County on Tuesday night. He will now be referred to a specialist.


Looks like out injured for 6months :cry:



We're all with you, Joe!




him being stretchered off could well be the last time we will see him in a Cardiff shirt....


why? He is in contract talks apparently, so while he may not play again this season unless the club do a u-turn then he is likely to be signing a new contract. I am sure we all wish him a speedy recovery as he has been another major beneficiary of the McCarthy factor and has been back to near his best.

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 6:04 pm

We'd be a shit club if we didn't offer him a new contract imo.

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 6:05 pm

Cardiff have now confirmed the worst news that they feared for Bennett.

"Scans today have shown that @JoeBennett27 sustained an anterior cruciate ligament injury in his right knee during City’s match with @dcfcofficial on Tuesday night. He will now be referred to a specialist. We're all with you, Joe!"

The injury rules Bennett out of the Bluebirds' Championship season run-in, and with the 30-year-old out of contract in the Welsh capital this summer, the future remains uncertain for the full-back.

Bennett's misfortune presents youngster Joel Bagan with an opportunity between now and the end of the campaign, and McCarthy backed him to do a job for the Bluebirds.



MICK McCARTHY:


"I've got absolutely zero worries about Joel Bagan," the manager said last night.

"He's very unfortunate that he's got such a good player and experienced player in front of him. Joe's vastly experienced and a good player.

"But Joel has got big things ahead of him and is terrific."
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 6:12 pm

It will take 6-9 months to recover from this so I hope the club see him through and back to full fitness. He will get over this so I hope he does complete a new contract agreement then hopefully we will see him play again in 2022.


:bluescarf: :bluescarf: :bluescarf:

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 6:13 pm

Gutted for Joe, always liked him.

We won’t see him now this season, but our club was already ready to offer him a new contract for next season, hopefully that still stands :bluebird: :bluebird:

Get better ASAP Joe :thumbright: :bluebird: :bluebird:

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 6:19 pm

Such a shame, but he will come back from this.
Hopefully the club will do the right thing by Joe and offer him a new contract

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 6:30 pm

fred keenor wrote:Such a shame, but he will come back from this.
Hopefully the club will do the right thing by Joe and offer him a new contract




All clubs do so In these situations but suspect it will be a reduced one for a year......even that is not to be sneezed at considering original wages players are on..

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 6:41 pm

Bluebird For Life wrote:
skidemin wrote:
worcester_ccfc wrote:Scans today have shown that Joe Bennett sustained an anterior cruciate ligament injury in his right knee during City’s match with Derby County on Tuesday night. He will now be referred to a specialist.


Looks like out injured for 6months :cry:



We're all with you, Joe!




him being stretchered off could well be the last time we will see him in a Cardiff shirt....


why? He is in contract talks apparently, so while he may not play again this season unless the club do a u-turn then he is likely to be signing a new contract. I am sure we all wish him a speedy recovery as he has been another major beneficiary of the McCarthy factor and has been back to near his best.



yes there was a bit of talk about a new contract prior to Christmas but nothing since...
personally i would love to see him here next season but the reality is he is out of contract in 3 months..as for the MM factor , he has always been good...

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 6:49 pm

Great player is Joe, never shirks from a challenge, fit fast and dedicated pro. If he is out of contract he deserves a new one if he wants to stay , which I think he does

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 6:55 pm

skidemin wrote:
Bluebird For Life wrote:
skidemin wrote:
worcester_ccfc wrote:Scans today have shown that Joe Bennett sustained an anterior cruciate ligament injury in his right knee during City’s match with Derby County on Tuesday night. He will now be referred to a specialist.


Looks like out injured for 6months :cry:



We're all with you, Joe!




him being stretchered off could well be the last time we will see him in a Cardiff shirt....


why? He is in contract talks apparently, so while he may not play again this season unless the club do a u-turn then he is likely to be signing a new contract. I am sure we all wish him a speedy recovery as he has been another major beneficiary of the McCarthy factor and has been back to near his best.



yes there was a bit of talk about a new contract prior to Christmas but nothing since...
personally i would love to see him here next season but the reality is he is out of contract in 3 months..as for the MM factor , he has always been good...


Never doubted his ability but like many others he was underperforming under Harris - he got caught out of position a lot and looked terrified to play a forward pass. I'm sure we will see him here for a couple more seasons yet...

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 7:12 pm

Bluebird For Life wrote:
skidemin wrote:
Bluebird For Life wrote:
skidemin wrote:
worcester_ccfc wrote:Scans today have shown that Joe Bennett sustained an anterior cruciate ligament injury in his right knee during City’s match with Derby County on Tuesday night. He will now be referred to a specialist.


Looks like out injured for 6months :cry:



We're all with you, Joe!




him being stretchered off could well be the last time we will see him in a Cardiff shirt....


why? He is in contract talks apparently, so while he may not play again this season unless the club do a u-turn then he is likely to be signing a new contract. I am sure we all wish him a speedy recovery as he has been another major beneficiary of the McCarthy factor and has been back to near his best.



yes there was a bit of talk about a new contract prior to Christmas but nothing since...
personally i would love to see him here next season but the reality is he is out of contract in 3 months..as for the MM factor , he has always been good...


Never doubted his ability but like many others he was underperforming under Harris - he got caught out of position a lot and looked terrified to play a forward pass. I'm sure we will see him here for a couple more seasons yet...



i kept reading this caught out of position when playing for Warnock as well as NH.... if he hadnt been encouraged to join attacks or even discouraged from doing it.. he wouldnt have been playing everyweek ? its not like he was stood in the middle of the park lost ,he was actually pushing on and both managers, well and Mick realise you cant be in 2 places the same time...

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 7:15 pm

So what happens if he gets a new deal at 20k a week, he’s out for 6-9 months. What if he struggles to get back fully fit?

Will people be saying it was a mistake and waste of money?

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 7:19 pm

More likely he will be out for 12 months that’s going to be a long time.

Any talks on resigning him have taken place but if signs again I can’t see him earning anywhere near what he’s on now. Someone is going to make a difficult decision. We are already carrying Vassel and Tomlin.

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 7:21 pm

Joe earns £1,040,000 per year, according to sites on Google. He ain’t cheap! But has been a loyal servant to the City and a good performer. I’d offer him an initial 1 year contract in the hope he can recover early next season in approximately Sept 2021. That would seem reasonable. If he cannot recover, then he’ll still pick up a sum over the year most of us can only dream of.

If he can get fit, then perhaps any new contract would be extended. Remember if we win promotion, the terms of his contract probably states he will receive a substantial pay rise, whether or not he plays.

Whether Mr. Tan will want to take the risk over Joe when his contract expires later this summer is anyone’s guess and a completely different matter.

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 8:36 pm

This is bad news for Joe, and also for club, team and support :(

Thankfully, we have Joel Bagan but it will be tough for Joe and I wish him a speedy recovery :ayatollah:

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 8:36 pm

Winchmore Hill Bluebird wrote:Joe earns £1,040,000 per year, according to sites on Google. He ain’t cheap! But has been a loyal servant to the City and a good performer. I’d offer him an initial 1 year contract in the hope he can recover early next season in approximately Sept 2021. That would seem reasonable. If he cannot recover, then he’ll still pick up a sum over the year most of us can only dream of.

If he can get fit, then perhaps any new contract would be extended. Remember if we win promotion, the terms of his contract probably states he will receive a substantial pay rise, whether or not he plays.

Whether Mr. Tan will want to take the risk over Joe when his contract expires later this summer is anyone’s guess and a completely different matter.


As someone said earlier this will be the time we find out whether Joel Bagan is a first team player or a back up. Joe Bennett has been three managers first choice LB and if MM decides Baglan isn't up to it then its likely going to cost the equivalent of Joe Bennett's wages to sign a first choice, so Mr. Tan's decision will be dictated by Joe's progress and who is available come the summer.

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 8:49 pm

Sven wrote:This is bad news for Joe, and also for club, team and support :(

Thankfully, we have Joel Bagan but it will be tough for Joe and I wish him a speedy recovery :ayatollah:



Gutted for Joe, he was having a decent season,but Joel has stepped up admirably when called upon.
Wish joe a full recovery. :old: :bluebird:

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 8:49 pm

Sven wrote:This is bad news for Joe, and also for club, team and support :(

Thankfully, we have Joel Bagan but it will be tough for Joe and I wish him a speedy recovery :ayatollah:



Gutted for Joe, he was having a decent season,but Joel has stepped up admirably when called upon.
Wish joe a full recovery. :old: :bluebird:

Re: BAD NEWS " JOE BENNETT SUFFERS ACL INJURY "

Wed Mar 03, 2021 10:11 pm

This is awful news. Speedy recovery Joe.