Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

' WHATS GOT TO BE NOW DONE '

Sun Jan 24, 2021 3:05 pm

Cardiff City's new manager inherits a team in a mess, but with enormous potential. Here are some of the major issues he will be addressing from week one

Cardiff's Committee especially Chairman Dalman will find it refreshing that the early backlash against McCarthy's appointment, particularly on social media, has been somewhat overtaken by more and more fans beginning to accept this is not a bad choice of manager.


By Paul Abbandonato


Sunday 24th January 2021


That said, there are clear issues.

As Neil Warnock stated upon his arrival as Bluebirds boss, 'When you're asked to come in as manager it's normally for a reason and there are problems to resolve.'




' Restore a fragile dressing room '


They say confidence is everything in football and from speaking to Bluebirds players heads really are down inside the dressing room.

That is a legacy, of course, of six defeats on the trot, with belief in Harris' methods and game plan evidently wavering.

How quickly McCarthy can restore morale, and put a smile back on the faces of those Cardiff stars, holds the key to what is in store for the rest of the season.

One of the concerns of the Bluebirds' hierarchy is that the slump meant they could have been heading into League One if change wasn't made.

McCarthy has not only been brought in to ensure that doesn't happen, but to actually see if he can even get this team looking towards the play-offs - however unlikely that may appear at the moment.

McCarthy's man management skills are famed within football, as is the case with his big mate Warnock.

He may have fallen out with Roy Keane, but the vast majority of his former players speak highly of McCarthy's methods and motivational ability.

Even when McCarthy left Ipswich under a cloud, having fallen out with the fans, it seems many of the players remained fiercely loyal.

One thing McCarthy has going for him is the fixture list. Cardiff's next six games see them play Barnsley, Millwall, Bristol City, Rotherham, Luton and Coventry.

It's a cliche to say there are no easy matches in the Championship, and there certainly aren't for this group of Bluebirds players who have reached rock bottom.

However, player for player and everything being equal, Cardiff would fancy their chances of winning every one of those next six games.

They won't of course, but if McCarthy can instantly lift spirits and build up something of a head of steam with these Bluebirds quickly turning their fortunes around, who knows what might be possible from there on in?
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: ' WHATS GOT TO BE NOW DONE '

Sun Jan 24, 2021 3:06 pm

' Make the Bluebirds enjoyable to watch again '


Perhaps the worst thing you can say about the Neil Harris regime towards the end is that watching Cardiff City became a painful and unpleasant experience.

You just kind of knew what was going to happen. Start slow, lack any creativity or panache, look ponderous, concede a sloppy goal or two, have a real go in the closing 15 minutes when the game was pretty much gone - and lose.

It actually got to the stage where one or two fans might have even half wanted their team not to win because they felt that would hasten the departure of the manager.

That is never a good position to be in, but it highlights how awful everything had become.

As such, in terms of looking at the bigger picture, defeat at home to Queens Park Rangers was no bad thing as it finally compelled the Board to act.

Suddenly, there will be a renewed vigour when Cardiff head to Barnsley on Wednesday night.

McCarthy needs to make watching Cardiff City what it should be - a thoroughly enjoyable experience again.

He needs to bring discipline, organisation, tempo and creativity to this Bluebirds team, get them playing front-foot as opposed to negative football.

McCarthy will quickly discover there is no more passionate fan base than Bluebirds supporters. They want a side that matches that fervour with 100 per cent commitment, but which also excites.

They are ready to rally behind. It's over to the manager to deliver.




' Get that defence sorted '


McCarthy was an absolute no-nonsense centre-half himself, perhaps best exemplified by what happened when he skippered Ireland under Jack Charlton during their golden era.

There were more talented defenders than him, notably Paul McGrath, Mark Lawrenson, David O'Leary.

But, for a while at least, those had to move into different roles as Charlton preferred the no-nonsense and bruising approach of McCarthy and Kevin Moran in the middle of his defence.

Expect that ethos to be the exact foundation Big Mick builds his Bluebirds team upon.

Sean Morrison will become the absolute kingpin of this team. He's had a poor season, but the skipper will be encouraged to start dominating the two penalty boxes again as we know he can.

Every single member of Harris' first-choice back four - Leandro Bacuna, Morrison, Curtis Nelson and Joe Bennett - have made major errors which have led to goals this season.

Yet however poorly any of that quartet fared, invariably they seemed destined to keep their place in the team again for the next match.

McCarthy won't put up with that. If he sees fundamental mistakes being repeated, he won't hesitate to drop players and compensate for their absence in other ways.

McCarthy will seek to bring discipline back to Cardiff's defence, eradicate the silly errors.

Morrison and Bennett are really good players at this level, major figures in the promotion charge under Neil Warnock, and they should thrive under McCarthy.


Sean Morrison has cut a frustrated figure this year, but he can thrive under McCarthy's management

Nelson performed admirably at the back end of last season, less so this year. McCarthy will want those former standards attained again. And maintained.

Bacuna is a far better midfielder than right-back, so expect that experiment to have ended with Perry Ng on board anyway.

The defence will underpin everything McCarthy hopes to achieve with Cardiff.

Clean sheets will be his demand. There have been far too few of them in recent times.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: ' WHATS GOT TO BE NOW DONE '

Sun Jan 24, 2021 3:08 pm

' Get the best out of Murphy and Wilson '



Next to Morrison, the other kingpin of the team under McCarthy is likely to be Kieffer Moore.

The big man has been outstanding this season, despite the chronic lack of service at times.

What happens around him, with the Bluebirds' flair players, holds the key to whether Cardiff will be more easy on the eye than they were under Harris.

Harry Wilson arrived as the marquee signing in the summer and on occasions has shown his undoubted talent.

But, certainly recently, the Liverpool loanee has looked out of sorts - demonstrating, more than anything else, what is so badly wrong with the side.

Wilson is a much better footballer than we are seeing. Hopefully McCarthy will free him up from any defensive duties, get the ball to his feet and instruct him to drop grenades around the opposition penalty box.

The case of Josh Murphy is more complicated, he divides opinion.


Those in the Murphy camp see an £11m player who has been poorly used by Cardiff, someone with pace, ability to go past players, a ferocious shot and able to score goals, but who gets an odd cameo appearance here or there, never a consistent run.

Those in the other camp see a footballer who flatters to deceive, isn't consistent enough, doesn't work hard enough and doesn't deserve his place in the team.

But if Cardiff have got Josh Murphy on their books, then Cardiff have to start properly utilising a player who cost them a fortune.

Murphy is clearly a confidence footballer. What he needs is an arm put around him, told he is an absolute key player in this side and given a proper run of matches to prove his worth.

Look at Jamal Lowe with Swansea. Do Cardiff fans really think he's got more ability than Murphy?

Yet Lowe was told by Steve Cooper he was fundamental to the game plan. He kept being told that when criticism came from the fans.

Look how Lowe has flourished under that tutelage, knowing he's not going to be dropped for a sub-par performance, or offered five minutes as a substitute. His confidence has soared as a result and he looks a really effective player.

Can that not happen with Josh Murphy, whether he has trained well or not?

Sometimes players just have to be treated differently. Normally it's the flair ones.

At 25, Murphy should be approaching his peak years. Something had to change for him and hopefully. McCarthy will recognise his talent. Then it's down to Murphy himself.

He certainly has the ability. If Murphy and Wilson start shining, and Lee Tomlin comes back into the mix, with Moore there as well the Bluebirds can have a potent front line and become a joy to watch.




Just eight days to make new signings

McCarthy recognises the quality of the underperforming squad he has inherited, but every manager wants his own players.

To that end, McCarthy has just eight days before the transfer window closes to make recommendations to Bluebirds owner Vincent Tan.

Time is tight, but the manager wants to first assess the players in training over the next couple of days, and in action at Barnsley, and then make decisions.



He is likely to want to strengthen in a couple of areas.

McCarthy may want a new centre-half, for starters, and he might also ask for a midfielder who is capable of dominating matches. Cardiff have functional players in that department, and McCarthy may be happy with them, but it's certainly an area he will look at.

Forward players? No need.

Left back? No need.

Goalkeeper? No need.

Right back? They've just signed Perry Ng.

Given the numbers on the Bluebirds' books, it's hard to see where else he needs to strengthen.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: ' WHATS GOT TO BE NOW DONE '

Sun Jan 24, 2021 3:11 pm

' Get the fans on board '


Cardiff's Committee especially Chairman Dalman will find it refreshing that the early backlash against McCarthy's appointment, particularly on social media, has been somewhat overtaken by more and more fans beginning to accept this is not a bad choice of manager.

Critics and sceptics remain of course and McCarthy clearly still has work to do there.

But while the doubts persist, as a whole there appears to be a far more positive feeling about McCarthy 48 hours on than there was when it first started to become clear he was Cardiff's chosen one.

The concern from fans was understandable and a legacy of a wish for a change in style of play, given Neil Harris, Neil Warnock and Russell Slade each adopted similar route one methods.

The football under Malky Mackay was pragmatic too, rather than tiki-taka.

You have to go back to the Dave Jones era for a Cardiff side who regularly thrilled with their tactics and approach to matches.


McCarthy's methods are well known, he isn't suddenly going to metamorphose into Pep Guardiola. He's more likely to be like Warnock.

However, he has been around the block and knows one thing will get the fans on board.

'Winning football', as Warnock called it at the weekend.

There is clearly far more to it than that because Cardiff fans also want their team playing in a faster, more expansive and exciting way.

But a few early wins will certainly do McCarthy more good than harm, let's put it that way.

Re: ' WHATS GOT TO BE NOW DONE '

Sun Jan 24, 2021 5:20 pm

He needs to strengthen the midfield not one of our players would get in any of the top ten sides. Until he does nothing will change up top as far as scoring goals.

Re: ' WHATS GOT TO BE NOW DONE '

Sun Jan 24, 2021 11:40 pm

I’ve penned some thoughts on where I think the club ultimately needs to go and what should happen. Let’s stop the rot.

https://thebobbankvillage.weebly.com/ho ... lan-please

Re: ' WHATS GOT TO BE NOW DONE '

Mon Jan 25, 2021 10:21 pm

exiled12345 wrote:I’ve penned some thoughts on where I think the club ultimately needs to go and what should happen. Let’s stop the rot.

https://thebobbankvillage.weebly.com/ho ... lan-please


Good read.