Best Cardiff & Jack born players alltime?

City

1. Gareth Bale

2. Ryan Giggs

3. John Toshack

4. Craig Bellamy

5. Terry Yorath



Others to consider ; Phil Dwyer, Nathan Blake, Ron Stitfall, Stan Richards



Jack Bastards

1. John Charles

2. Trevor Ford

3. Cliff Jones

4. Ivor Allchurch

5. Dean Saunders


Others to consider; Ray Daniel, Mel Nurse,
John Hartson and Robbie James.

Fred Keenor

Ramsey

Ramsey was born in Caerphilly but Keenor should be top 5.

Considering that Allchurch was one of the best players I have ever seen in a City shirt he can hardly be classed as a Jack b*stard. King John likewise though he was well past his best when we signed him

Considering that Allchurch was one of the best players I have ever seen in a City shirt he can hardly be classed as a Jack b*stard. King John likewise though he was well past his best when we signed him

They were both born in Swansea so they are jacks.

Always remember John Charles was a bluebird never played for Swansea at any level a bluebird legend

Considering that Allchurch was one of the best players I have ever seen in a City shirt he can hardly be classed as a Jack b*stard. King John likewise though he was well past his best when we signed him

pretty sure Ivor Allchurch is the only player to score a hattrick in a Derby.. Charles got the other 2... Cardiff 5. Swansea 0

Fred Keenor needs to be on the Cardiff list people are underestimating how highly regarded he was as a player.

Even captained a Wales team where he was the only pro (due to club disputes) the rest were ameatuers from the welsh league to beating a full strength England team.

Criteria? Ramsey from Caerphilly though played for us, twice, cant be included but Giggs and Bale can?
Does that mean no to Jason Perry too?

Jason Perry Bedwas boy.

Criteria? Ramsey from Caerphilly though played for us, twice, cant be included but Giggs and Bale can?
Does that mean no to Jason Perry too?

It’s not rocket science isit he’s talking about players born in the city’s not played for the clubs

Is Gorseinon Swansea?

Is Gorseinon Swansea?

no