Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Cardiff player of the Decade

You may select 1 option

0
No votes
0
No votes
0
No votes
0
No votes
0
No votes
0
No votes
2
9%
0
No votes
0
No votes
16
70%
0
No votes
0
No votes
2
9%
0
No votes
0
No votes
0
No votes
2
9%
0
No votes
0
No votes
0
No votes
0
No votes
0
No votes
0
No votes
1
4%
0
No votes
 
Total votes : 23
 

Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 8:51 am

A bit bored on Boxing day morning waiting for the game so With the decade coming to a close who would you vote as the player of the decade ?
Who did you enjoy watching the most?

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 9:50 am

I refuse to vote in any poll that has shortlisted Wilfried Zaha as a potential player of the decade option

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 10:08 am

If Zaha on list then Ramseys short loan back should get him included.

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 10:11 am

BarryWelsh88 wrote:I refuse to vote in any poll that has shortlisted Wilfried Zaha as a potential player of the decade option



in fairness it looks like he has put a few in there to beef the list up..
considering it covers 2 promotions and 2 play off teams its a disappointing list

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 10:23 am

dogfound wrote:
BarryWelsh88 wrote:I refuse to vote in any poll that has shortlisted Wilfried Zaha as a potential player of the decade option



in fairness it looks like he has put a few in there to beef the list up..
considering it covers 2 promotions and 2 play off teams its a disappointing list


It just saves all the why didnt you put this player in posts. I dont expect most of them to have any votes but it's easier to try and give more options
I tried to pick the best players from each position over the 10 years

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 10:25 am

dogfound wrote:
BarryWelsh88 wrote:I refuse to vote in any poll that has shortlisted Wilfried Zaha as a potential player of the decade option



in fairness it looks like he has put a few in there to beef the list up..
considering it covers 2 promotions and 2 play off teams its a disappointing list



Its an unbelievably disappointing list considering its taking in a hugely successful period in our history. Not knocking the compiler just so strange that there are not more candidates with longevity. Whitts stands out on that front. The list is padded out a lot and Macheda, Kenwyne, Daehli and a few others really have no place or if they do there are countless others to include for sake of it.

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 10:33 am

Isawgarystevensscoreagoal wrote:
dogfound wrote:
BarryWelsh88 wrote:I refuse to vote in any poll that has shortlisted Wilfried Zaha as a potential player of the decade option



in fairness it looks like he has put a few in there to beef the list up..
considering it covers 2 promotions and 2 play off teams its a disappointing list



Its an unbelievably disappointing list considering its taking in a hugely successful period in our history. Not knocking the compiler just so strange that there are not more candidates with longevity. Whitts stands out on that front. The list is padded out a lot and Macheda, Kenwyne, Daehli and a few others really have no place or if they do there are countless others to include for sake of it.


even Earnshaw...3 goals in the decade..i wasn't having a go at Thomas either

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 10:37 am

thomasblue wrote:
dogfound wrote:
BarryWelsh88 wrote:I refuse to vote in any poll that has shortlisted Wilfried Zaha as a potential player of the decade option



in fairness it looks like he has put a few in there to beef the list up..
considering it covers 2 promotions and 2 play off teams its a disappointing list


It just saves all the why didnt you put this player in posts. I dont expect most of them to have any votes but it's easier to try and give more options
I tried to pick the best players from each position over the 10 years



I did not mean your choices are disappointing..
I don't think you've left anyone out...….although im sure bothroyd and chopra would probably both be quite high on a top scoere of the decade list :lol: :lol:

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 10:41 am

dogfound wrote:
thomasblue wrote:
dogfound wrote:
BarryWelsh88 wrote:I refuse to vote in any poll that has shortlisted Wilfried Zaha as a potential player of the decade option



in fairness it looks like he has put a few in there to beef the list up..
considering it covers 2 promotions and 2 play off teams its a disappointing list


It just saves all the why didnt you put this player in posts. I dont expect most of them to have any votes but it's easier to try and give more options
I tried to pick the best players from each position over the 10 years



I did not mean your choices are disappointing..
I don't think you've left anyone out...….although im sure bothroyd and chopra would probably both be quite high on a top scoere of the decade list :lol: :lol:


Bothroyd and Chops warrant inclusion.

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 10:43 am

Isawgarystevensscoreagoal wrote:
dogfound wrote:
thomasblue wrote:
dogfound wrote:
BarryWelsh88 wrote:I refuse to vote in any poll that has shortlisted Wilfried Zaha as a potential player of the decade option



in fairness it looks like he has put a few in there to beef the list up..
considering it covers 2 promotions and 2 play off teams its a disappointing list


It just saves all the why didnt you put this player in posts. I dont expect most of them to have any votes but it's easier to try and give more options
I tried to pick the best players from each position over the 10 years



I did not mean your choices are disappointing..
I don't think you've left anyone out...….although im sure bothroyd and chopra would probably both be quite high on a top scoere of the decade list :lol: :lol:


Bothroyd and Chops warrant inclusion.



yes I suppose , they didn't play a great deal in this decade but neither did quite a few on the list...

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 10:50 am

dogfound wrote:
Isawgarystevensscoreagoal wrote:
dogfound wrote:
thomasblue wrote:
dogfound wrote:
BarryWelsh88 wrote:I refuse to vote in any poll that has shortlisted Wilfried Zaha as a potential player of the decade option



in fairness it looks like he has put a few in there to beef the list up..
considering it covers 2 promotions and 2 play off teams its a disappointing list


It just saves all the why didnt you put this player in posts. I dont expect most of them to have any votes but it's easier to try and give more options
I tried to pick the best players from each position over the 10 years



I did not mean your choices are disappointing..
I don't think you've left anyone out...….although im sure bothroyd and chopra would probably both be quite high on a top scoere of the decade list :lol: :lol:


Bothroyd and Chops warrant inclusion.



yes I suppose , they didn't play a great deal in this decade but neither did quite a few on the list...


Funny. They played the 10/11 season so sneak in. Last time we actually had a pair of strikers.

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 10:56 am

Isawgarystevensscoreagoal wrote:
dogfound wrote:
thomasblue wrote:
dogfound wrote:
BarryWelsh88 wrote:I refuse to vote in any poll that has shortlisted Wilfried Zaha as a potential player of the decade option



in fairness it looks like he has put a few in there to beef the list up..
considering it covers 2 promotions and 2 play off teams its a disappointing list


It just saves all the why didnt you put this player in posts. I dont expect most of them to have any votes but it's easier to try and give more options
I tried to pick the best players from each position over the 10 years



I did not mean your choices are disappointing..
I don't think you've left anyone out...….although im sure bothroyd and chopra would probably both be quite high on a top scoere of the decade list :lol: :lol:


Bothroyd and Chops warrant inclusion.


I thought about them but they were the end of last decade really and left the first season of this decade. They would be top of the list 10 years ago
Can only have 25 options and decided on more recent players

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 11:01 am

Yet you’ve chosen players who played less and a lot worse

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 11:04 am

thomasblue wrote:
Isawgarystevensscoreagoal wrote:
dogfound wrote:
thomasblue wrote:
dogfound wrote:
BarryWelsh88 wrote:I refuse to vote in any poll that has shortlisted Wilfried Zaha as a potential player of the decade option



in fairness it looks like he has put a few in there to beef the list up..
considering it covers 2 promotions and 2 play off teams its a disappointing list


It just saves all the why didnt you put this player in posts. I dont expect most of them to have any votes but it's easier to try and give more options
I tried to pick the best players from each position over the 10 years



I did not mean your choices are disappointing..
I don't think you've left anyone out...….although im sure bothroyd and chopra would probably both be quite high on a top scoere of the decade list :lol: :lol:


Bothroyd and Chops warrant inclusion.


I thought about them but they were the end of last decade really and left the first season of this decade. They would be top of the list 10 years ago
Can only have 25 options and decided on more recent players



I initially would have thought the same..but they played the 2nd half of the 2009/10 season...plus the 10/11 season...they probably would be high in a goals in the decade list..

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 11:15 am

For me players like Marshall,Hudson,Whitt’s and Gunnersson stand out for performing well for quite a number of seasons.
No don’t we have had better quality with the promotions but I’ll go for Whitt’s.

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 11:33 am

theclaw wrote:For me players like Marshall,Hudson,Whitt’s and Gunnersson stand out for performing well for quite a number of seasons.
No don’t we have had better quality with the promotions but I’ll go for Whitt’s.



more or less how I see it...I would add Mozza .over 200 games ,in his 6th season, captain for a big chunk of that including while being promoted..

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 12:17 pm

A very subjective question depending on class, longevity, style, etc.

Personally, I've gone for Craig Bellamy, as he is the player who excited me most by his arrival and pretty much lived up to his (playing) hype!

For longevity and contribution, I would have gone for Whitts :ayatollah:

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Thu Dec 26, 2019 1:15 pm

Can only be the legend that is peter whittingham for me :ayatollah:

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Fri Dec 27, 2019 12:15 am

There can be no debate - its clearly Whits. Macheda included in the list!! Lol

Re: Who is the you're City player of the Decade

Fri Dec 27, 2019 11:37 am

Whitt’s by a country mile