Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Who was your man of the match v Derby County away?

Poll ended at Sun Sep 15, 2019 8:40 pm

Alex Smithies
4
6%
Lee Peltier
0
No votes
Sean Morrison
6
9%
Aden Flint
2
3%
Joe Bennett
0
No votes
Leandro Bacuna
32
47%
Joe Ralls
13
19%
Callum Paterson
0
No votes
Gavin Whyte
3
4%
Josh Murphy
1
1%
Robert Glatzel
6
9%
Junior Hoilett (sub)
1
1%
Nathaniel Mendez-Laing (sub)
0
No votes
Omar Bogle (sub)
0
No votes
 
Total votes : 68

VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Fri Sep 13, 2019 8:40 pm

A point on the road tonight.

Who was your man of the match?

48 hours to vote.

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Fri Sep 13, 2019 8:45 pm

Glatzel for me, won the penalty and took it well getting his 1st goal, almost got his 2nd too before going off just not enough power on it and Clark hooked it away.

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Fri Sep 13, 2019 8:47 pm

Both wingers and Glatzel played well. Will give it to Whyte.

As for the dissapointments Bacuna was quite poor and Morrison who had a horrendous game. Get Etheridge and Bamba back ASAP and we will actually start winning games.

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Fri Sep 13, 2019 8:48 pm

Glatzel .Some of his touches with Murphy were top drawer.Ralls and Bacuna deserve a mention

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Fri Sep 13, 2019 8:48 pm

I thought everybody played OK

Nobody really stood out but nobody had a bad game

I gave it to Smithies for 2 brilliant saves that kept us in the game

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Fri Sep 13, 2019 8:49 pm

phildavies wrote:Both wingers and Glatzel played well. Will give it to Whyte.

As for the dissapointments Bacuna was quite poor and Morrison who had a horrendous game. Get Etheridge and Bamba back ASAP and we will actually start winning games.


Bacuna played well considering he got back to the U.K. late yesterday and hadn’t trained with Cardiff this week

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Fri Sep 13, 2019 8:50 pm

Bacuna for myself, in a game where nobody really stood out. I thought the amount of times he covered for the full backs and got us out of jail was enough for MOTM. One sloop ball at the end but other than that I can’t remember him wasting the ball. Delighted for Glatzel getting his goal, but one of my main gripes tonight is what does Paterson offer us at the moment?

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Fri Sep 13, 2019 8:51 pm

Nobody shone, nobody was that poor except for Patterson.
Bacuna for me.

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Fri Sep 13, 2019 8:51 pm

Between Ralls and Bacuna who is looking very good in midfield at the moment. I thought the main problem was Patterson who was fairly awful in the position Tomlin should be playing.

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Fri Sep 13, 2019 8:54 pm

Crayfish wrote:Between Ralls and Bacuna who is looking very good in midfield at the moment. I thought the main problem was Patterson who was fairly awful in the position Tomlin should be playing.


As an offensive player he offered jackshit I’m afraid.
Bacuna a big improvement than Gunnarsson.

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Fri Sep 13, 2019 8:59 pm

Bacuna my MOM played well considering he hasn’t trained with team, he only got back from South America yesterday.
Robert Glatzel took his pen well hope he now gets more chances to score, he looks like a striker something we haven’t had for years .Another point on our travels onwards and upwards BLUEBIRDS

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Fri Sep 13, 2019 8:59 pm

snoopystorm wrote:
phildavies wrote:Both wingers and Glatzel played well. Will give it to Whyte.

As for the dissapointments Bacuna was quite poor and Morrison who had a horrendous game. Get Etheridge and Bamba back ASAP and we will actually start winning games.


Bacuna played well considering he got back to the U.K. late yesterday and hadn’t trained with Cardiff this week


He didn’t play well IMO and circumstances mean nothing as if he wasn’t prepared to play then he shouldn’t have.

Don’t understand how he is winning this so easily particulary when our wingers played so well today.

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Fri Sep 13, 2019 9:09 pm

phildavies wrote:
snoopystorm wrote:
phildavies wrote:Both wingers and Glatzel played well. Will give it to Whyte.

As for the dissapointments Bacuna was quite poor and Morrison who had a horrendous game. Get Etheridge and Bamba back ASAP and we will actually start winning games.


Bacuna played well considering he got back to the U.K. late yesterday and hadn’t trained with Cardiff this week


He didn’t play well IMO and circumstances mean nothing as if he wasn’t prepared to play then he shouldn’t have.

Don’t understand how he is winning this so easily particulary when our wingers played so well today.


I think the reason he is winning comfortably because in most people’s eyes he done a great job tonight. Our wingers didn’t really have that much of a good game in my eyes, can’t recall any of them creating chances apart from Hoilett.

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Fri Sep 13, 2019 9:10 pm

phildavies wrote:
snoopystorm wrote:
phildavies wrote:Both wingers and Glatzel played well. Will give it to Whyte.

As for the dissapointments Bacuna was quite poor and Morrison who had a horrendous game. Get Etheridge and Bamba back ASAP and we will actually start winning games.


Bacuna played well considering he got back to the U.K. late yesterday and hadn’t trained with Cardiff this week


He didn’t play well IMO and circumstances mean nothing as if he wasn’t prepared to play then he shouldn’t have.

Don’t understand how he is winning this so easily particulary when our wingers played so well today.


He was prepared to play, and imo Bacuna and Ralls worked their socks and they played well.

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Sat Sep 14, 2019 2:00 am

What game was u watching phil davies ur a wind up for sure bacuna was very good Morrison was good ffs

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Sat Sep 14, 2019 7:51 am

Patterson awful can't see how he survived on there 90mins. As for my mom Bacuna for me thought as said above done well covering us defensively thought Bennett was poor also which us why bacuna was needed there. Ralls smithies whyte and glatzel played well

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Sat Sep 14, 2019 7:52 am

Smithies and Bacuna probably the best 2 although thought Morrison had a good game.

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Sat Sep 14, 2019 9:20 am

phildavies wrote:Both wingers and Glatzel played well. Will give it to Whyte.

As for the dissapointments Bacuna was quite poor and Morrison who had a horrendous game. Get Etheridge and Bamba back ASAP and we will actually start winning games.


Did you watch the same game as me :laughing6:

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Sat Sep 14, 2019 9:22 am

thomasblue wrote:I thought everybody played OK

Nobody really stood out but nobody had a bad game

I gave it to Smithies for 2 brilliant saves that kept us in the game


Smithies should have done better with the goal, Etheridge would have held onto that ball or at least pushed it around the post for a corner :thumbup:

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Sat Sep 14, 2019 9:42 am

Igovernor wrote:
thomasblue wrote:I thought everybody played OK

Nobody really stood out but nobody had a bad game

I gave it to Smithies for 2 brilliant saves that kept us in the game


Smithies should have done better with the goal, Etheridge would have held onto that ball or at least pushed it around the post for a corner :thumbup:


I thought it was a great save low down from the distance he shot from.
The defence bay let him down by firstly not defending then secondly reacting slowly to the saved shot.
He had a great game , Ethridge is made out to be this great keeper buy I doubt he would have done anything different to Smithies on that occasion. In fact low shots to his near post is big weakness of Etheridge he is better from long distance

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Sat Sep 14, 2019 12:28 pm

Bacuna for me :bluebird:

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Sat Sep 14, 2019 12:53 pm

Smithies kept us in it with women crucial saves

Re: VOTE " MOTM v Derby County (a) "

Sat Sep 14, 2019 1:22 pm

I am a actually with phildavies on this, Bacuna wasn’t good at all, just gave an awful lot of possession away, he did break a few things up but no enough to be MOM. To be honest, it highlights how desperate we are in midfield that a player who only got back from international duty the day before, started and played 90 mins. He looked shattered and played like he looked.

Patterson - well he’s crap been saying it for ages. Even the flicks or headers he does win are not directed anywhere, he doesn’t bring anything to the side.

Smithies kept us in it, goal not his fault, and there are 5 players in and around him to deal with the save.