Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

OK...who would you retain and, who would you let leave for n

Sun Mar 03, 2019 1:06 am

I'd get rid of

Zahore
Gunnerson
Harris
Hoilett
Richards
Peltier

The Manager??

And retain

Cammarrasa
After
Morrison (decent Championship defender)
Manga
Bennett
Patterson

And try and build a Team around

Reid
Murphy
Camarrasa
After
MDL

Re: OK...who would you retain and, who would you let leave f

Sun Mar 03, 2019 7:37 am

If we are in the championship next season we can forget cammarasa and arter.

Re: OK...who would you retain and, who would you let leave f

Sun Mar 03, 2019 8:06 am

Regardless of what league we are in we should lose:


Jazz Richard's
Matt Connolly
Loic Damour
Lee Tomlin
Stuart o'Keefe
Gary Madine
Danny Ward
Brian Murphy

Out of contract players:

Bruno Manga - Resign urgently
Gunnarsson - gone unless we stay up
Harris - Resign on basic wages

Loans:

Harry Arter - Sign as priority
Camarasa - cant see him staying
Niasse - release


Whichever way you look at it and whatever league we are in. Next season is going to be a major rebuild of our squad

Re: OK...who would you retain and, who would you let leave f

Sun Mar 03, 2019 8:36 am

If we go down it's not going to be a major rebuilding time.

We have plenty of players on sensible wages that are good in the Championship. They've proved missing at times in the Premier League. But they'll be fine next year.

Unlike many teams that get relegated we don't have earners on hundreds of thousands a week that we'll be desperate to get rid of.

There'll be the usual out of contract and a couple sold. And we'll need to sign a few - mainly midfielders. However, it's hardly a major rebuilding task.

Of last team to start. Etheridge, Peltier, Morrison, Bamba, Bennett, Reid, Zohore and Ralls could all stay. Only gunnars out of contract and 2 loans will most likely leave. Add to this lot NML, Murphy, Ward, Cunningham, Smithies, Bacuna and Paterson - that's a decent championship squad.

5 or 6 players probably needed. Hardly a major task! As opposed to Fulham and to an extent Huddersfield with their 30m+ players who will want out immediately...

Re: OK...who would you retain and, who would you let leave f

Sun Mar 03, 2019 10:19 am

We need EVERY player onside right now, so way too early; or has the OP given up on this season already? :? :roll:

It is a FACT that our last 5 games have yielded more points than any of Southampton Brighton, Bournemouth and Leicester (two of whom are right in the battle for that unwanted last spot! ;)

Re: OK...who would you retain and, who would you let leave f

Sun Mar 03, 2019 10:38 am

It will be a case of which ones of them decide to stay. Cant force a players who's crap to leave and cant force a world beater to stay once their heads been turned

Re: OK...who would you retain and, who would you let leave f

Sun Mar 03, 2019 1:22 pm

My biggest worry in the summer is Bruno Manga's contract expiring and the fact there's a high possibility we'll be without Gunnarsson, Arter, and Camarasa so we'll only have Joe Ralls unless Warnock is looking to promote Lloyd Humphries or Sion Spence and if not we'll need a whole new centre midfield. We'll also still need a RB a CB and a ST as well. Would be nice to see some youth given a chance as the under 18's have done brilliantly this season.

Re: OK...who would you retain and, who would you let leave f

Sun Mar 03, 2019 1:27 pm

We also have Tomlin to come back from on loan :lol:
And Bogle and Madine

My biggest worry is that many of the players are very good championship players but will they have the heart to go again knowing they are not good enough for the PL

Re: OK...who would you retain and, who would you let leave f

Sun Mar 03, 2019 5:08 pm

I WOULD GET RID OF:
Reid
Connolly
Richards
Madine

I WOULD KEEP:
Smithies
Bamba
Morrison
Manga
Mendez Laing
Hoilett
Zohore
Ralls
Danny Ward
Healey
Paterson
Josh Murphy
Bennett
Cunningham
Kadeem Harris


THE PLAYERS WHO WILL LEAVE:
Etheridge - A Premier League Team Will Go For Him, Maybe A Newly Promoted Side In The Prem
Gunnarsson - If Reports Are True, He Will Be Leaving To Go To Another Team
Damour - He Wants A Fresh Start Away
Camarasa, Arter & Niasse - Return Back To Parent Clubs Bournemouth, Real Betis & Everton


THIS OF COURSE THE SCENARIO WHERE CARDIFF COULD UNFORTUNATELY GET RELEGATED
BUT AS I SAID ALL SEASON THE BLUEBIRDS WILL SURVIVE

Re: OK...who would you retain and, who would you let leave f

Sun Mar 03, 2019 6:04 pm

Tried not to get involved in this thread because i agree with Sven, but must say any team that would keep Healey and Harris over Reid are preparing for League 1....

Etheridge will still be with us. Distribution is a must for any premier league keeper unless he wants to be third string for a top 10 (he is home grown UK citizen) which i doubt he'll want.

Agree on Gunnar he can't last another season in the championship

Re: OK...who would you retain and, who would you let leave f

Sun Mar 03, 2019 9:04 pm

[quote="City1983"]I'd get rid of

Zahore
Gunnerson
Harris
Hoilett
Richards
Peltier

The Manager??

And retain

Cammarrasa
After
Morrison (decent Championship defender)
Manga
Bennett
Patterson

And try and build a Team around

Reid
Murphy
Camarrasa
After
MDL[/quote What're you on

Re: OK...who would you retain and, who would you let leave f

Mon Mar 04, 2019 12:14 pm

Its impossible to tell but whatever the league the midfield needs urgent attention. If we stay up we have to try and sign Arter and Camarasa which wont come cheap and then we need a quality defensive midfield to replace Gunnersson who I wouldn't resign.

If we went down again I wouldn't resign Gunnerson but other than Ralls who I think is a very good championship player we don't have many options and needs depth.