Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

“ THREE CARDIFF CITY PLAYERS “

Mon Dec 31, 2018 1:16 am

Three of Cardiff City’s players have been selected in Garth Crooks’ team of the week.

Neil Etheridge, Sol Bamba and Victor Camarasa all made it into the XI.


8A4043B8-D8C6-413B-B7E8-C361A2D9AAC5.jpeg



BBC Sport


Liverpool hold a seven-point lead at the top of the Premier League after putting five past Arsenal at Anfield, while Manchester City moved up to second with a 3-1 win at Southampton.

Tottenham slipped to a 3-1 defeat against Wolves at Wembley, N'Golo Kante's second-half strike gave Chelsea a win at Crystal Palace and Manchester United's renaissance under caretaker manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer continued with a 4-1 win over Bournemouth.

Burnley gained three points with a 2-0 victory against West Ham, Fulham beat Huddersfield 1-0 and Cardiff also won by the same scoreline at Leicester City.

Brighton defeated Everton 1-0 and Watford and Newcastle played out a 1-1 draw.

But which players earned a spot in my team of the week?



Neil Etheridge: You can't make three penalty saves in a season and call it a coincidence. This is outstanding shot-stopping. Neil Etheridge's performance against Leicester was simply amazing and the catalyst to Cardiff's first away victory in the Premier League and their performance of the season.

His save from James Maddison's late penalty gave the Bluebirds the impetus to go on and win the match. Thank goodness the Philippines international is not going to the Asian Cup.

Sol Bamba: I never thought I would see three Cardiff players in my team of the week. Sol Bamba's tackle to clear the rebound from the brilliant penalty save by Neil Etheridge was just superb. The Cardiff defender had to be razor sharp in order to stop Maddison from slotting the ball into the back of the net from the keeper's save. The Bluebirds are slowly but surely starting to come to terms with the Premier League.

Wily Boly: His header to equalise was absolutely sensational and set Wolves up for a very impressive win against Spurs. Should Harry Kane have had a penalty when Boly appeared to impede the striker attacking the ball at the near post in the latter stages of the game? You bet your life he should. However, referee Stuart Attwell and his officials thought otherwise and that was the end of that.

Virgil van Dijk: He just seems to stroll through games at the moment. This time it was against Arsenal. I actually felt sorry for Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang. Is anyone really suggesting that if they had played with Aubameyang and substitute Alexandre Lacazette up front together Arsenal could have done any worse? I don't think so. Is Unai Emery losing his nerve against the big teams?

Giorgino Wijnaldum: I've made my case in 'The Crooks of the matter' below why Liverpool find themselves top of the table with one hand on the title. And Georginio Wijnaldum's performance against a totally outclassed Arsenal is another reason why the Merseyside club find themselves in such a glorious position. The ovation the Dutch international received when he left the field after 78 minutes said it all. Manager Jurgen Klopp would be wise to wrap the midfielder up in cotton wool before the game of the season against Manchester City on Thursday.

N’Golo Kante: There has been so much talk among pundits about whether N'Golo Kante should play in a two in front of the back four or in a three behind the centre-forward. Frankly, who cares as long as he's scoring goals. Kante has responded to the requirements set for him by his manager Maurizio Sarri and set Crystal Palace's fortunes back after some impressive performances.

Paul Pogba: Well, well, well. What do we have here? Paul Pogba looking like a leader as well as a player. I said a few days ago that if he listened to top former players more his game would benefit. I don't know who he is listening to at the moment but it seems to be working. His performances over the Christmas period have been nothing short of outstanding. The question now is, can he keep it up?

Fernandinho: Boy, have Manchester City missed this lad. You can talk all you want about Kevin de Bruyne and David Silva but it is clear to me that over the festive period City have not been the same force without Fernandinho. The Brazilian returned from injury for the clash with Southampton and he was instrumental in re-establishing City's personality on the game again. They can't win the title without him.

Victor Camarasa: If ever a goal was worthy of winning a football match then this was it. I had Harry Kane lined up for a place in this team but after Tottenham's capitulation it had to be Victor Camarasa. The injury-time winner sent the Cardiff fans delirious and boy did they deserve it. They have followed their team halfway through the season for this and victories don't come much sweeter.

Roberto Firmino: Just when you thought Liverpool might have had a game on their hands Roberto Firmino smashes a hat-trick past the Gunners. There's no doubt about it, when the Brazilian plays well Liverpool seem to excel. As for Arsenal, manager Emery should know his best team by now and that he does not have a credible defence. This was the worst Arsenal back five I've seen assembled in years. William Gallas and Sol Campbell must be falling about with laughter.

Aleksandar Mitrovic: This was a massive win for Fulham but no thanks to Aboubakar Kamara. The French forward put himself and his ego before the team. Thank goodness for Aleksandar Mitrovic. The Serbia international remained cool when Kamara refused to give him the ball and then missed the spot-kick. Mitrovic's response was to score the winning goal and close the gap in the relegation zone. This has given Fulham a lifeline and hopefully taught Kamara a little humility.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

THREE BLUEBIRDS IN GARTH CROOK'S TEAM OF THE WEEK

Mon Dec 31, 2018 1:51 am

Garth Crooks' Team of the Week includes three Cardiff City players
By Garth Crooks


Goalkeeper

Neil Etheridge
You can't make three penalty saves in a season and call it a coincidence. This is outstanding shot-stopping. Neil Etheridge's performance against Leicester was simply amazing and the catalyst to Cardiff's first away victory in the Premier League and their performance of the season.

His save from James Maddison's late penalty gave the Bluebirds the impetus to go on and win the match. Thank goodness the Philippines international is not going to the Asian Cup.

Did you know? Etheridge's three penalty saves in 2018-19 is more than any other keeper in the Premier League this season.


Defenders - Sol Bamba (Cardiff City), Willy Boly (Wolverhampton Wanderers) and Virgil van Dijk (Liverpool)

Sol Bamba: I never thought I would see three Cardiff players in my team of the week. Sol Bamba's tackle to clear the rebound from the brilliant penalty save by Neil Etheridge was just superb. The Cardiff defender had to be razor sharp in order to stop Maddison from slotting the ball into the back of the net from the keeper's save.

The Bluebirds are slowly but surely starting to come to terms with the Premier League.

Did you know? Bamba made nine clearances against Leicester; four more than any other Cardiff player.


Willy Boly: His header to equalise was absolutely sensational and set Wolves up for a very impressive win against Spurs. Should Harry Kane have had a penalty when Boly appeared to impede the striker attacking the ball at the near post in the latter stages of the game? You bet your life he should. However, referee Stuart Attwell and his officials thought otherwise and that was the end of that.

Did you know? Boly won 77.8% of his duels against Spurs; more than any other Wolves player.


Virgil van Dijk: He just seems to stroll through games at the moment. This time it was against Arsenal. I actually felt sorry for Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang. Is anyone really suggesting that if they had played with Aubameyang and substitute Alexandre Lacazette up front together Arsenal could have done any worse? I don't think so. Is Unai Emery losing his nerve against the big teams?

Did you know? Van Dijk completed 57 of his 60 passes (95%) against Arsenal, making four clearances and gaining possession six times.


Midfielders - Georginio Wijnaldum (Liverpool), N'Golo Kante (Chelsea), Paul Pogba (Manchester United), Fernandinho (Manchester City) and Victor Camarasa (Cardiff City)

Georginio Wijnaldum: I've made my case in 'The Crooks of the matter' below why Liverpool find themselves top of the table with one hand on the title. And Georginio Wijnaldum's performance against a totally outclassed Arsenal is another reason why the Merseyside club find themselves in such a glorious position. The ovation the Dutch international received when he left the field after 78 minutes said it all.

Manager Jurgen Klopp would be wise to wrap the midfielder up in cotton wool before the game of the season against Manchester City on Thursday.

Did you know? Wijnaldum contested more duels than any other Liverpool player in their 5-1 win over Arsenal (14), winning 71.4% of them.


N'Golo Kante: There has been so much talk among pundits about whether N'Golo Kante should play in a two in front of the back four or in a three behind the centre-forward. Frankly, who cares as long as he's scoring goals. Kante has responded to the requirements set for him by his manager Maurizio Sarri and set Crystal Palace's fortunes back after some impressive performances.

Did you know? Kante scored his third league goal of the season - his best return in a single campaign in the top five European leagues.


Paul Pogba: Well, well, well. What do we have here? Paul Pogba looking like a leader as well as a player. I said a few days ago that if he listened to top former players more his game would benefit. I don't know who he is listening to at the moment but it seems to be working. His performances over the Christmas period have been nothing short of outstanding. The question now is, can he keep it up?

Did you know? Pogba is the first Manchester United player to score at least twice in consecutive Premier League appearances since Wayne Rooney in December 2012.


Fernandinho: Boy, have Manchester City missed this lad. You can talk all you want about Kevin de Bruyne and David Silva but it is clear to me that over the festive period City have not been the same force without Fernandinho. The Brazilian returned from injury for the clash with Southampton and he was instrumental in re-establishing City's personality on the game again. They can't win the title without him.

Did you know? Fernandinho created two chances, played 75 passes and made one interception in the 3-1 win against Southampton.


Victor Camarasa: If ever a goal was worthy of winning a football match then this was it. I had Harry Kane lined up for a place in this team but after Tottenham's capitulation it had to be Victor Camarasa. The injury-time winner sent the Cardiff fans delirious and boy did they deserve it. They have followed their team halfway through the season for this and victories don't come much sweeter.

Did you know? Along with his 92nd-minute winner, Camarasa created more chances (two), made more passes (48) and had more touches (70) than any other Cardiff player.


Forwards - Roberto Firmino (Liverpool) and Aleksandar Mitrovic (Fulham)

Roberto Firmino: Just when you thought Liverpool might have had a game on their hands Roberto Firmino smashes a hat-trick past the Gunners. There's no doubt about it, when the Brazilian plays well Liverpool seem to excel.

As for Arsenal, manager Emery should know his best team by now and that he does not have a credible defence. This was the worst Arsenal back five I've seen assembled in years. William Gallas and Sol Campbell must be falling about with laughter.

Did you know? Firmino has become the third Brazilian player to score a Premier League hat-trick, after Robinho (for Manchester City v Stoke in October 2008) and Afonso Alves (for Middlesbrough v Manchester City in May 2008).


Aleksandar Mitrovic: This was a massive win for Fulham but no thanks to Aboubakar Kamara. The French forward put himself and his ego before the team. Thank goodness for Aleksandar Mitrovic. The Serbia international remained cool when Kamara refused to give him the ball and then missed the spot-kick.

Mitrovic's response was to score the winning goal and close the gap in the relegation zone. This has given Fulham a lifeline and hopefully taught Kamara a little humility.

Did you know? During 2018, Mitrovic scored 20 league goals for Fulham - seven more than any other Cottagers player.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: “ THREE CARDIFF CITY PLAYERS “

Mon Dec 31, 2018 10:41 am

Old toad face sounded complimentary towards us, maybe we’ve started winning over pundits

Re: “ THREE CARDIFF CITY PLAYERS “

Mon Dec 31, 2018 11:12 am

Wolfpac wrote:Old toad face sounded complimentary towards us, maybe we’ve started winning over pundits


Still early days yet; but I think pundits are realising there is more to Neil Warnock's Cardiff City than originally thought! :thumbright: :D

Re: “ THREE CARDIFF CITY PLAYERS “

Mon Dec 31, 2018 11:13 am

Wolfpac wrote:Old toad face sounded complimentary towards us, maybe we’ve started winning over pundits



I would rather our players get credit than not get it

but this overpaid dinosaur has proved beyond doubt he doesn't even watch the games..

Re: “ THREE CARDIFF CITY PLAYERS “

Mon Dec 31, 2018 12:00 pm

He will be saying that Etheridge will be close to the England squad soon.

Re: “ THREE CARDIFF CITY PLAYERS “

Mon Dec 31, 2018 12:46 pm

Still can’t stand the no necked dweeb. :laughing6:

Re: “ THREE CARDIFF CITY PLAYERS “

Mon Dec 31, 2018 1:11 pm

Don't normally give a toss as it's basically a team of 11 goalscorers regardless of how well everyone else plays, but in this instance Cheers Garth :ayatollah:

Re: “ THREE CARDIFF CITY PLAYERS “

Mon Dec 31, 2018 1:20 pm

TommyP wrote:Don't normally give a toss as it's basically a team of 11 goalscorers regardless of how well everyone else plays, but in this instance Cheers Garth :ayatollah:


Vincent Tan will be happy, then...according to your reckoning Neil Etheridge is finally on the score sheet! :laughing6:

Let's take any credit this team gets and build confidence for the long, hard road ahead :thumbright: :ayatollah:

Re: “ THREE CARDIFF CITY PLAYERS “

Mon Dec 31, 2018 1:24 pm

Did you know? Etheridge's three penalty saves in 2018-19 is more than any other keeper in the Premier League this season.

Don't think that is right. I'm sure the West Ham keeper ex-Jack Fabianski has saved 3 on the trot this season.

Re: “ THREE CARDIFF CITY PLAYERS “

Mon Dec 31, 2018 2:08 pm

Bakedalasker wrote:Did you know? Etheridge's three penalty saves in 2018-19 is more than any other keeper in the Premier League this season.

Don't think that is right. I'm sure the West Ham keeper ex-Jack Fabianski has saved 3 on the trot this season.


Maybe that was in cup games cause he's only got 1 PL penalty save this season. I wish he had 3 cause he's in my Fantasy football team :lol:

Re: “ THREE CARDIFF CITY PLAYERS “

Mon Dec 31, 2018 2:10 pm

Sven wrote:
TommyP wrote:Don't normally give a toss as it's basically a team of 11 goalscorers regardless of how well everyone else plays, but in this instance Cheers Garth :ayatollah:


Vincent Tan will be happy, then...according to your reckoning Neil Etheridge is finally on the score sheet! :laughing6:

Let's take any credit this team gets and build confidence for the long, hard road ahead :thumbright: :ayatollah:


To be fair Etheridge's penalty save and Bamba's follow up clearance were basically celebrated like a goal so I'll let Garth off this one week ;)

Re: “ THREE CARDIFF CITY PLAYERS “

Mon Dec 31, 2018 2:42 pm

And Robbie Savage's :bluebird:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: “ THREE CARDIFF CITY PLAYERS “

Mon Dec 31, 2018 4:22 pm

Bakedalasker wrote:Did you know? Etheridge's three penalty saves in 2018-19 is more than any other keeper in the Premier League this season.

Don't think that is right. I'm sure the West Ham keeper ex-Jack Fabianski has saved 3 on the trot this season.


Etheridge is top in terms of saves and penalty saved so far this season. Can't you believe that the Bluebirds has the top keeper in EPL?

Re: “ THREE CARDIFF CITY PLAYERS “

Tue Jan 01, 2019 1:56 pm

ryan4480 wrote:
Bakedalasker wrote:Did you know? Etheridge's three penalty saves in 2018-19 is more than any other keeper in the Premier League this season.

Don't think that is right. I'm sure the West Ham keeper ex-Jack Fabianski has saved 3 on the trot this season.


Etheridge is top in terms of saves and penalty saved so far this season. Can't you believe that the Bluebirds has the top keeper in EPL?


Only because amount of shots we have had.