Madine or Bogle?

IMHO Omar Bogle would be a better and much cheaper as an option. Scored his first goal for Brum today. Obviously we need a new signing at centre forward, but loaning out Madine (or selling if poss) and replacing with Bogle would be a positive move.

Id rather keep Medine, one goal and no doubt a lot more minutes in the pitch in the championship is not the answer.

Madine has never been given a chance. Who can judge a player on 10mins here 10mins there.
Our record on judging players like this is crap...our fans are the worse judge of players, thank god we don't have a say.

Madine has never been given a chance. Who can judge a player on 10mins here 10mins there.
Our record on judging players like this is crap...our fans are the worse judge of players, thank god we don't have a say.

thought he did ok in the games he played last season , this season its 6 mins is his longest outing , assume the manager doesn't think he can cut it at this level. as for Bogle I didn't think he looked to bad but the manager didn't take long moving him out and doesn't seem to be doing much at Brum. { only 3 starts and sometimes comes off the bench others he doesn't out of 24 games }

Bogle for me every day of the week

Bogle had a big falling out with warnock. Same as pilks and tomlin. That’s why neither are in the squad and bogle is out on loan. Also why we haven’t seen any of them since the middle of last season. Everyone knows warnock don’t take no shit

Madine has never been given a chance. Who can judge a player on 10mins here 10mins there.
Our record on judging players like this is crap...our fans are the worse judge of players, thank god we don't have a say.

Well you say this, but isn't Warnock proving those fans right? He sees him week in and week out in training ontop of his appearances last season. And he's realised he was a waste of money. Sometimes you just have to admit a player is shit and move him on. He's got no pace and no quality.

people still slate madine even tho he didnt score second half season for us he still out scored zohore

I think if Madine had scored that penalty he would have had a different time with us. His confidence is shot and is having no chances to change that, he needs time on the pitch and a goal which he is not likely to get.

I would choose Pilkington over both if i was picking the squad

Bogle is better but he’s a massive bellend who’s going to waste his career.

Got bombed out because he misses training not for his ability

Id bet Brum would happily swap and have Medine, no doubt he would have got more game time and goals for them as well.