Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Tue Dec 25, 2018 3:30 pm

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/46649000

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Tue Dec 25, 2018 3:45 pm

dogfound wrote:https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/46649000



will play in their first group game against South Korea on Jan 7th and then come back..

which means he will only miss Gillingham in the FA cup

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Tue Dec 25, 2018 4:23 pm

Wasting money on Smithies even more pointless now.

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Tue Dec 25, 2018 4:53 pm

Great news quiet shocked o

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Tue Dec 25, 2018 7:20 pm

Pencoed wrote:Great news quiet shocked o



same here, its very unusual

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Tue Dec 25, 2018 8:06 pm

I dont understand how paying £4mill for Smithies is a waste of money?

If Etheridge gets injured we have a very good goalkeeper to step straight into the team. If we had not signed him and we had to play Murphy people would be having a go because we didnt sign a back up player like is currently happening with our right back situation.

Sometimes the club cant win

Yes there may have been other options cheaper but we chose Smithies over paying huge wages to over the hill keepers to sit on the bench

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Tue Dec 25, 2018 8:20 pm

thomasblue wrote:I dont understand how paying £4mill for Smithies is a waste of money?

If Etheridge gets injured we have a very good goalkeeper to step straight into the team. If we had not signed him and we had to play Murphy people would be having a go because we didnt sign a back up player like is currently happening with our right back situation.

Sometimes the club cant win

Yes there may have been other options cheaper but we chose Smithies over paying huge wages to over the hill keepers to sit on the bench



we gave Murphy a new contract..and the few occasions he has been used he has not let us down..yes its nice to have back up but seriously how this back up keeper was a bigger priority than a right back for the first 11 beats me..
we are so short on quality back ups should be the under 23s and all money spent really should be aimed at 1 to 11

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Tue Dec 25, 2018 11:53 pm

dogfound wrote:
thomasblue wrote:I dont understand how paying £4mill for Smithies is a waste of money?

If Etheridge gets injured we have a very good goalkeeper to step straight into the team. If we had not signed him and we had to play Murphy people would be having a go because we didnt sign a back up player like is currently happening with our right back situation.

Sometimes the club cant win

Yes there may have been other options cheaper but we chose Smithies over paying huge wages to over the hill keepers to sit on the bench



we gave Murphy a new contract..and the few occasions he has been used he has not let us down..yes its nice to have back up but seriously how this back up keeper was a bigger priority than a right back for the first 11 beats me..
we are so short on quality back ups should be the under 23s and all money spent really should be aimed at 1 to 11


Exactly we wasted millions on a back up keeper when Murphy was already a fine replacement and if we were that desperate could have got a free transferee in as back up. Whilst we didn’t address the fact that we desperately needed a RB and also to strengthen even further up top and in midfield.

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Wed Dec 26, 2018 12:05 am

phildavies wrote:
dogfound wrote:
thomasblue wrote:I dont understand how paying £4mill for Smithies is a waste of money?

If Etheridge gets injured we have a very good goalkeeper to step straight into the team. If we had not signed him and we had to play Murphy people would be having a go because we didnt sign a back up player like is currently happening with our right back situation.

Sometimes the club cant win

Yes there may have been other options cheaper but we chose Smithies over paying huge wages to over the hill keepers to sit on the bench



we gave Murphy a new contract..and the few occasions he has been used he has not let us down..yes its nice to have back up but seriously how this back up keeper was a bigger priority than a right back for the first 11 beats me..
we are so short on quality back ups should be the under 23s and all money spent really should be aimed at 1 to 11


Exactly we wasted millions on a back up keeper when Murphy was already a fine replacement and if we were that desperate could have got a free transferee in as back up. Whilst we didn’t address the fact that we desperately needed a RB and also to strengthen even further up top and in midfield.



I really don't like being critical of our manager but this one makes no sense to me..at worse Etheridge was going to miss 2/3 games..

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Wed Dec 26, 2018 5:29 am

All premier league clubs have at least 3 keepers. We are with the big boys now.

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Wed Dec 26, 2018 11:38 am

Bluesman wrote:All premier league clubs have at least 3 keepers. We are with the big boys now.


We already had 3 keepers. Sorry but this signing was nothing more than a waste of millions which could have been much better spent.

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Wed Dec 26, 2018 1:49 pm

You need two quality players in every position in this league.

If Etheridge got injured we would be left with Murphy who is nowhere near good enough for the Premier league and a kid as back up. Everybody would then be berating Warnock for not having a second keeper.

Nobody including Warnock knew if Etheridge was going to be able to make the step up either so another goalkeeper was essential in the summer.

If anything it was £10mill Bobby Reid who was not needed as we have numerous players who can play his role.

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Wed Dec 26, 2018 2:01 pm

thomasblue wrote:You need two quality players in every position in this league.

If Etheridge got injured we would be left with Murphy who is nowhere near good enough for the Premier league and a kid as back up. Everybody would then be berating Warnock for not having a second keeper.

Nobody including Warnock knew if Etheridge was going to be able to make the step up either so another goalkeeper was essential in the summer.

If anything it was £10mill Bobby Reid who was not needed as we have numerous players who can play his role.


Sense at last!
People berating Warnock/the club for signing a decent back up goalkeeper in the premier league .... laughable!
Couldn’t make some of this shit up if you tried.
:lol:

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Thu Dec 27, 2018 1:52 pm

OriginalGrangeEndBlue wrote:
thomasblue wrote:You need two quality players in every position in this league.

If Etheridge got injured we would be left with Murphy who is nowhere near good enough for the Premier league and a kid as back up. Everybody would then be berating Warnock for not having a second keeper.

Nobody including Warnock knew if Etheridge was going to be able to make the step up either so another goalkeeper was essential in the summer.

If anything it was £10mill Bobby Reid who was not needed as we have numerous players who can play his role.


Sense at last!
People berating Warnock/the club for signing a decent back up goalkeeper in the premier league .... laughable!
Couldn’t make some of this shit up if you tried.
:lol:



sense is a player that started yesterday was not needed but a bloke that has yet to play was...wow
Warnock needs to sell a few first teamers and get some more keepers in.

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Thu Dec 27, 2018 4:30 pm

Who says Murphy isn’t good enough? Also what step up the the premier league being a keeper is pretty much the same at every level of professional football :lol:

Your either good or your not I said when we signed Etheridge he would be number one as he was already one of the best in the EFL when playing for Walsall most on here seemed to think Camp would be number one.

We couldn’t have got someone in on a free to be backup keeper and thus had more money to spend on other players in posiitions we needed to strengthen.

Warnock has done a fantastic job for us but if he ever moans about not enough money then he has nobody to blame but himself as he wasted millions on the summer on a back up keeper and lwftback instead of buying in poaoition we needed to strengthen such as RB, Striker and CM.

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Thu Dec 27, 2018 11:12 pm

Well he's missing none! :occasion5:

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Fri Dec 28, 2018 1:33 am

We need more then just two goalkeepers. Every squad in the premier league has three.

It’s not a waste of money at all.

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Fri Dec 28, 2018 2:14 am

Llan_Blue wrote:We need more then just two goalkeepers. Every squad in the premier league has three.

It’s not a waste of money at all.


Spending millions on a back up keeper whilst moaning about not having the money to sign players can only be described as a massive waste of money.

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Fri Dec 28, 2018 3:37 am

phildavies wrote:
Llan_Blue wrote:We need more then just two goalkeepers. Every squad in the premier league has three.

It’s not a waste of money at all.


Spending millions on a back up keeper whilst moaning about not having the money to sign players can only be described as a massive waste of money.

Four million in 2018 isn’t a lot of money.

Could you please tell us who that four million could of been spent on to improve the team?

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Fri Dec 28, 2018 8:54 am

phildavies wrote:
Llan_Blue wrote:We need more then just two goalkeepers. Every squad in the premier league has three.

It’s not a waste of money at all.


Spending millions on a back up keeper whilst moaning about not having the money to sign players can only be described as a massive waste of money.


Etheridge has done really well but who’s to say he wouldn’t have bombed, made a shed full of mistakes or got injured and was out a month or more. May still happen.
That’s why you need a decent back up. And then you need a third decent back up. It’s a no brainier.

Re: Etheridge to miss just 1 game for Asia cup

Fri Dec 28, 2018 9:26 am

Llan_Blue wrote:
phildavies wrote:
Llan_Blue wrote:We need more then just two goalkeepers. Every squad in the premier league has three.

It’s not a waste of money at all.


Spending millions on a back up keeper whilst moaning about not having the money to sign players can only be described as a massive waste of money.

Four million in 2018 isn’t a lot of money.

Could you please tell us who that four million could of been spent on to improve the team?


Moussa Wague as a RB
Erick Gutierrez or Ryan Woods as a CM
Marcos Vinicius Amaral Alves as a Striker

I could go on their we’re plenty of better ways to spend the millions we payed for Smithies and Cunningham