A forum for all things Cardiff City
Mon Dec 24, 2018 11:40 am
Perhaps it’s time to start players In the right positions and give it a run of games.RB to play RB,CB to play CB and Striker to play striker.
So far I’ve seen fullback play up front,centre half play fullback,CM out wide and a few more during games.
There will be plenty of discussion as to whom fills those positions but let’s start these players in the correct positions and see what happens.
Mon Dec 24, 2018 11:52 am
Peltier brief appearances at RB this season have been worrying, he didn’t have the pace or the positioning that Manga has shown to have this season (not the pace but positioning).
So that’s why Manga is Right Back
Camarasa is a Winger, he can play many posittions and he may not be gifted with a lot of pace, but he is a winger for sure. His only burden is that he can play in the middle and behind the striker too...
As for Patterson upfront, he’s scored 4 goals and our only other option was Madine who may I remind you hasn’t scored a single competitive goal for City.
Is this just a post for the sake of posting?
Let’s talk about United
Antonio Valencia is a Winger playing Right Back.
Ashley Young is a Winger playing Left Back
Juan Mata is a Central attacker playing winger
Etc etc
Mon Dec 24, 2018 12:42 pm
Ashley young was taken to the cleaners a few times by Murphy. So not a good example of people playing well , when out of position. Combined with giving the goal away against Liverpool.
Mon Dec 24, 2018 12:47 pm
Savigma wrote:Peltier brief appearances at RB this season have been worrying, he didn’t have the pace or the positioning that Manga has shown to have this season (not the pace but positioning).
So that’s why Manga is Right Back
Camarasa is a Winger, he can play many posittions and he may not be gifted with a lot of pace, but he is a winger for sure. His only burden is that he can play in the middle and behind the striker too...
As for Patterson upfront, he’s scored 4 goals and our only other option was Madine who may I remind you hasn’t scored a single competitive goal for City.
Is this just a post for the sake of posting?
Let’s talk about United
Antonio Valencia is a Winger playing Right Back.
Ashley Young is a Winger playing Left Back
Juan Mata is a Central attacker playing winger
Etc etc
Defensively manga is OK at rb but going forward is shocking and is much better at cb. Peltier hasn't played much so don't see why we can't give him a run of a few games to prove himself.
Camarasa is most definitely not a winger he's much better in the middle where he seems to command the midfield and show some vision.
Mon Dec 24, 2018 12:51 pm
As you pointed out Peltier has a brief opportunity maybe he like the vast majority of the squad needs a run of games,we are almost halfway through the season and still haven’t given players a tidy chance.
As for Patterson he’s done brilliantly but it’s time for a change in my opinion.
As for let’s talk United no thanx.
Mon Dec 24, 2018 12:54 pm
theclaw wrote:As you pointed out Peltier has a brief opportunity maybe he like the vast majority of the squad needs a run of games,we are almost halfway through the season and still haven’t given players a tidy chance.
As for Patterson he’s done brilliantly but it’s time for a change in my opinion.
As for let’s talk United no thanx.
Was gonna say using United players as an example isn't the best as they have alot more quality than our lads (No disrespect to an city players who may be reading this).
Mon Dec 24, 2018 6:15 pm
Manga is scapegoated. He is fine and is our best choice of RB until we sign someone else. Moussa Wagué On loan in January would be choice for his repalcement.
I agree Camarasa is better in the midfield and we are better when we play with two actual wingers.
Patterson is and never was a fullback so people need to stop bringing that up everything about his body shape and the way he plays is suited to being a striker and he has done his job fine so again until we bring someone in who is better he is going to carry on doing a good job for us up top.
Mon Dec 24, 2018 8:47 pm
phildavies wrote:Manga is scapegoated. He is fine and is our best choice of RB until we sign someone else. Moussa Wagué On loan in January would be choice for his repalcement.
I agree Camarasa is better in the midfield and we are better when we play with two actual wingers.
Patterson is and never was a fullback so people need to stop bringing that up everything about his body shape and the way he plays is suited to being a striker and he has done his job fine so again until we bring someone in who is better he is going to carry on doing a good job for us up top.
Yes but some say he’s our best CB so why wouldn’t you play him in his natural position and then pay a right back.
Mon Dec 24, 2018 10:37 pm
theclaw wrote:phildavies wrote:Manga is scapegoated. He is fine and is our best choice of RB until we sign someone else. Moussa Wagué On loan in January would be choice for his repalcement.
I agree Camarasa is better in the midfield and we are better when we play with two actual wingers.
Patterson is and never was a fullback so people need to stop bringing that up everything about his body shape and the way he plays is suited to being a striker and he has done his job fine so again until we bring someone in who is better he is going to carry on doing a good job for us up top.
Yes but some say he’s our best CB so why wouldn’t you play him in his natural position and then pay a right back.
Because none of our RB are anywhere near good enough for the prem so Manga has to play their
Tue Dec 25, 2018 11:37 am
phildavies wrote:theclaw wrote:phildavies wrote:Manga is scapegoated. He is fine and is our best choice of RB until we sign someone else. Moussa Wagué On loan in January would be choice for his repalcement.
I agree Camarasa is better in the midfield and we are better when we play with two actual wingers.
Patterson is and never was a fullback so people need to stop bringing that up everything about his body shape and the way he plays is suited to being a striker and he has done his job fine so again until we bring someone in who is better he is going to carry on doing a good job for us up top.
Yes but some say he’s our best CB so why wouldn’t you play him in his natural position and then pay a right back.
Because none of our RB are anywhere near good enough for the prem so Manga has to play their
I get your logic and your probably pretty much correct but Harris can also play at right back
Personally I am with you that manga really has to play there until we get better but Warnock should have made right back his biggest target in the summer but part of me thinks he doesn’t want to not play any of bamba manga and Morrison and would rather play manga their so he doesn’t have to make the decision
Tue Dec 25, 2018 12:52 pm
I disagree if you are the best in your position that’s where you should play.Camarasa has already proved this.
It’s def time for a change.
Wed Dec 26, 2018 5:17 am
Etherige
Patterson
Magna
Bamba
Morrison
Bennett
Drinkwater
Arter
NML
Zohore
Camarasa
Wed Dec 26, 2018 9:54 am
BlueMoon1974 wrote:Etherige
Patterson
Magna
Bamba
Morrison
Bennett
Drinkwater
Arter
NML
Zohore
Camarasa
So where would you play NML? Wide right? Because that wobt work in a 3-5-2.
Same as Camarasa? Because Camarasa hasn't played on the left? Or are you going to play Camarasa as a striker? Because he isn't one of those either
you've opted to retain one of Bamba and Morrison and dropped the one player who causes danger to opposing teams (Murphy)
Powered by phpBB © phpBB Group.
phpBB Mobile / SEO by Artodia.