Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Following top 20 players - ' Best 16 in your time. '

Fri Nov 02, 2018 9:52 am

For a bit of fun...
What is the greatest team of players from your time watching city.
I started in roughly 96 ( I think )

Schmeichel
Gunter Morrison Bamba Bennett

Routledge Koumas Ramsey Hoilett

Bothroyd Chopra

David Marshall
Glenn Loovens
Kerrea Gilbert
Gary Medel
Earnshaw

Re: Following top 20 players - Best 16 in your time.

Fri Nov 02, 2018 10:01 am

Marshall
McNaughton Gabbidon Loovens Bennett
Hoilett Whitts Koumas Bellamy
Bothroyd Earnshaw

Alexander
Hudson
Gunnarsson
Chopra
Murphy

Re: Following top 20 players - Best 16 in your time.

Fri Nov 02, 2018 10:07 am

Marshall

McNaughton
Hudson
Gabbidon
Bennett

Hoilett
Medel
Ramsey
Bellamy

Bothroyd(such a waste of his career)
Earnshaw

Re: Following top 20 players - Best 16 in your time.

Fri Nov 02, 2018 10:08 am

CaerphillyBluebird15 wrote:For a bit of fun...
What is the greatest team of players from your time watching city.
I started in roughly 96 ( I think )

Schmeichel
Gunter Morrison Bamba Bennett

Routledge Koumas Ramsey Hoilett

Bothroyd Chopra

David Marshall
Glenn Loovens
Kerrea Gilbert
Gary Medel
Earnshaw



I started a long time before that, and I could select a great team if you'd asked for my favourite players, but if I'm honest - because of improved fitness and the speed of the game today -it'd just be the current team.
Some of the very recent ones who you've listed would cope , but our most heroic and iconic players,( who I won't name in this context) would be left standing on the spot by the slowest man in today's team.

Re: Following top 20 players - ' Best 16 in your time. '

Fri Nov 02, 2018 12:01 pm

From 2006 roughly i think

Marshall
Mcnaughton purse johnson hudson bennet
Burke whitts rambo bellamy
Chops

Heaton
Gunners
Koumas
Helguson (always liked him)
Hoilett

Re: Following top 20 players - ' Best 16 in your time. '

Fri Nov 02, 2018 1:50 pm

I saw my first City game in 1950 against Manchester City, and I have been hooked ever since. Some of my favourite players that haven’t been mentioned yet are:- Alf Sherwood (Stanley Matthews very rarely played a league match at the City because of Alf), Stan Montgomery, George Edwards, Mike Tiddy, Ron Howells (Welsh International goalkeeper), Peter Rodrigues, Barrie Hole,Don Murray, Danny Malloy, Doug Livermore, Colin Baker, Leighton Phillips, Mel Sutton, Bobby Woodruff, Roger Gibbins, Johnny Watkins, Dougy Blair, Alan Harrington, Chris Pike, Graham Vearnecombe, Danny Gabbidon,Bobby Brown and Gary Bennett- all very good players. My team from that squad using the old WW formation would have been:-

Howells

Rodrigues Sherwood

Bennett Malloy Hole

Blair Phillips

Tiddy Brown Watkins

Re: Following top 20 players - ' Best 16 in your time. '

Fri Nov 02, 2018 10:16 pm

Marshall
McNaughton / Gabbidon / Morisson /
Ramsey / Bellamy / Whittingham / McPhail
Earnshaw / Bothroyd

Subs:
Kasper / Bamba / Medel / Gunnar / Chopra

Re: Following top 20 players - ' Best 16 in your time. '

Fri Nov 02, 2018 11:08 pm

Marshall

Manga Morrison Bamba Fabio

Gunnerson Patterson Mendez-Laing

Matts Moller Daehli

Kenneth Zohore Bellamy


Kenwyne Jones
Craig Noone
Peter Whittingham
Neil Etheridge
Gary Medel
Joe Bennett
Victor Camarasa
Marko Grujic
Juan Cala

I know most of my picks including the bench might be very polarising. But I get quickly attached to a player. Zohore & Daehli for example, a couple of amazing runs or bits of brilliance makes it hard for them to undo my feelings toward them. I’ll always love watching Zohore play, can’t help it.