Pilkington or Tomlin

If neither left and there was only 1 place left in the 25 man squad who would you pick, for me Tomlin

Tomlin for me as well,just got that bit of something different.

Pilkington all day, true professional.

You obviously didn’t see Tomlin preseason in Cornwall his fitness compared to all the others was frightening.

Pilkington for me. Good pro. Can play striker, on the wing and in midfield. Decent scoring record. Did well when called on last year.More Premier League experience than anyone else in our squad, I think. Tomlin is trouble.

Pilkington all day, true professional.

You obviously didn’t see Tomlin preseason in Cornwall his fitness compared to all the others was frightening.

Tomlin seems to have slimmed down a fair bit, but should it happen either one would only be an impact player for 15 mins and I think Tomlin would have a greater impact