Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

John McGINN

Sun Aug 05, 2018 9:34 pm

Scottish press reporting that we are interested in & have watched the Hibs midfielder.

Re: John McGINN

Sun Aug 05, 2018 9:42 pm

We were linked with him in January.

Perhaps it could be a case of Warnock trying again to get him, like with Cunningham.

Re: John McGINN

Sun Aug 05, 2018 10:09 pm

Neil Lennon hopes "superstar" midfielder John McGinn will remain at Hibernian this season, but fears a bid from England may arrive this week.

The English transfer window closes at 17:00 BST on Thursday, hours before Hibs' Europa League tie with Molde.

Brighton and Hove Albion have held talks with the Leith side over McGinn, 23, but no offer has been submitted.

"It wouldn't surprise me if something was on the table before Thursday," Lennon told BBC Scotland.

"He's a fantastic footballer. I hope we can keep him but it's very difficult when a talent like him is playing like he is."

Scotland international McGinn has a year remaining on his contract and has been the subject of three rejected bids from Celtic this summer.

The midfielder's away goal helped Hibs eliminate Asteras Tripolis from the Europa League last week, and he produced another all-action display as Lennon's men opened their Premiership account with Sunday's 3-0 win over Motherwell.

Hibs host Molde on Thursday, before the return leg of their third qualifying round tie in Norway seven days later.

"To play the way he is with all the speculation - and a concrete bid - is fantastic," the Hibs boss said.

"He's an international, playing at a high level, the quality of his performances, his athleticism, his vision, his goals, he's the complete midfielder player at the minute.

"The money in the game in England doesn't mean the players are better. We've got an absolute superstar here and I hope to get to work with him a bit longer. Maybe not, though, we'll see."

'McGinn better than £25m Grealish' - analysis

Former Dundee United manager and Scotland assistant Peter Houston on Sportsound

Celtic have got to be careful that they don't lose him to England. If it's £3m they've got to pay, he's worth that in this market.

The lad Jack Grealish at Aston Villa is maybe going to Tottenham for £25m but McGinn is a better player in my opinion as a modern-day midfielder. Celtic should bite the hand off Hibs to get him.

Former Hibernian, Dundee and Morton manager Jim Duffy on Sportsound

McGinn was subbed with about 10 minutes to go and he was out on the pitch applauding the fans and you sometimes think, 'is that a send-off?' He was immense today and I'd be amazed if there are no bids before the English transfer window closes.

I'm baffled there are so many bang-ordinary players going in England for £5m just because they can trap a bag of cement. John is top-class and thriving.

Re: John McGINN

Sun Aug 05, 2018 11:24 pm

Good player,well worth a punt I'm. :bluescarf:

Re: John McGINN

Sun Aug 05, 2018 11:25 pm

IMO,FOR I'M :banghead:

Re: John McGINN

Mon Aug 06, 2018 5:38 am

I said at the end of last season we should sign McGinn and Woods. 10m for the pair is a steal. McGinn runs the show for Hibs, even against Celtic he is the stand out player on the park and is incredibly strong on the ball. I expect him to be the future captain of Scotland.

Re: John McGINN

Mon Aug 06, 2018 5:59 am

Hope so, 3 mill would be a steal in the current market.

Re: John McGINN

Mon Aug 06, 2018 7:58 am

What is the source of this link? Brighton is the only Premier League club I can see linked with him.

Re: John McGINN

Mon Aug 06, 2018 8:09 am

DITH80 wrote:What is the source of this link? Brighton is the only Premier League club I can see linked with him.


That’s what I want to know this would be a decent signing.

Re: John McGINN

Mon Aug 06, 2018 8:13 am

yes please.....

Re: John McGINN

Mon Aug 06, 2018 9:00 am

Go get him Neil

quality & hungry
:bluebird:

Re: John McGINN

Mon Aug 06, 2018 9:35 am

Boys more than decent, I think he could doa job for the City.

Re: John McGINN

Mon Aug 06, 2018 9:55 am

Blackburn interested as well.

Re: John McGINN

Mon Aug 06, 2018 10:20 am

DITH80 wrote:What is the source of this link? Brighton is the only Premier League club I can see linked with him.


edinburghnews.scotsman.com

No good at doing links!

Re: John McGINN

Mon Aug 06, 2018 11:50 am

https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/ ... -1-4779131

View here :thumbright:

Re: John McGINN

Mon Aug 06, 2018 12:08 pm

Where in the article does it mention that Cardiff City are interested?

Re: John McGINN

Mon Aug 06, 2018 12:09 pm

Now I could see this happening .

Re: John McGINN

Mon Aug 06, 2018 12:15 pm

DITH80 wrote:Where in the article does it mention that Cardiff City are interested?


See what your saying but he will be playing for someone else by the end of the week and they are expecting bid from several clubs and I'd be a bit surprised if we weren't one of those clubs.

Re: John McGINN

Mon Aug 06, 2018 12:31 pm

Llan_Blue wrote:Neil Lennon hopes "superstar" midfielder John McGinn will remain at Hibernian this season, but fears a bid from England may arrive this week.

The English transfer window closes at 17:00 BST on Thursday, hours before Hibs' Europa League tie with Molde.

Brighton and Hove Albion have held talks with the Leith side over McGinn, 23, but no offer has been submitted.

"It wouldn't surprise me if something was on the table before Thursday," Lennon told BBC Scotland.

"He's a fantastic footballer. I hope we can keep him but it's very difficult when a talent like him is playing like he is."

Scotland international McGinn has a year remaining on his contract and has been the subject of three rejected bids from Celtic this summer.

The midfielder's away goal helped Hibs eliminate Asteras Tripolis from the Europa League last week, and he produced another all-action display as Lennon's men opened their Premiership account with Sunday's 3-0 win over Motherwell.

Hibs host Molde on Thursday, before the return leg of their third qualifying round tie in Norway seven days later.

"To play the way he is with all the speculation - and a concrete bid - is fantastic," the Hibs boss said.

"He's an international, playing at a high level, the quality of his performances, his athleticism, his vision, his goals, he's the complete midfielder player at the minute.

"The money in the game in England doesn't mean the players are better. We've got an absolute superstar here and I hope to get to work with him a bit longer. Maybe not, though, we'll see."

'McGinn better than £25m Grealish' - analysis

Former Dundee United manager and Scotland assistant Peter Houston on Sportsound

Celtic have got to be careful that they don't lose him to England. If it's £3m they've got to pay, he's worth that in this market.

The lad Jack Grealish at Aston Villa is maybe going to Tottenham for £25m but McGinn is a better player in my opinion as a modern-day midfielder. Celtic should bite the hand off Hibs to get him.

Former Hibernian, Dundee and Morton manager Jim Duffy on Sportsound

McGinn was subbed with about 10 minutes to go and he was out on the pitch applauding the fans and you sometimes think, 'is that a send-off?' He was immense today and I'd be amazed if there are no bids before the English transfer window closes.

I'm baffled there are so many bang-ordinary players going in England for £5m just because they can trap a bag of cement. John is top-class and thriving.


Fair play to Lennon - knows he's going to lose the player and is talking him up big time in order to get as high a price as he can.

Bit like Lee Clark did at Birmingham when they fleeced us for Tom Adyemi.

Re: John McGINN

Mon Aug 06, 2018 12:51 pm

davids wrote:
Llan_Blue wrote:Neil Lennon hopes "superstar" midfielder John McGinn will remain at Hibernian this season, but fears a bid from England may arrive this week.

The English transfer window closes at 17:00 BST on Thursday, hours before Hibs' Europa League tie with Molde.

Brighton and Hove Albion have held talks with the Leith side over McGinn, 23, but no offer has been submitted.

"It wouldn't surprise me if something was on the table before Thursday," Lennon told BBC Scotland.

"He's a fantastic footballer. I hope we can keep him but it's very difficult when a talent like him is playing like he is."

Scotland international McGinn has a year remaining on his contract and has been the subject of three rejected bids from Celtic this summer.

The midfielder's away goal helped Hibs eliminate Asteras Tripolis from the Europa League last week, and he produced another all-action display as Lennon's men opened their Premiership account with Sunday's 3-0 win over Motherwell.

Hibs host Molde on Thursday, before the return leg of their third qualifying round tie in Norway seven days later.

"To play the way he is with all the speculation - and a concrete bid - is fantastic," the Hibs boss said.

"He's an international, playing at a high level, the quality of his performances, his athleticism, his vision, his goals, he's the complete midfielder player at the minute.

"The money in the game in England doesn't mean the players are better. We've got an absolute superstar here and I hope to get to work with him a bit longer. Maybe not, though, we'll see."

'McGinn better than £25m Grealish' - analysis

Former Dundee United manager and Scotland assistant Peter Houston on Sportsound

Celtic have got to be careful that they don't lose him to England. If it's £3m they've got to pay, he's worth that in this market.

The lad Jack Grealish at Aston Villa is maybe going to Tottenham for £25m but McGinn is a better player in my opinion as a modern-day midfielder. Celtic should bite the hand off Hibs to get him.

Former Hibernian, Dundee and Morton manager Jim Duffy on Sportsound

McGinn was subbed with about 10 minutes to go and he was out on the pitch applauding the fans and you sometimes think, 'is that a send-off?' He was immense today and I'd be amazed if there are no bids before the English transfer window closes.

I'm baffled there are so many bang-ordinary players going in England for £5m just because they can trap a bag of cement. John is top-class and thriving.


Fair play to Lennon - knows he's going to lose the player and is talking him up big time in order to get as high a price as he can.

Bit like Lee Clark did at Birmingham when they fleeced us for Tom Adyemi.


I'd quite forgotten that,however,Warnock isn't a chump like that.

Re: John McGINN

Tue Aug 07, 2018 1:05 pm

Tom adeyemi,he was dubbed the new Jordon Mutch,when we bought him. We could really do with the 2013/14 version of Mutch now.

Re: John McGINN

Tue Aug 07, 2018 1:29 pm

Adeyemi forgot about him.
3 million wasted was it?

Re: John McGINN

Tue Aug 07, 2018 1:59 pm

nojac wrote:Tom adeyemi,he was dubbed the new Jordon Mutch,when we bought him. We could really do with the 2013/14 version of Mutch now.

What an injury prone midfielder lived up to all expectations there hasn’t he :lol:

Re: John McGINN

Tue Aug 07, 2018 2:24 pm

Don't think Warnock will take this any further besides Villa are in pole position to sign him