Thu Dec 28, 2017 9:18 pm
Thu Dec 28, 2017 9:24 pm
Thu Dec 28, 2017 9:25 pm
Thu Dec 28, 2017 9:48 pm
Thu Dec 28, 2017 9:56 pm
pembroke allan wrote:Think someone should ask those fans why they take thousands away while we take hundreds maybe we'll get answer to the question of our low away support? But I wonder Do they compare themselves to us like we compare ourselves to them? To me all fans are different and comparing fans is bit like comparing chalk and cheese?
Thu Dec 28, 2017 10:21 pm
Thu Dec 28, 2017 10:29 pm
Wayne S wrote:Why make comparisons, we are what we are.
This issue only annoys those who think we are bigger than we REALLY are and cannot handle the smaller size of our club.
But is you want to talk analysis of support...... every team has its limits both high and low. Our away support has dropped but will plateau HOWEVER low in the league's we go. This is why club's like Pompey and Luton seem to have high away support compared to their lowly positions.
You are also talking about club's taking large support to cup games against large teams. You will always get a massive uptake for such games.
Thu Dec 28, 2017 11:39 pm
Fri Dec 29, 2017 1:32 am
Stringfellow wrote:Apples and oranges, for me growing up the gunners away, Man City home, Wembley, Liverpool away and even quite recently Chelsea away it's a dream come true. Fast forward all the years, a club who could only dream of playing in them games has now been done and in the championship we have had some big clubs. It's not a dream and is quite a regular thing, the appeal is not the same as it would be for a Grimsby etc.
I see all the decent away followings and respect them, one questions what is the average away support these teams take? Come season end.
I will be honest, not many away games excite me these days. Even goodison park was a total let down. Old Trafford is the only one that would excite me and the jacks is always a pull.
Fri Dec 29, 2017 2:40 am
Fri Dec 29, 2017 9:09 am
Stringfellow wrote:Apples and oranges, for me growing up the gunners away, Man City home, Wembley, Liverpool away and even quite recently Chelsea away it's a dream come true. Fast forward all the years, a club who could only dream of playing in them games has now been done and in the championship we have had some big clubs. It's not a dream and is quite a regular thing, the appeal is not the same as it would be for a Grimsby etc.
I see all the decent away followings and respect them, one questions what is the average away support these teams take? Come season end.
I will be honest, not many away games excite me these days. Even goodison park was a total let down. Old Trafford is the only one that would excite me and the jacks is always a pull.
Fri Dec 29, 2017 9:29 am
ae15 wrote:I don't understand that whenever there are debates on this forum as to why our support is so small why it's never brought up that it might have something to do with the amount of Welsh/home grown talent in the team at the moment.
If you think of the cult players in the team at the moment it's Sol Bamba, Ken Zohore, Bruno and Hoilett. Most of these players have only really gained cult status in the last year too, meaning that the excitement about them has only just began to reach the non diehards. It's hard to gain excitable supporters when they feel they can barely relate to the players.
I remember the excitement that came to the club when Bellamy signed. It was certainly the most excited I have been supporting the Bluebirds. Even the Premier League and promotion wasn't as exciting and that wasn't just rebrand based.
Fri Dec 29, 2017 9:43 am
Fri Dec 29, 2017 10:37 am
Gaynor Straight wrote:So are all the extra Luton fans going to Newcastle just a bunch of plastics/glory hunters and not their die-hard fans?
Fri Dec 29, 2017 10:41 am
Forever Blue wrote:Stringfellow wrote:Apples and oranges, for me growing up the gunners away, Man City home, Wembley, Liverpool away and even quite recently Chelsea away it's a dream come true. Fast forward all the years, a club who could only dream of playing in them games has now been done and in the championship we have had some big clubs. It's not a dream and is quite a regular thing, the appeal is not the same as it would be for a Grimsby etc.
I see all the decent away followings and respect them, one questions what is the average away support these teams take? Come season end.
I will be honest, not many away games excite me these days. Even goodison park was a total let down. Old Trafford is the only one that would excite me and the jacks is always a pull.
Answering your question![]()
Gareth, their average away support so far for this season in League 2(Div 4) is approx 1,300.
Our is just over 1,400, Championship.
Come the end of last season ours was 780, Lutons was 1,300 approx.
Gareth you asked the question![]()
Ours is
Fri Dec 29, 2017 10:45 am
Gaynor Straight wrote:So are all the extra Luton fans going to Newcastle just a bunch of plastics/glory hunters and not their die-hard fans?
Fri Dec 29, 2017 10:50 am
Forever Blue wrote:Gaynor Straight wrote:So are all the extra Luton fans going to Newcastle just a bunch of plastics/glory hunters and not their die-hard fans?
They average 8,500 fans at home, their capacity is only 10,000 including away fans.
Fri Dec 29, 2017 10:52 am
Stringfellow wrote:Forever Blue wrote:Stringfellow wrote:Apples and oranges, for me growing up the gunners away, Man City home, Wembley, Liverpool away and even quite recently Chelsea away it's a dream come true. Fast forward all the years, a club who could only dream of playing in them games has now been done and in the championship we have had some big clubs. It's not a dream and is quite a regular thing, the appeal is not the same as it would be for a Grimsby etc.
I see all the decent away followings and respect them, one questions what is the average away support these teams take? Come season end.
I will be honest, not many away games excite me these days. Even goodison park was a total let down. Old Trafford is the only one that would excite me and the jacks is always a pull.
Answering your question![]()
Gareth, their average away support so far for this season in League 2(Div 4) is approx 1,300.
Our is just over 1,400, Championship.
Come the end of last season ours was 780, Lutons was 1,300 approx.
Gareth you asked the question![]()
Ours is
Then we are massively up on last year despite reading and Brum being on sky at non sociable times, hats off to Luton.
Fri Dec 29, 2017 10:53 am
Gaynor Straight wrote:Forever Blue wrote:Gaynor Straight wrote:So are all the extra Luton fans going to Newcastle just a bunch of plastics/glory hunters and not their die-hard fans?
They average 8,500 fans at home, their capacity is only 10,000 including away fans.
Didn't know that. Fair play that's excellent
Fri Dec 29, 2017 1:07 pm
Forever Blue wrote:ae15 wrote:I don't understand that whenever there are debates on this forum as to why our support is so small why it's never brought up that it might have something to do with the amount of Welsh/home grown talent in the team at the moment.
If you think of the cult players in the team at the moment it's Sol Bamba, Ken Zohore, Bruno and Hoilett. Most of these players have only really gained cult status in the last year too, meaning that the excitement about them has only just began to reach the non diehards. It's hard to gain excitable supporters when they feel they can barely relate to the players.
I remember the excitement that came to the club when Bellamy signed. It was certainly the most excited I have been supporting the Bluebirds. Even the Premier League and promotion wasn't as exciting and that wasn't just rebrand based.
I have always said having local players helps big time and gives that little bit extra as fans feel closer to their club and feel more when they see their local players on the pitch out there.
Interesting question, the current regime have been in total control for nearly 8 years and said they were putting money i to our academy and cared out it, which I did not believe at the time.
How many local players in the last 8 years have made it from our academy?
Fri Dec 29, 2017 1:32 pm
ae15 wrote:Forever Blue wrote:ae15 wrote:I don't understand that whenever there are debates on this forum as to why our support is so small why it's never brought up that it might have something to do with the amount of Welsh/home grown talent in the team at the moment.
If you think of the cult players in the team at the moment it's Sol Bamba, Ken Zohore, Bruno and Hoilett. Most of these players have only really gained cult status in the last year too, meaning that the excitement about them has only just began to reach the non diehards. It's hard to gain excitable supporters when they feel they can barely relate to the players.
I remember the excitement that came to the club when Bellamy signed. It was certainly the most excited I have been supporting the Bluebirds. Even the Premier League and promotion wasn't as exciting and that wasn't just rebrand based.
I have always said having local players helps big time and gives that little bit extra as fans feel closer to their club and feel more when they see their local players on the pitch out there.
Interesting question, the current regime have been in total control for nearly 8 years and said they were putting money i to our academy and cared out it, which I did not believe at the time.
How many local players in the last 8 years have made it from our academy?
Off the top of my head - Adam Matthews, Joe Ledley, Darcy Blake, Declan John - players that came straight out of our academy. We have players who we signed young and bedded them in, like Kadeem and Rhys Healey, but it's been 4 years since we've had a player playing regular first team football from the academy.
My dad, who although being a Cardiff fan is primarily Wales, doesn't pay much interest to the games at all anymore because of this reason. You can guarantee that if there were more local players in the team he would be paying attention. I would imagine he isn't the only one in the same position.
Fri Dec 29, 2017 1:35 pm
dogfound wrote:ae15 wrote:Forever Blue wrote:ae15 wrote:I don't understand that whenever there are debates on this forum as to why our support is so small why it's never brought up that it might have something to do with the amount of Welsh/home grown talent in the team at the moment.
If you think of the cult players in the team at the moment it's Sol Bamba, Ken Zohore, Bruno and Hoilett. Most of these players have only really gained cult status in the last year too, meaning that the excitement about them has only just began to reach the non diehards. It's hard to gain excitable supporters when they feel they can barely relate to the players.
I remember the excitement that came to the club when Bellamy signed. It was certainly the most excited I have been supporting the Bluebirds. Even the Premier League and promotion wasn't as exciting and that wasn't just rebrand based.
I have always said having local players helps big time and gives that little bit extra as fans feel closer to their club and feel more when they see their local players on the pitch out there.
Interesting question, the current regime have been in total control for nearly 8 years and said they were putting money i to our academy and cared out it, which I did not believe at the time.
How many local players in the last 8 years have made it from our academy?
Off the top of my head - Adam Matthews, Joe Ledley, Darcy Blake, Declan John - players that came straight out of our academy. We have players who we signed young and bedded them in, like Kadeem and Rhys Healey, but it's been 4 years since we've had a player playing regular first team football from the academy.
My dad, who although being a Cardiff fan is primarily Wales, doesn't pay much interest to the games at all anymore because of this reason. You can guarantee that if there were more local players in the team he would be paying attention. I would imagine he isn't the only one in the same position.
im afraid Declan John is the only accademy player out of the 4 you name who made his 1st team debut while the current regime have been in charge..or within 8 years....
having said that the only period we produced 1st team players in any numbers was the early 2000s.
even our 1927 FA cup winning team only had 3 welshmen
Fri Dec 29, 2017 6:03 pm
ae15 wrote:dogfound wrote:ae15 wrote:Forever Blue wrote:ae15 wrote:I don't understand that whenever there are debates on this forum as to why our support is so small why it's never brought up that it might have something to do with the amount of Welsh/home grown talent in the team at the moment.
If you think of the cult players in the team at the moment it's Sol Bamba, Ken Zohore, Bruno and Hoilett. Most of these players have only really gained cult status in the last year too, meaning that the excitement about them has only just began to reach the non diehards. It's hard to gain excitable supporters when they feel they can barely relate to the players.
I remember the excitement that came to the club when Bellamy signed. It was certainly the most excited I have been supporting the Bluebirds. Even the Premier League and promotion wasn't as exciting and that wasn't just rebrand based.
I have always said having local players helps big time and gives that little bit extra as fans feel closer to their club and feel more when they see their local players on the pitch out there.
Interesting question, the current regime have been in total control for nearly 8 years and said they were putting money i to our academy and cared out it, which I did not believe at the time.
How many local players in the last 8 years have made it from our academy?
Off the top of my head - Adam Matthews, Joe Ledley, Darcy Blake, Declan John - players that came straight out of our academy. We have players who we signed young and bedded them in, like Kadeem and Rhys Healey, but it's been 4 years since we've had a player playing regular first team football from the academy.
My dad, who although being a Cardiff fan is primarily Wales, doesn't pay much interest to the games at all anymore because of this reason. You can guarantee that if there were more local players in the team he would be paying attention. I would imagine he isn't the only one in the same position.
im afraid Declan John is the only accademy player out of the 4 you name who made his 1st team debut while the current regime have been in charge..or within 8 years....
having said that the only period we produced 1st team players in any numbers was the early 2000s.
even our 1927 FA cup winning team only had 3 welshmen
Don't worry, I did realise that! Just saying which players who had come through the academy were playing during that period. It is incredibly worrying that in the last 8 years we've only had one first teamer come through the academy.
Fri Dec 29, 2017 6:07 pm
ae15 wrote:Forever Blue wrote:ae15 wrote:I don't understand that whenever there are debates on this forum as to why our support is so small why it's never brought up that it might have something to do with the amount of Welsh/home grown talent in the team at the moment.
If you think of the cult players in the team at the moment it's Sol Bamba, Ken Zohore, Bruno and Hoilett. Most of these players have only really gained cult status in the last year too, meaning that the excitement about them has only just began to reach the non diehards. It's hard to gain excitable supporters when they feel they can barely relate to the players.
I remember the excitement that came to the club when Bellamy signed. It was certainly the most excited I have been supporting the Bluebirds. Even the Premier League and promotion wasn't as exciting and that wasn't just rebrand based.
I have always said having local players helps big time and gives that little bit extra as fans feel closer to their club and feel more when they see their local players on the pitch out there.
Interesting question, the current regime have been in total control for nearly 8 years and said they were putting money i to our academy and cared out it, which I did not believe at the time.
How many local players in the last 8 years have made it from our academy?
Off the top of my head - Adam Matthews, Joe Ledley, Darcy Blake, Declan John - players that came straight out of our academy. We have players who we signed young and bedded them in, like Kadeem and Rhys Healey, but it's been 4 years since we've had a player playing regular first team football from the academy.
My dad, who although being a Cardiff fan is primarily Wales, doesn't pay much interest to the games at all anymore because of this reason. You can guarantee that if there were more local players in the team he would be paying attention. I would imagine he isn't the only one in the same position.
Fri Dec 29, 2017 6:16 pm
Stringfellow wrote:Gaynor Straight wrote:So are all the extra Luton fans going to Newcastle just a bunch of plastics/glory hunters and not their die-hard fans?
Hate that term, everybody is different. You have suppprters like myself who do 80% of home games and 5 or 6 away, you get the guys who don't miss a home game never go away, ones who do them all and ones who dip in and out. They are all supporters of Cardiff city. Some have work commitments and young children, things change through your life but wherever you are in the world or however many games you attend no doubt the majority are bluebirds.
Fri Dec 29, 2017 8:38 pm
Sat Dec 30, 2017 9:48 am
dogfound wrote:Stringfellow wrote:Gaynor Straight wrote:So are all the extra Luton fans going to Newcastle just a bunch of plastics/glory hunters and not their die-hard fans?
Hate that term, everybody is different. You have suppprters like myself who do 80% of home games and 5 or 6 away, you get the guys who don't miss a home game never go away, ones who do them all and ones who dip in and out. They are all supporters of Cardiff city. Some have work commitments and young children, things change through your life but wherever you are in the world or however many games you attend no doubt the majority are bluebirds.
i think the remark was made tongue in cheek..because on here this weeks die hard is next weeks glory hunter and vice versa..
as for Luton no doubt to some degree all travelling feel they are Luton fans. but they dont take 7k away every other week. doesnt make them die hards or glory hunters..
Sat Dec 30, 2017 10:45 am
Sat Dec 30, 2017 10:48 am
Blueboys1927 wrote:Some of the smaller clubs have a lot more passion and dwarf our away support. We use to take thousands to certain games, in the lower league we would take more away than we would get at home. We are not a big club, never have been really, but I thought we have always been at least a mid size club, but looking at where we are in the league and size of the City our home and away crowds are that of a small to aspiring mid size football club