Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

David marshall

Sat Oct 28, 2017 11:24 am

I just noticed he is not starting for Hull.....would you make a grab for him to come back at Christmas......i personally don’t like going back in for players that have gone but I would take him back as he never wanted to go.... :ayatollah:

Re: David marshall

Sat Oct 28, 2017 11:26 am

krabb wrote:I just noticed he is not starting for Hull.....would you make a grab for him to come back at Christmas......i personally don’t like going back in for players that have gone but I would take him back as he never wanted to go.... :ayatollah:


Didn't want him to go, but not now. Both he and City have moved on too far and City have keepers who can more than hold their own on a team pushing at the top! :ayatollah:

Re: David marshall

Sat Oct 28, 2017 11:40 am

Sven wrote:
krabb wrote:I just noticed he is not starting for Hull.....would you make a grab for him to come back at Christmas......i personally don’t like going back in for players that have gone but I would take him back as he never wanted to go.... :ayatollah:


Didn't want him to go, but not now. Both he and City have moved on too far and City have keepers who can more than hold their own on a team pushing at the top! :ayatollah:

I felt he was like a duck out of water when he went...never looked happy or confident...... :ayatollah:

Re: David marshall

Sat Oct 28, 2017 5:07 pm

He's only getting older. If we did sign him he would be lacking game time and he would be a year and a half older than since we let him go.
Etheridge and Camp will do us fine this season :)

Re: David marshall

Sat Oct 28, 2017 5:44 pm

krabb wrote:I just noticed he is not starting for Hull.....would you make a grab for him to come back at Christmas......i personally don’t like going back in for players that have gone but I would take him back as he never wanted to go.... :ayatollah:

Other areas of the team striker/midfield needed first.

Re: David marshall

Sat Oct 28, 2017 6:39 pm

No, as much as he was geeat for us his salary would be too high and we already have 3 good keepers

Re: David marshall

Sat Oct 28, 2017 8:27 pm

I thought Etheridge was very good today. He has generally been very good with the exception of the 2 games we have lost. 12 out of 14 is pretty good for me.

Re: David marshall

Sat Oct 28, 2017 11:06 pm

welshrarebit wrote:I thought Etheridge was very good today. He has generally been very good with the exception of the 2 games we have lost. 12 out of 14 is pretty good for me.


Agree - Amazed how some on here have a go at Etheridge :?: and Marshall is better than Camp ;)

Re: David marshall

Sat Oct 28, 2017 11:30 pm

Not sure why we suddenly need him. Which team has conceded the least amount of goals in the Championship so far this season. Clue - begins with C and ends with F.

Re: David marshall

Sun Oct 29, 2017 2:51 am

Steve Zodiak wrote:Not sure why we suddenly need him. Which team has conceded the least amount of goals in the Championship so far this season. Clue - begins with C and ends with F.



the amount of goalkeeper threads this season is bizarre...having watched that today you could, as some have... make a point about the wing backs not being wing backs.. play two out of the 3 CBs. .have a playmaker..sign a striker..etc..
but a goalkeeper ffs..we could have had 6 goalkeepers it still couldnt be any better than nil.