Thu Sep 07, 2017 12:09 pm
Thu Sep 07, 2017 1:59 pm
Thu Sep 07, 2017 4:02 pm
Jock wrote:Can Rangers sign him on a pre contract in January?
Thu Sep 07, 2017 4:28 pm
wez1927 wrote:Jock wrote:Can Rangers sign him on a pre contract in January?
Yes they will owe us compo tho any club that signs him will have to
Thu Sep 07, 2017 5:01 pm
Thu Sep 07, 2017 6:32 pm
maccydee wrote:wez1927 wrote:Jock wrote:Can Rangers sign him on a pre contract in January?
Yes they will owe us compo tho any club that signs him will have to
Celtic didn't for Ledley so not sure they will have to.
Thu Sep 07, 2017 6:34 pm
Thu Sep 07, 2017 8:36 pm
Sven wrote:maccydee wrote:wez1927 wrote:Jock wrote:Can Rangers sign him on a pre contract in January?
Yes they will owe us compo tho any club that signs him will have to
Celtic didn't for Ledley so not sure they will have to.
Initially, I wasn't sure if the Joe Ledley 'thing' was that he signed for Celtic on a specific date to avoid that payment being due but a little research appears to show that the 'Training Compensation' agreement is between Premier League and EFL clubs only
That's not to say Joe didn't 'engineer' his move to avoid any kind of compensation being paid in order maximise his own earning potential but by signing for Celtic at any time (even a pre-nuptual) wouldn't have seen City get a penny from them
This is what it says (in part):
"Where a professional player, under the age of 24, has been offered a new contract by his club (subject to certain requirements that the offer must meet set out in Rule 64.3 of the Football League Rules) and he rejects that offer in order to take up the opportunity to sign for another club, compensation will be payable."
"In the majority of cases, clubs will reach mutual agreement on a compensation fee. However, in others the two clubs’ valuations will differ, sometimes significantly, and the matter will need to be settled through an arbitration process."
"That process is operated by the Professional Football Compensation Committee (PFCC). The PFCC is incorporated under the rules of both The Football League and Premier League, and forms part of the collective bargaining agreement with the Professional Footballers’ Association. The PFCC comprises of an independent Chairman, appointees from The Football League and Premier League (as appropriate), an appointee of The Professional Footballers’ Association and an appointee of the League Managers’ Association."
http://fullcontactlaw.co.uk/2016/11/com ... 4-mystery/
Sat Sep 09, 2017 9:28 am
Tony Blue Williams wrote:Sven wrote:maccydee wrote:wez1927 wrote:Jock wrote:Can Rangers sign him on a pre contract in January?
Yes they will owe us compo tho any club that signs him will have to
Celtic didn't for Ledley so not sure they will have to.
Initially, I wasn't sure if the Joe Ledley 'thing' was that he signed for Celtic on a specific date to avoid that payment being due but a little research appears to show that the 'Training Compensation' agreement is between Premier League and EFL clubs only
That's not to say Joe didn't 'engineer' his move to avoid any kind of compensation being paid in order maximise his own earning potential but by signing for Celtic at any time (even a pre-nuptual) wouldn't have seen City get a penny from them
This is what it says (in part):
"Where a professional player, under the age of 24, has been offered a new contract by his club (subject to certain requirements that the offer must meet set out in Rule 64.3 of the Football League Rules) and he rejects that offer in order to take up the opportunity to sign for another club, compensation will be payable."
"In the majority of cases, clubs will reach mutual agreement on a compensation fee. However, in others the two clubs’ valuations will differ, sometimes significantly, and the matter will need to be settled through an arbitration process."
"That process is operated by the Professional Football Compensation Committee (PFCC). The PFCC is incorporated under the rules of both The Football League and Premier League, and forms part of the collective bargaining agreement with the Professional Footballers’ Association. The PFCC comprises of an independent Chairman, appointees from The Football League and Premier League (as appropriate), an appointee of The Professional Footballers’ Association and an appointee of the League Managers’ Association."
http://fullcontactlaw.co.uk/2016/11/com ... 4-mystery/
Joe's contract was up and he was free to move employers like anyone else would be. He didn't owe City anything and it is nonsense to even suggest he was remotely 'engineering' a move. If you want examples of that then try Diego Costa, Philippe Coutinho or Virgil van Dijk who are all under contract but believe they have the right to a transfer when they choose.