Sun Mar 05, 2017 5:10 pm
Sun Mar 05, 2017 8:45 pm
Sun Mar 05, 2017 9:22 pm
since64 wrote:Problem is you have a club far to big for the league they are in
Sun Mar 05, 2017 9:52 pm
Sun Mar 05, 2017 10:16 pm
Mon Mar 06, 2017 11:50 am
since64 wrote:No of course not ,but they should not have been allowed in that league in the first place,
Mon Mar 06, 2017 12:00 pm
pembroke allan wrote:since64 wrote:No of course not ,but they should not have been allowed in that league in the first place,
What league should they have been in? As far as aware there is set criteria where liquidated clubs restart from Must asume they are in correct one! maybe fault lies with police and clubs not liasing about size of away fans?
Mon Mar 06, 2017 12:54 pm
Sven wrote:pembroke allan wrote:since64 wrote:No of course not ,but they should not have been allowed in that league in the first place,
What league should they have been in? As far as aware there is set criteria where liquidated clubs restart from Must asume they are in correct one! maybe fault lies with police and clubs not liasing about size of away fans?
Allan, I think you are dealing with one of those characters that can't see the wood for the trees here!![]()
![]()
Like others, I always enjoyed a trip to Edgar Street and still smile with the memories whenever I drive past the place, but Hereford are where they are for a multitude of reasons and for someone to say "they should not have been allowed in that League in the first place" is to misunderstand their actual position as it stands, i.e. not in a good place!
Others (Newport County, Wrexham and Shrewsbury are all good examples of teams that were once decent. All have been in the 2nd Division (now Championship) of the Football League and all have fallen somewhat sort of what is required in 'modern' football
Sad but nonetheless true!![]()
Mon Mar 06, 2017 1:16 pm
pembroke allan wrote:Sven wrote:pembroke allan wrote:since64 wrote:No of course not ,but they should not have been allowed in that league in the first place,
What league should they have been in? As far as aware there is set criteria where liquidated clubs restart from Must asume they are in correct one! maybe fault lies with police and clubs not liasing about size of away fans?
Allan, I think you are dealing with one of those characters that can't see the wood for the trees here!![]()
![]()
Like others, I always enjoyed a trip to Edgar Street and still smile with the memories whenever I drive past the place, but Hereford are where they are for a multitude of reasons and for someone to say "they should not have been allowed in that League in the first place" is to misunderstand their actual position as it stands, i.e. not in a good place!
Others (Newport County, Wrexham and Shrewsbury are all good examples of teams that were once decent. All have been in the 2nd Division (now Championship) of the Football League and all have fallen somewhat sort of what is required in 'modern' football
Sad but nonetheless true!![]()
Sven take look at bottom of national league? Was 3 X league clubs there last week! It appears the devide between semi professional and professional teams is not there anymore.
Mon Mar 06, 2017 3:38 pm
pembroke allan wrote:since64 wrote:No of course not ,but they should not have been allowed in that league in the first place,
What league should they have been in? As far as aware there is set criteria where liquidated clubs restart from Must asume they are in correct one! maybe fault lies with police and clubs not liasing about size of away fans?
Mon Mar 06, 2017 4:16 pm
since64 wrote:pembroke allan wrote:since64 wrote:No of course not ,but they should not have been allowed in that league in the first place,
What league should they have been in? As far as aware there is set criteria where liquidated clubs restart from Must asume they are in correct one! maybe fault lies with police and clubs not liasing about size of away fans?
Yes of course Didcot and the police are to blame they should have had some idea on the travelling support from other games Hereford have played this season after all they have probably taken bigger away numbers than the City this season but to get a crowd of 800 when Didcot average home attendance is 134 is unusual but nevertheless no excuse.
Mon Mar 06, 2017 4:40 pm
Mon Mar 06, 2017 4:42 pm
since64 wrote:And that's my point,they are playing teams that are not set up for that sort of away following,in two seasons time if Merthyr stay in the Premier league southern they will meet Hereford but at least there can be some segregation at Penydarren park,but there will still be problems at other grounds at that level ,and when you think that the best supported team in the prem only averages just over 600 you can see how big Hereford are at this level averaging 2700 per home game in a league two divisions lower,it's one thing for the football authorities to punish Hereford but they don't half create problems for the teams in the same league as them.So as l,said they should never have been placed in such a low point in the pyramid as one day they will almost certainly return to the football league or if not to the Conference but that is an impossible target for the teams they will play in the next few seasons and l include Merthyr in that.hope I've cleared away some of the wood for you![]()
Mon Mar 06, 2017 4:54 pm
since64 wrote:And that's my point,they are playing teams that are not set up for that sort of away following,in two seasons time if Merthyr stay in the Premier league southern they will meet Hereford but at least there can be some segregation at Penydarren park,but there will still be problems at other grounds at that level ,and when you think that the best supported team in the prem only averages just over 600 you can see how big Hereford are at this level averaging 2700 per home game in a league two divisions lower,it's one thing for the football authorities to punish Hereford but they don't half create problems for the teams in the same league as them.So as l,said they should never have been placed in such a low point in the pyramid as one day they will almost certainly return to the football league or if not to the Conference but that is an impossible target for the teams they will play in the next few seasons and l include Merthyr in that.hope I've cleared away some of the wood for you![]()
Mon Mar 06, 2017 5:53 pm
Mon Mar 06, 2017 8:05 pm
since64 wrote:I don't believe there are any hard or fast rules in these cases,l would like to know myself to be honest,but my question is who decided that the Midland league ,the ninth tier in the league pyramid system was punishment enough what criteria was used,when a club who were averaging 2,000 crowds were going up against teams averaging crowds of between 20 and 50 why not make them play in the local Hereford and district playing park football.
Tue Mar 07, 2017 5:10 pm
since64 wrote:And that's my point,they are playing teams that are not set up for that sort of away following,in two seasons time if Merthyr stay in the Premier league southern they will meet Hereford but at least there can be some segregation at Penydarren park,but there will still be problems at other grounds at that level ,and when you think that the best supported team in the prem only averages just over 600 you can see how big Hereford are at this level averaging 2700 per home game in a league two divisions lower,it's one thing for the football authorities to punish Hereford but they don't half create problems for the teams in the same league as them.So as l,said they should never have been placed in such a low point in the pyramid as one day they will almost certainly return to the football league or if not to the Conference but that is an impossible target for the teams they will play in the next few seasons and l include Merthyr in that.hope I've cleared away some of the wood for you![]()
Tue Mar 07, 2017 5:40 pm
dogfound wrote:since64 wrote:And that's my point,they are playing teams that are not set up for that sort of away following,in two seasons time if Merthyr stay in the Premier league southern they will meet Hereford but at least there can be some segregation at Penydarren park,but there will still be problems at other grounds at that level ,and when you think that the best supported team in the prem only averages just over 600 you can see how big Hereford are at this level averaging 2700 per home game in a league two divisions lower,it's one thing for the football authorities to punish Hereford but they don't half create problems for the teams in the same league as them.So as l,said they should never have been placed in such a low point in the pyramid as one day they will almost certainly return to the football league or if not to the Conference but that is an impossible target for the teams they will play in the next few seasons and l include Merthyr in that.hope I've cleared away some of the wood for you![]()
i think most people understood your point in the original post.its really very simple.
ive thought in the past when its been mentioned how impractical it would be for ourselves and Swansea to be in the LOW for similar reasons.
Tue Mar 07, 2017 6:29 pm
pembroke allan wrote:dogfound wrote:since64 wrote:And that's my point,they are playing teams that are not set up for that sort of away following,in two seasons time if Merthyr stay in the Premier league southern they will meet Hereford but at least there can be some segregation at Penydarren park,but there will still be problems at other grounds at that level ,and when you think that the best supported team in the prem only averages just over 600 you can see how big Hereford are at this level averaging 2700 per home game in a league two divisions lower,it's one thing for the football authorities to punish Hereford but they don't half create problems for the teams in the same league as them.So as l,said they should never have been placed in such a low point in the pyramid as one day they will almost certainly return to the football league or if not to the Conference but that is an impossible target for the teams they will play in the next few seasons and l include Merthyr in that.hope I've cleared away some of the wood for you![]()
i think most people understood your point in the original post.its really very simple.
ive thought in the past when its been mentioned how impractical it would be for ourselves and Swansea to be in the LOW for similar reasons.
So what happens for arguement sake if say sheff wed was to be relegated to national league? Would they stay up because clubs couldn't cater for large away crowds?? Basic point being size of club cannot dictate what league club play in !
Tue Mar 07, 2017 6:37 pm
dogfound wrote:pembroke allan wrote:dogfound wrote:since64 wrote:And that's my point,they are playing teams that are not set up for that sort of away following,in two seasons time if Merthyr stay in the Premier league southern they will meet Hereford but at least there can be some segregation at Penydarren park,but there will still be problems at other grounds at that level ,and when you think that the best supported team in the prem only averages just over 600 you can see how big Hereford are at this level averaging 2700 per home game in a league two divisions lower,it's one thing for the football authorities to punish Hereford but they don't half create problems for the teams in the same league as them.So as l,said they should never have been placed in such a low point in the pyramid as one day they will almost certainly return to the football league or if not to the Conference but that is an impossible target for the teams they will play in the next few seasons and l include Merthyr in that.hope I've cleared away some of the wood for you![]()
i think most people understood your point in the original post.its really very simple.
ive thought in the past when its been mentioned how impractical it would be for ourselves and Swansea to be in the LOW for similar reasons.
So what happens for arguement sake if say sheff wed was to be relegated to national league? Would they stay up because clubs couldn't cater for large away crowds?? Basic point being size of club cannot dictate what league club play in !
according to you there is a set criteria so they would be in the same division as Didcot and Hereford.???
but yes of course each should be looked at from all points.
is this really the lowest point Hereford could have been placed.? no it isnt. Herefordshire div 5 is. so somebody somewhere made a decision based on something that was other than start from scratch.
Tue Mar 07, 2017 6:44 pm
pembroke allan wrote:dogfound wrote:since64 wrote:And that's my point,they are playing teams that are not set up for that sort of away following,in two seasons time if Merthyr stay in the Premier league southern they will meet Hereford but at least there can be some segregation at Penydarren park,but there will still be problems at other grounds at that level ,and when you think that the best supported team in the prem only averages just over 600 you can see how big Hereford are at this level averaging 2700 per home game in a league two divisions lower,it's one thing for the football authorities to punish Hereford but they don't half create problems for the teams in the same league as them.So as l,said they should never have been placed in such a low point in the pyramid as one day they will almost certainly return to the football league or if not to the Conference but that is an impossible target for the teams they will play in the next few seasons and l include Merthyr in that.hope I've cleared away some of the wood for you![]()
i think most people understood your point in the original post.its really very simple.
ive thought in the past when its been mentioned how impractical it would be for ourselves and Swansea to be in the LOW for similar reasons.
So what happens for arguement sake if say sheff wed was to be relegated to national league? Would they stay up because clubs couldn't cater for large away crowds?? Basic point being size of club cannot dictate what league club play in !
Tue Mar 07, 2017 6:46 pm
pembroke allan wrote:dogfound wrote:pembroke allan wrote:dogfound wrote:since64 wrote:And that's my point,they are playing teams that are not set up for that sort of away following,in two seasons time if Merthyr stay in the Premier league southern they will meet Hereford but at least there can be some segregation at Penydarren park,but there will still be problems at other grounds at that level ,and when you think that the best supported team in the prem only averages just over 600 you can see how big Hereford are at this level averaging 2700 per home game in a league two divisions lower,it's one thing for the football authorities to punish Hereford but they don't half create problems for the teams in the same league as them.So as l,said they should never have been placed in such a low point in the pyramid as one day they will almost certainly return to the football league or if not to the Conference but that is an impossible target for the teams they will play in the next few seasons and l include Merthyr in that.hope I've cleared away some of the wood for you![]()
i think most people understood your point in the original post.its really very simple.
ive thought in the past when its been mentioned how impractical it would be for ourselves and Swansea to be in the LOW for similar reasons.
So what happens for arguement sake if say sheff wed was to be relegated to national league? Would they stay up because clubs couldn't cater for large away crowds?? Basic point being size of club cannot dictate what league club play in !
according to you there is a set criteria so they would be in the same division as Didcot and Hereford.???
but yes of course each should be looked at from all points.
is this really the lowest point Hereford could have been placed.? no it isnt. Herefordshire div 5 is. so somebody somewhere made a decision based on something that was other than start from scratch.
Did say was a committee who decided also! But getting back to my last point,the argument is said Hereford shouldn't have been put in that particular league as to big? So if sheff wed got relegated to national league they wouldn't be relegated because club to big? There's me thinking relegation was open to all clubs !
Tue Mar 07, 2017 7:14 pm
dogfound wrote:pembroke allan wrote:dogfound wrote:pembroke allan wrote:dogfound wrote:since64 wrote:And that's my point,they are playing teams that are not set up for that sort of away following,in two seasons time if Merthyr stay in the Premier league southern they will meet Hereford but at least there can be some segregation at Penydarren park,but there will still be problems at other grounds at that level ,and when you think that the best supported team in the prem only averages just over 600 you can see how big Hereford are at this level averaging 2700 per home game in a league two divisions lower,it's one thing for the football authorities to punish Hereford but they don't half create problems for the teams in the same league as them.So as l,said they should never have been placed in such a low point in the pyramid as one day they will almost certainly return to the football league or if not to the Conference but that is an impossible target for the teams they will play in the next few seasons and l include Merthyr in that.hope I've cleared away some of the wood for you![]()
i think most people understood your point in the original post.its really very simple.
ive thought in the past when its been mentioned how impractical it would be for ourselves and Swansea to be in the LOW for similar reasons.
So what happens for arguement sake if say sheff wed was to be relegated to national league? Would they stay up because clubs couldn't cater for large away crowds?? Basic point being size of club cannot dictate what league club play in !
according to you there is a set criteria so they would be in the same division as Didcot and Hereford.???
but yes of course each should be looked at from all points.
is this really the lowest point Hereford could have been placed.? no it isnt. Herefordshire div 5 is. so somebody somewhere made a decision based on something that was other than start from scratch.
Did say was a committee who decided also! But getting back to my last point,the argument is said Hereford shouldn't have been put in that particular league as to big? So if sheff wed got relegated to national league they wouldn't be relegated because club to big? There's me thinking relegation was open to all clubs !
its NOT relegation though![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Tue Mar 07, 2017 7:50 pm
Tue Mar 07, 2017 8:36 pm
murphy wrote:If clubs like Didcot can't cope with 800 fans there then maybe they should make the games all ticket of about 400.
Tue Mar 07, 2017 8:54 pm
pembroke allan wrote:dogfound wrote:pembroke allan wrote:dogfound wrote:pembroke allan wrote:dogfound wrote:since64 wrote:And that's my point,they are playing teams that are not set up for that sort of away following,in two seasons time if Merthyr stay in the Premier league southern they will meet Hereford but at least there can be some segregation at Penydarren park,but there will still be problems at other grounds at that level ,and when you think that the best supported team in the prem only averages just over 600 you can see how big Hereford are at this level averaging 2700 per home game in a league two divisions lower,it's one thing for the football authorities to punish Hereford but they don't half create problems for the teams in the same league as them.So as l,said they should never have been placed in such a low point in the pyramid as one day they will almost certainly return to the football league or if not to the Conference but that is an impossible target for the teams they will play in the next few seasons and l include Merthyr in that.hope I've cleared away some of the wood for you![]()
i think most people understood your point in the original post.its really very simple.
ive thought in the past when its been mentioned how impractical it would be for ourselves and Swansea to be in the LOW for similar reasons.
So what happens for arguement sake if say sheff wed was to be relegated to national league? Would they stay up because clubs couldn't cater for large away crowds?? Basic point being size of club cannot dictate what league club play in !
according to you there is a set criteria so they would be in the same division as Didcot and Hereford.???
but yes of course each should be looked at from all points.
is this really the lowest point Hereford could have been placed.? no it isnt. Herefordshire div 5 is. so somebody somewhere made a decision based on something that was other than start from scratch.
Did say was a committee who decided also! But getting back to my last point,the argument is said Hereford shouldn't have been put in that particular league as to big? So if sheff wed got relegated to national league they wouldn't be relegated because club to big? There's me thinking relegation was open to all clubs !
its NOT relegation though![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()