' Cardiff City Need an Experienced New Keeper Says '

Nathan Blake: "Cardiff City's need for an experienced goalkeeper."

Not good enough,Ben Amos?

Opinions Please

You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

I'm not sure he's done much wrong so far, he's no Marshall or Heaton but he's no Simon Moore or Ben Wilson either !!

Not being helped by a certain CB at the moment !!

I'm not sure he's done much wrong so far, he's no Marshall or Heaton but he's no Simon Moore or Ben Wilson either !!

Not being helped by a certain CB at the moment !!

Correct,thats how I see it.
Amos,not the best keeper,but not the worst and of course not David Marshall.

Amos has saved us a number of times and has done very little wrong would say it's time for a new centre half and captain personally.

Amos has saved us a number of times and has done very little wrong would say it's time for a new centre half and captain personally.

Morrison was crap at villa

Don't agree, Amos is doing ok.
Players in front of him need to keep their concentration .

I'm not sure he's done much wrong so far, he's no Marshall or Heaton but he's no Simon Moore or Ben Wilson either !!

Not being helped by a certain CB at the moment !!

Correct,thats how I see it.
Amos,not the best keeper,but not the worst and of course not David Marshall.

David Marshall ain the same David Marshall we had anyway gone way downhill

And no Amos isn't good enuff for this league, we need to b lookin at some one like al habsi calibre atleast

Amos is a league 1 keeper at best, nowhere near the standard of a championship side, his positioning and direction in particular are poor.

Warnock needs to address this in Jan.

Amos is a league 1 keeper at best, nowhere near the standard of a championship side, his positioning and direction in particular are poor.

Warnock needs to address this in Jan.

I made near those comments when Trollope signed him,Bolton fans said the same,I got shot down.

Emyr Huws and Jazz Richards another two,waste of money in my opinion.

I agree Annis, I haven't seen anything from the 3 of the above that show me they warrant a place in a championship side.

I really liked Scott Malone and was gutted when he left, same goes for Marshy, he's the best shot stopper outside of the prem and to sell him for peanuts is nuts considering how settled he was with his family down here, unfortunately that's the modern footballing world.

Long term we need to try and find an established GK, some one like Robert Green type.

I agree Annis, I haven't seen anything from the 3 of the above that show me they warrant a place in a championship side.

I really liked Scott Malone and was gutted when he left, same goes for Marshy, he's the best shot stopper outside of the prem and to sell him for peanuts is nuts considering how settled he was with his family down here, unfortunately that's the modern footballing world.

Long term we need to try and find an established GK, some one like Robert Green type.

We caused our own down fall employing managers like Ole,Slade and Trollope and we are paying for it now.

Thankfully we now have Neil Warnock,but us fans have to be very patient

I agree Annis, I haven't seen anything from the 3 of the above that show me they warrant a place in a championship side.

I really liked Scott Malone and was gutted when he left, same goes for Marshy, he's the best shot stopper outside of the prem and to sell him for peanuts is nuts considering how settled he was with his family down here, unfortunately that's the modern footballing world.

Long term we need to try and find an established GK, some one like Robert Green type.

We caused our own down fall employing managers like Ole,Slade and Trollope and we are paying for it now.

Thankfully we now have Neil Warnock,but us fans have to be very patient

Exactly and you've always been honest upfront and passionate about City, more than any fan.

We have the best manager outside of the premier league, i'm confident in our future under Warnock as long as he's given funds to invest wisely

I agree Annis, I haven't seen anything from the 3 of the above that show me they warrant a place in a championship side.

I really liked Scott Malone and was gutted when he left, same goes for Marshy, he's the best shot stopper outside of the prem and to sell him for peanuts is nuts considering how settled he was with his family down here, unfortunately that's the modern footballing world.

Long term we need to try and find an established GK, some one like Robert Green type.

We caused our own down fall employing managers like Ole,Slade and Trollope and we are paying for it now.

Thankfully we now have Neil Warnock,but us fans have to be very patient

Exactly and you've always been honest upfront and passionate about City, more than any fan.

We have the best manager outside of the premier league, i'm confident in our future under Warnock as long as he's given funds to invest wisely

The club needs to fully back a proven and trusted manager who can and will deliver for us

WE ALL NEED TO 100% FULLY BACK HIM

I've been waiting since 1975 for city to have genuine success.I'm used to waiting.

I AGREE WITH NATHAN

One thing to consider; is replcing Amos a priority ?

He is steady and I've seen a lot worse keepers. If we had loads of money to spend then I might agree that we need a more experienced keeper but given that most would agree we need a striker, wideman and centre back is it really a necessity to get a new keeper.

If we were to go for a new experienced keeper then he would either command a big transfer fee, big wages or both !! I don't think we've got money to burn and therefore we need to prioritise, Warnock knows best but I would be surprised if a keeper was top of his list or even close.

I'm not sure he's done much wrong so far, he's no Marshall or Heaton but he's no Simon Moore or Ben Wilson either !!

Not being helped by a certain CB at the moment !!

Correct,thats how I see it.
Amos,not the best keeper,but not the worst and of course not David Marshall.

Agree