Sun Nov 06, 2016 11:41 am
Sun Nov 06, 2016 11:53 am
Sun Nov 06, 2016 3:46 pm
Sun Nov 06, 2016 4:50 pm
Sun Nov 06, 2016 7:32 pm
The Fish wrote:Geordie in peace,
I don't think what Rafa said was a complaint. I think it was just an assessment, Mitrovic had a tough game because of the size and physicality of your centrebacks, he still had a good game and he'll benefit from facing a variety of challenges from the opposition defence.
The standard of refereeing in this league is shocking, mind. Brentford could/should have had a penalty in their last game against us, Brighton should have faced a penalty yesterday, and your consolation came after a handball. And those are just the recent examples, all season Newcastle fans have been baffled at the terrible standard of officiating. Not just the big decisions, but stupid stuff like where a throw-in should be taken from, what's a foul throw, if it's a goal kick or a corner.
Sun Nov 06, 2016 8:50 pm
The Fish wrote:Geordie in peace,
I don't think what Rafa said was a complaint. I think it was just an assessment, Mitrovic had a tough game because of the size and physicality of your centrebacks, he still had a good game and he'll benefit from facing a variety of challenges from the opposition defence.
The standard of refereeing in this league is shocking, mind. Brentford could/should have had a penalty in their last game against us, Brighton should have faced a penalty yesterday, and your consolation came after a handball. And those are just the recent examples, all season Newcastle fans have been baffled at the terrible standard of officiating. Not just the big decisions, but stupid stuff like where a throw-in should be taken from, what's a foul throw, if it's a goal kick or a corner.
Sun Nov 06, 2016 8:52 pm
The Fish wrote:Geordie in peace,
I don't think what Rafa said was a complaint. I think it was just an assessment, Mitrovic had a tough game because of the size and physicality of your centrebacks, he still had a good game and he'll benefit from facing a variety of challenges from the opposition defence.
The standard of refereeing in this league is shocking, mind. Brentford could/should have had a penalty in their last game against us, Brighton should have faced a penalty yesterday, and your consolation came after a handball. And those are just the recent examples, all season Newcastle fans have been baffled at the terrible standard of officiating. Not just the big decisions, but stupid stuff like where a throw-in should be taken from, what's a foul throw, if it's a goal kick or a corner.
Mon Nov 07, 2016 9:29 am
davids wrote:Greetings Mr The Fish,
You are very welcome and congratulations on your win yesterday - welcome to the world of appalling officiating known as the Championship. It's terrible week in week out I'm afraid and when you think of the possible consequences of poor decisions when the difference between getting promoted or not can rest on such small margins it's positively scary!
Your manager was moaning about the "physical" side of our gameAs mentioned in my post we got nowhere near your players in the first half yesterday and it's a source of frustration to some of our fans that we rarely put pressure on the opposition when they have possession, allowing them to proceed virtually unchallenged until they reach our box - for both of your goals yesterday not one meaningful attempt was made to tackle your players before the ball hit the net!
So we were delighted when during the second half we started at last to put your talented team under a bit if pressure. Did Benitez honestly think that we were just going to stand there watching your players have fun all game? We've tried the "possession" game and the patient build up and the playing it on the floor method under our previous manager and look at where that's got us!
From my vantage point halfway to the moon in the away end, I could see nothing wrong with our "aggressive" approach which began to pose some questions of your team and upset your Champions League winning manager. He has to realise that the Championship is different to the Premier League and that dealing with what he believes to be "aggressive" play is something he has to deal with. Any team managed by our current manager isn't just going to lie down to have it's tummy tickled whilst being over-run.
You had enough chances yesterday particularly in the first half to have buried us - we had enough chances in the second half to put you at risk of drawing or even losing the game.
You'll be going up this season and you'll deserve it - you have by far the best squad in this division (thank god Gayle stayed on the bench yesterday!), you have an amazing level of support, you have the ability to spend tens of millions of pounds in January if your manager feels he needs to and yet he moans about an "aggressive" approach from a team that is currently scrapping for every point to try to get away from their current precarious position.
Good luck for the rest of the season (except the return in Cardiff of course) and enjoy a season where you'll win far more than you lose for a change. Rafa's real challenge will be when you get back to the Premier League next season.
ps - I don't think our goal was a "consolation". A consolation is a goal when you are completely out of the game. We were right back in the game when we scored and could well have nicked a point late on.
Mon Nov 07, 2016 9:34 am
Lawnmower wrote:
Didn't notice it at the time, but apparently Chamack played it with the top of his shoulder, which is not handball.

Mon Nov 07, 2016 10:18 am
The Fish wrote:Lawnmower wrote:
Didn't notice it at the time, but apparently Chamack played it with the top of his shoulder, which is not handball.
Doesn't look like his shoulder to me, looks like he's controlling it with his arm.
Mon Nov 07, 2016 10:27 am
KBK-13 wrote:
He's got massive shoulders. The ref was poor for both teams, no mention of the challenge on Morrison, or the small decisions like corners. We should of had 1 at our end but by the reaction of your crowd we shouldn't have when Hoilett tried to play the ball off a defender and we were given a corner, hard to see when your sat on the moon.