Earnshaw or Ledley.

Both local boys who started their careers at Cardiff at a young age.

Earnshaw for me all day long.

Both local boys who started their careers at Cardiff at a young age.

Earnshaw for me all day long.

no competetion...........earnie all day long for me too

Easy call, Earnie

is this a serious question
earnie, no hesitations

is this a serious question
earnie, no hesitations

hi im fish

is this a serious question
earnie, no hesitations

Hi I'm Claire I like the user name!

is this a serious question
earnie, no hesitations

Hi I'm Claire I like the user name!

beat you too it

is this a serious question
earnie, no hesitations

hi im fish

i dont know whether its tiredness, but i am still laughing at that sarcy comment by fish

is this a serious question
earnie, no hesitations

hi im fish

i dont know whether its tiredness, but i am still laughing at that sarcy comment by fish

is this a serious question
earnie, no hesitations

Hi I'm Claire I like the user name!

beat you too it

But I wrote more than you

Both local boys who started their careers at Cardiff at a young age.

Earnshaw for me all day long.

Gotta be Earnie for me too

Joe Ledley has just come on at half-time in Celtic's friendly

Both local boys who started their careers at Cardiff at a young age.

Earnshaw for me all day long.

Gotta be Earnie for me too

Joe Ledley has just come on at half-time in Celtic's friendly

ABS
Anyone but septic

I also believe Earnshaw is a Cardiff fan, where as Ledley is a Cardiff lad.

Don't you lot have a bed to go to?

cant compare the two of em as completely different players, different position etc...

like em both but due to personal reasons I'd prefer Ledley

Earnie by a mile, from Zambia but still so much more of City boy

Look at my nick that should give you my answer

I know we class him as a Cardiff lad, but hes actually from Zambia and lived in Caerphilly, so he isnt really a Cardiff lad. Whereas Joe is, born a few miles from the stadium.

As a striker, I'd take Earnie over Ledley every time. But ask Earnie to play midfield, I'd have to say he wouldn't do a better job than Joe. And that's where the problem of comparing them really starts.

Earnie, though, is probably my favourite ever City player

my fav ever is Kav, followed by Leggy...legends

btw i remember Kav getting sh1t from some of our "fans" who called him Judas etc...

cos our former chairman sold him for next to nothing to Wigan...

phil stant for me great guy

EARNSHAW is still a legend and will always be............

phil stant for me great guy

With a moniker like earnieblue?

I have had the pleasure of meeting Earnshaw and he is gentleman. I met him after a home game against Forest and despite his team being beaten he was was very positive towards Swansea and had only good things to say about us. I asked him if he ever considered signing for the jacks. he said he would get lynched if he did but footballl is a funny game and you can never say never.
He gets my respect totally unlike Ledley.

I have had the pleasure of meeting Earnshaw and he is gentleman. I met him after a home game against Forest and despite his team being beaten he was was very positive towards Swansea and had only good things to say about us. I asked him if he ever considered signing for the jacks. he said he would get lynched if he did but footballl is a funny game and you can never say never.
He gets my respect totally unlike Ledley.

he was just being polite.

really he has f**k all good to say about you