Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Sun Jun 05, 2016 9:43 am

The BBC has warned English football fans not to dress as crusaders when attending the Euro 2016 tournament this summer as they might cause offence to Muslims.

BBC


By DONNA RACHEL EDMUNDS

Saturday 4th June 2016


The advice comes via their ‘iWonder’ website, aimed at a younger audience, which asks such pressing questions as “Was Shakespeare a feminist?” and “How green is my commute?”

Posing the question: “Is it wrong to dress as a crusader for an England match?” the answer appears to be a resounding “yes”.

“Crusaders were the perpetrators of violent attacks across Europe and the Middle East on Muslims, Jews and pagans,” the website intones, suggesting that fans may simply want to don the English flag instead, as “this has nothing to do with crusaders or what they stood for”.

And although it can’t help musing: “The English flag used to have connotations with far-right nationalism,” it is forced to concede that: “Today the flag is flown by local authorities and individuals in a purely patriotic sense.”

Digging deeper into the history of the crusades, the website depicts crusaders as “wading ankle deep in blood, killing civilians and resorting to cannibalism,” although it admits that accounts of such actions “may have [been] exaggerated,” while a source is cited describing the leader of the Muslim forces, Nur ed-Din as “a just prince, valiant and wise, and according to the traditions of his race, a religious man”.

Breezing past the fact that the Christian Holy Roman Empire was “losing territory to Muslim Turks in the East,” the website recounts the history of the crusades in terms depicting the Christian forces as the equivalent of today’s Islamic State: religion-crazed extremists who ravaged the Middle East in an attempt to win favour in heaven.

The English king Richard the First, we are told, slayed his captives while his forces “massacred” the people of Constantinople and plundered the city.

The website then goes on to ask three members of the public whether they would dress up as a crusader at a football match. One would as “the costumes are very over-the-top and clearly in the realms of fancy dress,” but the others wouldn’t.

David from Hounslow said: “If I know that something offends others but I am involved with them in a joint activity then it is probably a good idea to moderate or stop what is giving offence. The potent symbolism of the crusader outfit takes the issue beyond the world of just a bit of fun.”

And Amin from London chips in: “I have some reservations due to the bloody history of the crusades. Yes, it’s a part of history, but we need to move on. Conquest and pillage in the name of Christianity isn’t exactly a positive reminder of our history and not something we should really be celebrating.”

A spokesman for the BBC insisted that the iWonder website doesn’t take a view on any topic. “iWonder guides are not the BBC passing judgement, they cover a huge range of topics and are designed to ask questions which encourage debate. In this instance, the users were given the opportunity to express their own views by voting on the topic,” he told The Times.

But the Council for the Advancement of Arab-British Understanding (Caabu) has suggested that fans take heed of the BBC’s warning and leave the crusader costumes behind when travelling to France for the tournament this summer.

Chris Doyle, director of Caabu, said the word “crusade” has powerful negative connotations in the Arab world, which could potentially open fans up to being targeted by extremists.

“I would hope Muslims do not take offence but there may well be people who do. They may present themselves as more of a target to any extremist,” he said.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Sun Jun 05, 2016 11:42 am

Forever Blue wrote:The BBC has warned English football fans not to dress as crusaders when attending the Euro 2016 tournament this summer as they might cause offence to Muslims.

BBC


By DONNA RACHEL EDMUNDS

Saturday 4th June 2016


The advice comes via their ‘iWonder’ website, aimed at a younger audience, which asks such pressing questions as “Was Shakespeare a feminist?” and “How green is my commute?”

Posing the question: “Is it wrong to dress as a crusader for an England match?” the answer appears to be a resounding “yes”.

“Crusaders were the perpetrators of violent attacks across Europe and the Middle East on Muslims, Jews and pagans,” the website intones, suggesting that fans may simply want to don the English flag instead, as “this has nothing to do with crusaders or what they stood for”.

And although it can’t help musing: “The English flag used to have connotations with far-right nationalism,” it is forced to concede that: “Today the flag is flown by local authorities and individuals in a purely patriotic sense.”

Digging deeper into the history of the crusades, the website depicts crusaders as “wading ankle deep in blood, killing civilians and resorting to cannibalism,” although it admits that accounts of such actions “may have [been] exaggerated,” while a source is cited describing the leader of the Muslim forces, Nur ed-Din as “a just prince, valiant and wise, and according to the traditions of his race, a religious man”.

Breezing past the fact that the Christian Holy Roman Empire was “losing territory to Muslim Turks in the East,” the website recounts the history of the crusades in terms depicting the Christian forces as the equivalent of today’s Islamic State: religion-crazed extremists who ravaged the Middle East in an attempt to win favour in heaven.

The English king Richard the First, we are told, slayed his captives while his forces “massacred” the people of Constantinople and plundered the city.

The website then goes on to ask three members of the public whether they would dress up as a crusader at a football match. One would as “the costumes are very over-the-top and clearly in the realms of fancy dress,” but the others wouldn’t.

David from Hounslow said: “If I know that something offends others but I am involved with them in a joint activity then it is probably a good idea to moderate or stop what is giving offence. The potent symbolism of the crusader outfit takes the issue beyond the world of just a bit of fun.”

And Amin from London chips in: “I have some reservations due to the bloody history of the crusades. Yes, it’s a part of history, but we need to move on. Conquest and pillage in the name of Christianity isn’t exactly a positive reminder of our history and not something we should really be celebrating.”

A spokesman for the BBC insisted that the iWonder website doesn’t take a view on any topic. “iWonder guides are not the BBC passing judgement, they cover a huge range of topics and are designed to ask questions which encourage debate. In this instance, the users were given the opportunity to express their own views by voting on the topic,” he told The Times.

But the Council for the Advancement of Arab-British Understanding (Caabu) has suggested that fans take heed of the BBC’s warning and leave the crusader costumes behind when travelling to France for the tournament this summer.

Chris Doyle, director of Caabu, said the word “crusade” has powerful negative connotations in the Arab world, which could potentially open fans up to being targeted by extremists.

“I would hope Muslims do not take offence but there may well be people who do. They may present themselves as more of a target to any extremist,” he said.

I hope English fans totally ignore this politicly correct nonsense

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Sun Jun 05, 2016 11:57 am

angelis1949 wrote:
Forever Blue wrote:The BBC has warned English football fans not to dress as crusaders when attending the Euro 2016 tournament this summer as they might cause offence to Muslims.

BBC


By DONNA RACHEL EDMUNDS

Saturday 4th June 2016


The advice comes via their ‘iWonder’ website, aimed at a younger audience, which asks such pressing questions as “Was Shakespeare a feminist?” and “How green is my commute?”

Posing the question: “Is it wrong to dress as a crusader for an England match?” the answer appears to be a resounding “yes”.

“Crusaders were the perpetrators of violent attacks across Europe and the Middle East on Muslims, Jews and pagans,” the website intones, suggesting that fans may simply want to don the English flag instead, as “this has nothing to do with crusaders or what they stood for”.

And although it can’t help musing: “The English flag used to have connotations with far-right nationalism,” it is forced to concede that: “Today the flag is flown by local authorities and individuals in a purely patriotic sense.”

Digging deeper into the history of the crusades, the website depicts crusaders as “wading ankle deep in blood, killing civilians and resorting to cannibalism,” although it admits that accounts of such actions “may have [been] exaggerated,” while a source is cited describing the leader of the Muslim forces, Nur ed-Din as “a just prince, valiant and wise, and according to the traditions of his race, a religious man”.

Breezing past the fact that the Christian Holy Roman Empire was “losing territory to Muslim Turks in the East,” the website recounts the history of the crusades in terms depicting the Christian forces as the equivalent of today’s Islamic State: religion-crazed extremists who ravaged the Middle East in an attempt to win favour in heaven.

The English king Richard the First, we are told, slayed his captives while his forces “massacred” the people of Constantinople and plundered the city.

The website then goes on to ask three members of the public whether they would dress up as a crusader at a football match. One would as “the costumes are very over-the-top and clearly in the realms of fancy dress,” but the others wouldn’t.

David from Hounslow said: “If I know that something offends others but I am involved with them in a joint activity then it is probably a good idea to moderate or stop what is giving offence. The potent symbolism of the crusader outfit takes the issue beyond the world of just a bit of fun.”

And Amin from London chips in: “I have some reservations due to the bloody history of the crusades. Yes, it’s a part of history, but we need to move on. Conquest and pillage in the name of Christianity isn’t exactly a positive reminder of our history and not something we should really be celebrating.”

A spokesman for the BBC insisted that the iWonder website doesn’t take a view on any topic. “iWonder guides are not the BBC passing judgement, they cover a huge range of topics and are designed to ask questions which encourage debate. In this instance, the users were given the opportunity to express their own views by voting on the topic,” he told The Times.

But the Council for the Advancement of Arab-British Understanding (Caabu) has suggested that fans take heed of the BBC’s warning and leave the crusader costumes behind when travelling to France for the tournament this summer.

Chris Doyle, director of Caabu, said the word “crusade” has powerful negative connotations in the Arab world, which could potentially open fans up to being targeted by extremists.

“I would hope Muslims do not take offence but there may well be people who do. They may present themselves as more of a target to any extremist,” he said.

I hope English fans totally ignore this politicly correct nonsense


I reckon they will do it even more and so they should :ayatollah:

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Sun Jun 05, 2016 1:18 pm

Forever Blue wrote:
angelis1949 wrote:
Forever Blue wrote:The BBC has warned English football fans not to dress as crusaders when attending the Euro 2016 tournament this summer as they might cause offence to Muslims.

BBC


By DONNA RACHEL EDMUNDS

Saturday 4th June 2016


The advice comes via their ‘iWonder’ website, aimed at a younger audience, which asks such pressing questions as “Was Shakespeare a feminist?” and “How green is my commute?”

Posing the question: “Is it wrong to dress as a crusader for an England match?” the answer appears to be a resounding “yes”.

“Crusaders were the perpetrators of violent attacks across Europe and the Middle East on Muslims, Jews and pagans,” the website intones, suggesting that fans may simply want to don the English flag instead, as “this has nothing to do with crusaders or what they stood for”.

And although it can’t help musing: “The English flag used to have connotations with far-right nationalism,” it is forced to concede that: “Today the flag is flown by local authorities and individuals in a purely patriotic sense.”

Digging deeper into the history of the crusades, the website depicts crusaders as “wading ankle deep in blood, killing civilians and resorting to cannibalism,” although it admits that accounts of such actions “may have [been] exaggerated,” while a source is cited describing the leader of the Muslim forces, Nur ed-Din as “a just prince, valiant and wise, and according to the traditions of his race, a religious man”.

Breezing past the fact that the Christian Holy Roman Empire was “losing territory to Muslim Turks in the East,” the website recounts the history of the crusades in terms depicting the Christian forces as the equivalent of today’s Islamic State: religion-crazed extremists who ravaged the Middle East in an attempt to win favour in heaven.

The English king Richard the First, we are told, slayed his captives while his forces “massacred” the people of Constantinople and plundered the city.

The website then goes on to ask three members of the public whether they would dress up as a crusader at a football match. One would as “the costumes are very over-the-top and clearly in the realms of fancy dress,” but the others wouldn’t.

David from Hounslow said: “If I know that something offends others but I am involved with them in a joint activity then it is probably a good idea to moderate or stop what is giving offence. The potent symbolism of the crusader outfit takes the issue beyond the world of just a bit of fun.”

And Amin from London chips in: “I have some reservations due to the bloody history of the crusades. Yes, it’s a part of history, but we need to move on. Conquest and pillage in the name of Christianity isn’t exactly a positive reminder of our history and not something we should really be celebrating.”

A spokesman for the BBC insisted that the iWonder website doesn’t take a view on any topic. “iWonder guides are not the BBC passing judgement, they cover a huge range of topics and are designed to ask questions which encourage debate. In this instance, the users were given the opportunity to express their own views by voting on the topic,” he told The Times.

But the Council for the Advancement of Arab-British Understanding (Caabu) has suggested that fans take heed of the BBC’s warning and leave the crusader costumes behind when travelling to France for the tournament this summer.

Chris Doyle, director of Caabu, said the word “crusade” has powerful negative connotations in the Arab world, which could potentially open fans up to being targeted by extremists.

“I would hope Muslims do not take offence but there may well be people who do. They may present themselves as more of a target to any extremist,” he said.

I hope English fans totally ignore this politicly correct nonsense


I reckon they will do it even more and so they should :ayatollah:




Yep, have to agree :thumbup: :ayatollah:

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Sun Jun 05, 2016 1:32 pm

Does seem a bit bull shit tbh

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Sun Jun 05, 2016 2:14 pm

I hope all English fans dress as crusaders.

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Sun Jun 05, 2016 4:39 pm

Perhaps it's time to ban the f*cking burkha then as that offends a lot of Britons.

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Sun Jun 05, 2016 4:42 pm

The BBC is supposed to be fair and accurate, it is neither. They're promotion of a PC Facism has and continues to harm this country.

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Sun Jun 05, 2016 4:50 pm

I've just written to the BBC suggesting it would be a far better idea to just simply ban Muslims. Then the rest of us can simply wear and do what we want without fear of these nutters trying to kill us for it. Happy Christmas.

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Sun Jun 05, 2016 5:05 pm

I thought the BBC stood for the British Broadcasting Corporation and was paid for by us the British Licence fee payers. Therefore I am at total loss why it seems to represent other countries and cultures more than those for paid for it!

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Sun Jun 05, 2016 7:04 pm

How stupid considering Mars advert is full of crusaders! :laughing6:

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Sun Jun 05, 2016 7:55 pm

cardiffblue74 wrote:I thought the BBC stood for the British Broadcasting Corporation and was paid for by us the British Licence fee payers. Therefore I am at total loss why it seems to represent other countries and cultures more than those for paid for it!

When the first Iraqi war was raging the BBC was known as the Baghdad Broadcast Company because of its willingness to accept all the Iraqi propergande dished out night after night

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Sun Jun 05, 2016 7:59 pm

Forever Blue wrote:The BBC has warned English football fans not to dress as crusaders when attending the Euro 2016 tournament this summer as they might cause offence to Muslims.

BBC


By DONNA RACHEL EDMUNDS

Saturday 4th June 2016


The advice comes via their ‘iWonder’ website, aimed at a younger audience, which asks such pressing questions as “Was Shakespeare a feminist?” and “How green is my commute?”

Posing the question: “Is it wrong to dress as a crusader for an England match?” the answer appears to be a resounding “yes”.

“Crusaders were the perpetrators of violent attacks across Europe and the Middle East on Muslims, Jews and pagans,” the website intones, suggesting that fans may simply want to don the English flag instead, as “this has nothing to do with crusaders or what they stood for”.

And although it can’t help musing: “The English flag used to have connotations with far-right nationalism,” it is forced to concede that: “Today the flag is flown by local authorities and individuals in a purely patriotic sense.”

Digging deeper into the history of the crusades, the website depicts crusaders as “wading ankle deep in blood, killing civilians and resorting to cannibalism,” although it admits that accounts of such actions “may have [been] exaggerated,” while a source is cited describing the leader of the Muslim forces, Nur ed-Din as “a just prince, valiant and wise, and according to the traditions of his race, a religious man”.

Breezing past the fact that the Christian Holy Roman Empire was “losing territory to Muslim Turks in the East,” the website recounts the history of the crusades in terms depicting the Christian forces as the equivalent of today’s Islamic State: religion-crazed extremists who ravaged the Middle East in an attempt to win favour in heaven.

The English king Richard the First, we are told, slayed his captives while his forces “massacred” the people of Constantinople and plundered the city.

The website then goes on to ask three members of the public whether they would dress up as a crusader at a football match. One would as “the costumes are very over-the-top and clearly in the realms of fancy dress,” but the others wouldn’t.

David from Hounslow said: “If I know that something offends others but I am involved with them in a joint activity then it is probably a good idea to moderate or stop what is giving offence. The potent symbolism of the crusader outfit takes the issue beyond the world of just a bit of fun.”

And Amin from London chips in: “I have some reservations due to the bloody history of the crusades. Yes, it’s a part of history, but we need to move on. Conquest and pillage in the name of Christianity isn’t exactly a positive reminder of our history and not something we should really be celebrating.”

A spokesman for the BBC insisted that the iWonder website doesn’t take a view on any topic. “iWonder guides are not the BBC passing judgement, they cover a huge range of topics and are designed to ask questions which encourage debate. In this instance, the users were given the opportunity to express their own views by voting on the topic,” he told The Times.

But the Council for the Advancement of Arab-British Understanding (Caabu) has suggested that fans take heed of the BBC’s warning and leave the crusader costumes behind when travelling to France for the tournament this summer.

Chris Doyle, director of Caabu, said the word “crusade” has powerful negative connotations in the Arab world, which could potentially open fans up to being targeted by extremists.

“I would hope Muslims do not take offence but there may well be people who do. They may present themselves as more of a target to any extremist,” he said.

Ffs why don't the Muslim s and bbc funk off

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Sun Jun 05, 2016 8:01 pm

GrangeEndStar wrote:I've just written to the BBC suggesting it would be a far better idea to just simply ban Muslims. Then the rest of us can simply wear and do what we want without fear of these nutters trying to kill us for it. Happy Christmas.

:lol:

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Mon Jun 06, 2016 7:17 am

The French are well ahead of us in regards to not bowing down to pressure from religious bigots.

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Mon Jun 06, 2016 8:52 am

Why do we have to keep tip toeing around these ffs? If they don't like it don't watch it. We don't keep telling them what to do

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Mon Jun 06, 2016 8:56 am

Typical Liberal response it's laughable. Don't offend constantly. But these baffons offend Mr and Mrs average beyond. Just to piss them off I hope every English fan dresses as Crusaders. Typical some are determined to destroy anything that is Nationalistic, because they feel ashamed of who we are and our history.
As said above ban the Burka, and get rid of Sharia Law from our shores as they offend me.

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Mon Jun 06, 2016 1:18 pm

Nuclearblue wrote:Typical Liberal response it's laughable. Don't offend constantly. But these baffons offend Mr and Mrs average beyond. Just to piss them off I hope every English fan dresses as Crusaders. Typical some are determined to destroy anything that is Nationalistic, because they feel ashamed of who we are and our history.
As said above ban the Burka, and get rid of Sharia Law from our shores as they offend me.


Spot on Nukes. I find the burqa offensive in Britain and also those who insist it is their right to wearing it for 'religious reasons'. Those people know that other people find it offensive and should choose not to wear it for that very reason. The times I've chosen to wear 'appropriate' clothing in other countries is numerous but I've done it out of consideration of what is the norm and expected in that country. As for sharia law, well they can simply stick that up their arse.

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Mon Jun 06, 2016 5:16 pm

Just ban England.

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Mon Jun 06, 2016 6:33 pm

griff105 wrote:Just ban England.

Oh dear

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Mon Jun 06, 2016 7:46 pm

angelis1949 wrote:
griff105 wrote:Just ban England.

Oh dear


It was a joke.

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Tue Jun 07, 2016 8:53 am

OriginalGrangeEndBlue wrote:Perhaps it's time to ban the f*cking burkha then as that offends a lot of Britons.


:ayatollah:

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Tue Jun 07, 2016 10:31 am

griff105 wrote:
angelis1949 wrote:
griff105 wrote:Just ban England.

Oh dear


It was a joke.

Oh dear oh dear

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Tue Jun 07, 2016 11:00 am

The Muslims need to lighten up a bit. We all get insulted sometimes but live with it. Every time we open our mouths or wear some item of clothing it seems to offend Muslims. No doubt the English will call us sheepshaggers. I could take offence at that, particularly as I doubt if I have shagged more than twenty or so sheep in my entire life.

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Tue Jun 07, 2016 11:22 am

Steve Zodiak wrote:The Muslims need to lighten up a bit. We all get insulted sometimes but live with it. Every time we open our mouths or wear some item of clothing it seems to offend Muslims. No doubt the English will call us sheepshaggers. I could take offence at that, particularly as I doubt if I have shagged more than twenty or so sheep in my entire life.

Not only agree with your posting but was also amused by the ending of your posting

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Tue Jun 07, 2016 6:18 pm

Jock wrote:The BBC is supposed to be fair and accurate, it is neither. They're promotion of a PC Facism has and continues to harm this country.



I have to agree with you to an extent. The BBC has certainly disappeared so far up its own arse that it has lost all sense of direction.

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Tue Jun 07, 2016 6:45 pm

Steve Zodiak wrote:The Muslims need to lighten up a bit. We all get insulted sometimes but live with it. Every time we open our mouths or wear some item of clothing it seems to offend Muslims. No doubt the English will call us sheepshaggers. I could take offence at that, particularly as I doubt if I have shagged more than twenty or so sheep in my entire life.

But it ain't the Mossies it's the Liberal BBC that's trying to dictate to us Chief.

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Wed Jun 08, 2016 11:08 pm

Maybe the Germans should dress up as Nazis....I am sure no one will be offended.

Re: BBC WARNS ENGLISH FANS/NOT TO CAUSE OFFENCE TO MUSLIMS

Thu Jun 09, 2016 6:06 pm

blackandbluebird wrote:Maybe the Germans should dress up as Nazis....I am sure no one will be offended.

Well the Islamofacists certainly won't be.