Wed Feb 17, 2016 8:11 am
Wed Feb 17, 2016 10:24 am
Wed Feb 17, 2016 11:04 am
theclaw wrote:I don't see anything in him to suggest he will be a good manager.
Wed Feb 17, 2016 11:44 am
Wed Feb 17, 2016 1:36 pm
wez1927 wrote:I think he would be better than Bellamy
Wed Feb 17, 2016 3:02 pm
Wed Feb 17, 2016 3:51 pm
Wed Feb 17, 2016 3:53 pm
davids wrote:wez1927 wrote:I think he would be better than Bellamy
Why?
Not arguing with you but I wonder why you think he would do a better job than Bellamy?
Wed Feb 17, 2016 4:00 pm
Wayne S wrote:davids wrote:wez1927 wrote:I think he would be better than Bellamy
Why?
Not arguing with you but I wonder why you think he would do a better job than Bellamy?
Achieved more, better temprament, learnt under the very very best. Would have great contacts from within the Man U ex brethren.
Wed Feb 17, 2016 4:04 pm
Sven wrote:Wayne S wrote:davids wrote:wez1927 wrote:I think he would be better than Bellamy
Why?
Not arguing with you but I wonder why you think he would do a better job than Bellamy?
Achieved more, better temprament, learnt under the very very best. Would have great contacts from within the Man U ex brethren.
Serious question: Given how many ManUre ex-players have actually 'made it' in management, could he (Giggs) be able to cope with little or no money to spend on 'class' players?![]()
His 'hopo' OGS couldn't make the step with many £millions at his disposal and they were from the same stable!![]()
Not many from there have made the grade, have they? Steve Bruce is an obvious exception, of course!
Wed Feb 17, 2016 4:26 pm
Rydogsccfc wrote:Sven wrote:Wayne S wrote:davids wrote:wez1927 wrote:I think he would be better than Bellamy
Why?
Not arguing with you but I wonder why you think he would do a better job than Bellamy?
Achieved more, better temprament, learnt under the very very best. Would have great contacts from within the Man U ex brethren.
Serious question: Given how many ManUre ex-players have actually 'made it' in management, could he (Giggs) be able to cope with little or no money to spend on 'class' players?![]()
His 'hopo' OGS couldn't make the step with many £millions at his disposal and they were from the same stable!![]()
Not many from there have made the grade, have they? Steve Bruce is an obvious exception, of course!
Mark Hughes, Bryan Robson and Gordon Strachan to name a few aswell.
Wed Feb 17, 2016 4:38 pm
Sven wrote:Rydogsccfc wrote:Sven wrote:Wayne S wrote:davids wrote:wez1927 wrote:I think he would be better than Bellamy
Why?
Not arguing with you but I wonder why you think he would do a better job than Bellamy?
Achieved more, better temprament, learnt under the very very best. Would have great contacts from within the Man U ex brethren.
Serious question: Given how many ManUre ex-players have actually 'made it' in management, could he (Giggs) be able to cope with little or no money to spend on 'class' players?![]()
His 'hopo' OGS couldn't make the step with many £millions at his disposal and they were from the same stable!![]()
Not many from there have made the grade, have they? Steve Bruce is an obvious exception, of course!
Mark Hughes, Bryan Robson and Gordon Strachan to name a few aswell.
Bryan Robson????![]()
![]()
![]()
Had to get Sir Terry Venables to bail him out! Was lucky he had a great Chairman in Steve Gibson at Boro!![]()
I'll accept Mark Hughes but not so much Strachan, although he is doing a decent job for the Scots!
When you consider how many players have come out of the University of Ferguson, then I think the return in 'decent' managers has been poor!
Wed Feb 17, 2016 4:57 pm
Sven wrote:Wayne S wrote:davids wrote:wez1927 wrote:I think he would be better than Bellamy
Why?
Not arguing with you but I wonder why you think he would do a better job than Bellamy?
Achieved more, better temprament, learnt under the very very best. Would have great contacts from within the Man U ex brethren.
Serious question: Given how many ManUre ex-players have actually 'made it' in management, could he (Giggs) be able to cope with little or no money to spend on 'class' players?![]()
His 'hopo' OGS couldn't make the step with many £millions at his disposal and they were from the same stable!![]()
Not many from there have made the grade, have they? Steve Bruce is an obvious exception, of course!
Wed Feb 17, 2016 5:13 pm
Wayne S wrote:Sven wrote:Wayne S wrote:davids wrote:wez1927 wrote:I think he would be better than Bellamy
Why?
Not arguing with you but I wonder why you think he would do a better job than Bellamy?
Achieved more, better temprament, learnt under the very very best. Would have great contacts from within the Man U ex brethren.
Serious question: Given how many ManUre ex-players have actually 'made it' in management, could he (Giggs) be able to cope with little or no money to spend on 'class' players?![]()
His 'hopo' OGS couldn't make the step with many £millions at his disposal and they were from the same stable!![]()
Not many from there have made the grade, have they? Steve Bruce is an obvious exception, of course!
I just reckon Giggs would do better than Bellamy.
HOWEVER, I wouldn't have either of them. Too early in their managerial careers.
Wed Feb 17, 2016 5:25 pm
RV Casual wrote:I agree he would be better than Bellamy.
First off, hes got experience albeit in a caretaker role but experience nonetheless, also been a number 2 for the past 2 seasons and would have learned from one of the best in the business in SAF.
He also commamns respect, would likely have better contacts and would be a bigger pull than Bellamy in attracting players.
All in all, for me, theres no contest.
Wed Feb 17, 2016 9:34 pm
Wed Feb 17, 2016 10:01 pm
RV Casual wrote:I agree he would be better than Bellamy.
First off, hes got experience albeit in a caretaker role but experience nonetheless, also been a number 2 for the past 2 seasons and would have learned from one of the best in the business in SAF.
He also commamns respect, would likely have better contacts and would be a bigger pull than Bellamy in attracting players.
All in all, for me, theres no contest.
Thu Feb 18, 2016 12:30 pm
theclaw wrote:I don't see anything in him to suggest he will be a good manager.