Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Mon Oct 26, 2015 11:07 pm

this would be my choice 451 with Dikgacoi as CDM

Marshall
Malone Manga Connoly Fabio
Dikgacoi
Noone Whitts Ralls Pilks
Jones

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Mon Oct 26, 2015 11:09 pm

Marshall

Peltier Morrison Connolly Fabio

Ameobi Whitts Dikagcoi Ralls

Mason

Saadi

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Mon Oct 26, 2015 11:12 pm

Rydogsccfc wrote:Marshall

Peltier Morrison Connolly Fabio

Ameobi Whitts Dikagcoi Ralls

Mason

Saadi

I haven't considered Saadi as I know nothing about him

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Mon Oct 26, 2015 11:25 pm

Marshall
Fabio
Manga
Turner
Malone
Kennedy
Ralls
Dikgacoi
Ameobi
Jones
Asaadi
433

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Tue Oct 27, 2015 12:16 am

stentona wrote:Marshall
Fabio
Manga
Turner
Malone
Kennedy
Ralls
Dikgacoi
Ameobi
Jones
Asaadi
433
completely forgot we had Kennedy would swap him for noone in my team

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Tue Oct 27, 2015 1:39 am

4-4-1-1:

Marshall
Fabio, Manga, Turner, Malone
Ralls, Whittingham, Gunnarsson, Pilkington
Mason, Saadi

Subs: Moore, Connolly, Kennedy, Noone, Dikgacoi, Jones, Ameobi

- Manga and Turner are definitely the best centre-backs at the club, Connolly and Morrison have shown to be liabilities time and time again.
- I don't rate Peltier one bit. Malone and Fabio should both start, always.
- Pilkington when fully fit is class, also Gunnarsson has been class these last two games and deserves his place. Dikgacoi seems to be too much a donkey rather than any use. It's always a tough one between Ralls and Noone, but I find Nooney fucks up too many times.
- Mason is our only pacey (to an extent) little striker, so he starts. I'd give Saadi a run out to see what he's got, he could be the goal machine we've been looking for we just don't know.
- We have a bloody strong bench no matter what team we put out.

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Tue Oct 27, 2015 2:07 am

---------------Marshall
Peltier---Manga--Morrison---Fabio
----------------Dickagoi
----------Ralls----------Whitts
Pilkington--------Jones---------Noone

Bench; Moore, Kennedy, Connolly, Malone/John, Saadi, Ameobi, O'Sullivan(Or O'Keefe)

Do not want Gunnar, Mason or Revell anywhere near the squad, the lack of pace, lack of ability to keep the ball and lack of creativity in these three is a massive cause for the crap the last few weeks. Especially Gunnar back in midfield, it is no coincidence the team has performed poorly since his reinstatement.

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Tue Oct 27, 2015 9:12 am

everyone saying Saadi, no one seen him play :D :D

heads fallen off

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Tue Oct 27, 2015 11:47 am

Cb at pick Saadi as haven't seen him

Marshall

Peltier
Manga
Conolly
Fabio

Kennedy
Digachoi
Whitts
Ralls

Jones
Mason

Subs, Moore, Turner, Malone, Gunnerson, Noone, Ameobi, Saadi

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Tue Oct 27, 2015 11:50 am

cecilccfc wrote:everyone saying Saadi, no one seen him play :D :D

heads fallen off

Why not? We're not scoring enough goals, may as well try out the new guy and see what he's got. Give him a chance. :roll:

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Tue Oct 27, 2015 12:11 pm

Marshall

Peltier - Manga - Connolly - Fabio

Ameobi - Ralls - Dikajoi - Whitts - Noone

Jones

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Tue Oct 27, 2015 12:17 pm

....................Marshall....................

Peltier.....Connolly.....Manga......Fabio

............Dikgachoi...Ralls...............

Noone.........Pilkington...........Kennedy

..................Jones......................

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Tue Oct 27, 2015 8:29 pm

Depressed Blue wrote:....................Marshall....................

Peltier.....Connolly.....Manga......Fabio

............Dikgachoi...Ralls...............

Noone.........Pilkington...........Kennedy

..................Jones......................


Ameobi in for Noone and I'd say this

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Wed Oct 28, 2015 10:09 am

JonCCFC wrote:
cecilccfc wrote:everyone saying Saadi, no one seen him play :D :D

heads fallen off

Why not? We're not scoring enough goals, may as well try out the new guy and see what he's got. Give him a chance. :roll:



:D :D It's like the Echo reporting City got you on a free trial, not scoring goals so try the new fella off the messageboard.

Do you know what type of player he is? Is he like Guerra, decent goalscorer but won't adapt to playing in a foreign country?
Can he handle playing in a team that plays long ball?
Is he used to chasing the CB's for 90 minutes?

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Wed Oct 28, 2015 10:22 am

Reminds me of that episode of Mike bassett. When they buy a foreign player thinking he'll be good because he is foreign.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UdQ78cAYNa8

No idea how to embed youtube videos. Tried everything.

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Wed Oct 28, 2015 10:30 am

Marshall

Connelly Manga Turner

Fabio John
Dicakoi

Ralls Whittingham

Saaidi Jones


Why is everybody fixated with 4-4-2 we have good players kicking their heels because they don'tf it into Russ' only formation.

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Wed Oct 28, 2015 11:27 am

Rydogsccfc wrote:Marshall

Peltier Morrison Connolly Fabio

Ameobi Whitts Dikagcoi Ralls

Mason

Saadi


You would play Saadi ahead of a fully fit KJ?

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Wed Oct 28, 2015 11:31 am

11 eddie johnsons.

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Wed Oct 28, 2015 11:32 am

Marshall
Malone Morrison Manga Fabio

Kennedy Dickajoi Whitts Ralls

Mason
Jones

Ameobi would be breaking the door down to start.

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Wed Oct 28, 2015 12:27 pm

4-3-3

Marshall
Fabio manga connelly malone
Dickachoi whitts
Rails
Amoebi. Jones. Noone

4-4-2

Marshall
Peltier. Manga. Connolly. Fabio

Pilkington. Dickachoi whitts rails

Mason
Jones

Horses for courses. If 4-4-2 need peltier for back 4 protection and pilks as keeps ball well and good full back protection.

If 4-3-3 can play Fabio and malone as more cover centre mid and two more attacking wingers who can beat people. Both sides capable of doing well, although probably prefer the 4-3-3 one.

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Wed Oct 28, 2015 12:34 pm

pontlliwblue wrote:Marshall

Connelly Manga Turner

Fabio John
Dicakoi

Ralls Whittingham

Saaidi Jones


Why is everybody fixated with 4-4-2 we have good players kicking their heels because they don'tf it into Russ' only formation.


until Russ fucks off, we're stuck with 4-4-2 i'm afraid. Dinosaurs never change their spots. The coaching manual 1985 edition is all you'll find on his desk.

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Wed Oct 28, 2015 12:57 pm

Only one team for me
Marshy
Fabio manga conners malone
Deecashwee
Kennedy whitts
Saddi
Jones

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Wed Oct 28, 2015 3:58 pm

cecilccfc wrote:
JonCCFC wrote:
cecilccfc wrote:everyone saying Saadi, no one seen him play :D :D

heads fallen off

Why not? We're not scoring enough goals, may as well try out the new guy and see what he's got. Give him a chance. :roll:



:D :D It's like the Echo reporting City got you on a free trial, not scoring goals so try the new fella off the messageboard.

Do you know what type of player he is? Is he like Guerra, decent goalscorer but won't adapt to playing in a foreign country?
Can he handle playing in a team that plays long ball?
Is he used to chasing the CB's for 90 minutes?

New fella off the messageboard? Saadi is a new STRIKER mate, in case you didn't know. :D :D

Slade brought in this guy for a reason. Have you seen play? Do you know what he's like? Nope. :D :D

Don't write him off before he's even kicked a ball for us. I'd rather give the new striker a chance than carry on playing Revell every time Jones is injured, what have we got to lose? Absolutely nothing. :thumbup:

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Wed Oct 28, 2015 5:36 pm

JonCCFC wrote:
Slade brought in this guy for a reason. Have you seen play? Do you know what he's like? Nope. :D :D

Don't write him off before he's even kicked a ball for us. I'd rather give the new striker a chance than carry on playing Revell every time Jones is injured, what have we got to lose? Absolutely nothing. :thumbup:


SLADE didn't bring him in though did he tan did even the guy who done the deal between the clubs said so in the media from what I remember, still hopefully he comes good jon as anythings worth a shot atm which is something we aint doing :bluescarf:

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Wed Oct 28, 2015 5:42 pm

Bluebird1977 wrote:
JonCCFC wrote:
Slade brought in this guy for a reason. Have you seen play? Do you know what he's like? Nope. :D :D

Don't write him off before he's even kicked a ball for us. I'd rather give the new striker a chance than carry on playing Revell every time Jones is injured, what have we got to lose? Absolutely nothing. :thumbup:


SLADE didn't bring him in though did he tan did even the guy who done the deal between the clubs said so in the media from what I remember, still hopefully he comes good jon as anythings worth a shot atm which is something we aint doing :bluescarf:

Can you show me the article? I didn't read that.

Exactly anything's worth a shot when we're not scoring goals. :thumbright:

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Tue Nov 03, 2015 11:05 am

JonCCFC wrote:
cecilccfc wrote:
JonCCFC wrote:
cecilccfc wrote:everyone saying Saadi, no one seen him play :D :D

heads fallen off

Why not? We're not scoring enough goals, may as well try out the new guy and see what he's got. Give him a chance. :roll:



:D :D It's like the Echo reporting City got you on a free trial, not scoring goals so try the new fella off the messageboard.

Do you know what type of player he is? Is he like Guerra, decent goalscorer but won't adapt to playing in a foreign country?
Can he handle playing in a team that plays long ball?
Is he used to chasing the CB's for 90 minutes?

New fella off the messageboard? Saadi is a new STRIKER mate, in case you didn't know. :D :D

Slade brought in this guy for a reason. Have you seen play? Do you know what he's like? Nope. :D :D

Don't write him off before he's even kicked a ball for us. I'd rather give the new striker a chance than carry on playing Revell every time Jones is injured, what have we got to lose? Absolutely nothing. :thumbup:


Nah mate, not new to the messagebaoard just find better ways to fill my time than post 8,000 times.

But, what relevance does being on a messageboard have to knowing what position a new signing is? :sleepy2:

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Tue Nov 03, 2015 4:00 pm

Depressed Blue wrote:....................Marshall....................

Peltier.....Connolly.....Manga......Fabio

............Dikgachoi...Ralls...............

Noone.........Pilkington...........Kennedy

..................Jones......................
strong looking team :thumbup:

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Tue Nov 03, 2015 4:28 pm

cecilccfc wrote:
JonCCFC wrote:
cecilccfc wrote:
JonCCFC wrote:
cecilccfc wrote:everyone saying Saadi, no one seen him play :D :D

heads fallen off

Why not? We're not scoring enough goals, may as well try out the new guy and see what he's got. Give him a chance. :roll:



:D :D It's like the Echo reporting City got you on a free trial, not scoring goals so try the new fella off the messageboard.

Do you know what type of player he is? Is he like Guerra, decent goalscorer but won't adapt to playing in a foreign country?
Can he handle playing in a team that plays long ball?
Is he used to chasing the CB's for 90 minutes?

New fella off the messageboard? Saadi is a new STRIKER mate, in case you didn't know. :D :D

Slade brought in this guy for a reason. Have you seen play? Do you know what he's like? Nope. :D :D

Don't write him off before he's even kicked a ball for us. I'd rather give the new striker a chance than carry on playing Revell every time Jones is injured, what have we got to lose? Absolutely nothing. :thumbup:


Nah mate, not new to the messagebaoard just find better ways to fill my time than post 8,000 times.

But, what relevance does being on a messageboard have to knowing what position a new signing is? :sleepy2:

Congratulations, you've just managed to completely misread a post. I was quoting your "new fella off the messageboard" nonsense. Try again.

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Tue Nov 03, 2015 6:08 pm

Agree with Jon give Saadi a chance what have we got to lose? :ayatollah:

Re: What team would you have us play if everyone was fit ?

Wed Nov 04, 2015 4:24 pm

Rydogsccfc wrote:Agree with Jon give Saadi a chance what have we got to lose? :ayatollah:

:thumbup: