' SHOULD HE HAVE GIVEN SOME PENALTIES? '
Sat Oct 17, 2015 4:38 pm
By Chris Wathan
SHOULD HE HAVE GIVEN SOME PENALTIES?
There were a few shouts for each side, with Craig Noone seemingly unlucky not to have won a second-half spot kick when he looked to have been tripped. At the other end Sean Morrison and Scott Malone may have been lucky as Morrison's shove on Stevie May was a risk inside the box that he needn't have taken and Scott Malone tried to chest a ball away that came very close to his arm.
SHOULD HE HAVE GIVEN SOME PENALTIES?
There were a few shouts for each side, with Craig Noone seemingly unlucky not to have won a second-half spot kick when he looked to have been tripped. At the other end Sean Morrison and Scott Malone may have been lucky as Morrison's shove on Stevie May was a risk inside the box that he needn't have taken and Scott Malone tried to chest a ball away that came very close to his arm.
Re: ' SHOULD HE HAVE GIVEN SOME PENALTIES? '
Sat Oct 17, 2015 4:44 pm
Possibly but the ref played it safe today.
Re: ' SHOULD HE HAVE GIVEN SOME PENALTIES? '
Sat Oct 17, 2015 5:17 pm
Rydogsccfc wrote:Possibly but the ref played it safe today.
I think he made a few poor decisions
Re: ' SHOULD HE HAVE GIVEN SOME PENALTIES? '
Sat Oct 17, 2015 5:21 pm
Santa Ponsa Blue wrote:Rydogsccfc wrote:Possibly but the ref played it safe today.
I think he made a few poor decisions
That's I mean he played it safe didn't put his neck on the line and make a decision.
Re: ' SHOULD HE HAVE GIVEN SOME PENALTIES? '
Sat Oct 17, 2015 6:08 pm
Cardiff boss Russell Slade: We should have had a penalty -
However, it was a moment early in the second half, when Noone went down under a challenge from Bailey Wright, which stuck in Slade's mind. "It looks a strong, strong claim for a penalty," he said. "Even the centre-half who he'd spoken to admitted it was a penalty but we just don't seem to be getting them at the minute. "I was a little bit disappointed that some of the things we'd worked on, in the first period there was only just glimpses of really. "It wasn't a great game or spectacle by either side in the first period and not a lot of opportunities, but that was in contrast to the second half. "Even though mistakes were made, there were opportunities to be taken and we were looking to do that. We pushed forward. "I thought Noone made a difference coming on at half-time. We took the game to them and we had some wonderful opportunities to get on the scoreboard. -
However, it was a moment early in the second half, when Noone went down under a challenge from Bailey Wright, which stuck in Slade's mind. "It looks a strong, strong claim for a penalty," he said. "Even the centre-half who he'd spoken to admitted it was a penalty but we just don't seem to be getting them at the minute. "I was a little bit disappointed that some of the things we'd worked on, in the first period there was only just glimpses of really. "It wasn't a great game or spectacle by either side in the first period and not a lot of opportunities, but that was in contrast to the second half. "Even though mistakes were made, there were opportunities to be taken and we were looking to do that. We pushed forward. "I thought Noone made a difference coming on at half-time. We took the game to them and we had some wonderful opportunities to get on the scoreboard. -
Re: ' SHOULD HE HAVE GIVEN SOME PENALTIES? '
Sat Oct 17, 2015 10:14 pm
There were a few possible penalties today but for me the clearest one was the trip on Noone.
The ref's guide dog should have been able to give that one.
The ref's guide dog should have been able to give that one.
Re: ' SHOULD HE HAVE GIVEN SOME PENALTIES? '
Sun Oct 18, 2015 8:30 am
Santa Ponsa Blue wrote:By Chris Wathan
SHOULD HE HAVE GIVEN SOME PENALTIES?
There were a few shouts for each side, with Craig Noone seemingly unlucky not to have won a second-half spot kick when he looked to have been tripped. At the other end Sean Morrison and Scott Malone may have been lucky as Morrison's shove on Stevie May was a risk inside the box that he needn't have taken and Scott Malone tried to chest a ball away that came very close to his arm.
Didn't see the Noone one on the highlights i watched however the 2 PNE pens were very debatable, think we got lucky
Re: ' SHOULD HE HAVE GIVEN SOME PENALTIES? '
Sun Oct 18, 2015 12:04 pm
bluespeers wrote:Santa Ponsa Blue wrote:By Chris Wathan
SHOULD HE HAVE GIVEN SOME PENALTIES?
There were a few shouts for each side, with Craig Noone seemingly unlucky not to have won a second-half spot kick when he looked to have been tripped. At the other end Sean Morrison and Scott Malone may have been lucky as Morrison's shove on Stevie May was a risk inside the box that he needn't have taken and Scott Malone tried to chest a ball away that came very close to his arm.
Didn't see the Noone one on the highlights i watched however the 2 PNE pens were very debatable, think we got lucky
The Noone one was up our end and it did look as if he was tripped. Did'nt clearly see the Morrison shove, from where I was sitting, but it was plain as day that Malone was trying to chest the ball down if it hit his hand then it was'nt intentional.