' HE IS STILL QUALITY, WE CAN'T LOSE HIM '

Before people continue to berate David Marshall for his sending off yesterday, take a look at what he has done for City.

He is a points winner for us and we should remember how good he is and we are fortunate to have him.

Totally agree the guy has been crucified on here, some people on here have short memories, yes he made a stupid mistake, but jesus look at what he has done for us, and very loyal as well,

Totally agree the guy has been crucified on here, some people on here have short memories, yes he made a stupid mistake, but jesus look at what he has done for us, and very loyal as well,

Spot on

Nothing in it slight kick which you can't do these days still bad decision by ref, who says we don't want him? Probably the same posters who criticise absolutely anything, lots have different opinions but you can tell the genuine posters to those who don't attend games or those who simply talk through their backside

Scotland's number one will be chanted louder than ever at his next game, the fans attending know his importance

Half the people who've slammed him have forgotten where the CCS is so how do you expect them to remember how much of an oustanding keeper he really is.

Well he can't make saves like that if he is not available.

No one is doubting his quality but what's the point having it if he is not between the sticks.

In my opinion it was a sending off offence,can't really see how a referee can send him off and not give a decision against us,and as it was in the box it had to be a penalty. He couldn't send him off and then give the ball to Moore to carry on the game. If a player was to kick out at an opponent off the ball anywhere on the pitch and then the linesman informs him,he would stop the game send off the player and then give a free kick where the incident took place. As much as I wish the ref hadn't given a penalty I for one am not criticising the ref. Let's hope Marshall learns from this.

In my opinion it was a sending off offence,can't really see how a referee can send him off and not give a decision against us,and as it was in the box it had to be a penalty. He couldn't send him off and then give the ball to Moore to carry on the game. If a player was to kick out at an opponent off the ball anywhere on the pitch and then the linesman informs him,he would stop the game send off the player and then give a free kick where the incident took place. As much as I wish the ref hadn't given a penalty I for one am not criticising the ref. Let's hope Marshall learns from this.

I'd say Marshall was fouled first.
Should have been a free kick to city then a card to Marshall.

As for Marshall I felt he should have been sold when we came down, his value is diminishing quickly. Still top keeper tho.

What he did yesterday was silly and totally unnecessary but we all make mistakes, and we have to learn to move on.

Marshall is quality and IMO the best keeper in this league by far, he's also very loyal and were very lucky to have a goalkeeper of his standard

He is a quality keeper there's no doubt about that its that he can be really frustrating at times and losing his rag twice in 8 games is not good.

Class keeper but stupid , second time he's done that . Notts forest last season

Class keeper but stupid , second time he's done that . Notts forest last season

Its Notts County and Nottingham Forest Dibs. The locals up here have a contract out for you now.

Well he can't make saves like that if he is not available.

No one is doubting his quality but what's the point having it if he is not between the sticks.

Very true!!!

Well he can't make saves like that if he is not available.

No one is doubting his quality but what's the point having it if he is not between the sticks.

It's a bit like all the "resting" players every game. They can't score or defend etc if they are not on the field either. The only reason for this uproar is because he is so good!!!

Other players have seen red cards and it's just unfortunate. Marshall does it and he's a serial monster. Pathetic!!

Best keeper in the division, pure loyalty to CCFC and a great example to all except for a couple of incidents which are hugely regrettable, but hardly capital offences.

Well he can't make saves like that if he is not available.

No one is doubting his quality but what's the point having it if he is not between the sticks.

It's a bit like all the "resting" players every game. They can't score or defend etc if they are not on the field either. The only reason for this uproar is because he is so good!!!

Other players have seen red cards and it's just unfortunate. Marshall does it and he's a serial monster. Pathetic!!

Best keeper in the division, pure loyalty to CCFC and a great example to all except for a couple of incidents which are hugely regrettable, but hardly capital offences.

Totally disagree.

This is all Marshalls doing. To defend him using players who are resting through no fault of their own or players recovering through injured due to the call of duty is wrong. Marshall was totally responsible for his actions and to make himself unavailable for what is half the present season is unacceptable.

The problem could be that players will know he has it in him to lash out so they will be targeting him with little 'digs' to see if he bites. No point being brilliant if you can't keep your head.

For me though it's gone, glad he's ours and we move on

lol some on here making our Marshall is as bad as Diego Costa....

Class keeper but stupid , second time he's done that . Notts forest last season

Its Notts County and Nottingham Forest Dibs. The locals up here have a contract out for you now.

Also known as Scabs

Well he can't make saves like that if he is not available.

No one is doubting his quality but what's the point having it if he is not between the sticks.

It's a bit like all the "resting" players every game. They can't score or defend etc if they are not on the field either. The only reason for this uproar is because he is so good!!!

Other players have seen red cards and it's just unfortunate. Marshall does it and he's a serial monster. Pathetic!!

Best keeper in the division, pure loyalty to CCFC and a great example to all except for a couple of incidents which are hugely regrettable, but hardly capital offences.

Totally disagree.

This is all Marshalls doing. To defend him using players who are resting through no fault of their own or players recovering through injured due to the call of duty is wrong. Marshall was totally responsible for his actions and to make himself unavailable for what is half the present season is unacceptable.

I disagree.

Players who are not in the first XI or subs may need to work harder to put themselves in the frame.

There are plenty of people who, having seen the footage, disagree with the red card too. This isn't as straightforward as you are making out. To turn on a long-standing player for this lets the side down in my opinion. Marshall was swung through virtually a full circle by being held by his shirt. Towards the end of the spin, he unwisely swung his leg (which probably made no contact).

For that, he has let the club down. Get a grip. The ref's decision was flawed in giving a penalty and Moore should be capable of deputising for injuries, resting or any other eventuality. He shouldn't have faced a penalty in the first place.

Like I said on another thread, if he's such a liability, sell him on but I think that would be a disaster.
To say Marshall chose to make himself unavailable is just not true. I've seen a lot worse from Bellers over the years but he wasn't vilified like this.

I feel David Marshall was hard done by we was pulled back and tried to get free but because of him being off balance it looks far worse than it was. Also I am not sure we would have won that game with 11 from what people who were there assessed our performance.

Never a red card for me , he is a top goalkeeper and will be back, now its up to Simon Moore to step up to the plate for the next three games

Well he can't make saves like that if he is not available.

No one is doubting his quality but what's the point having it if he is not between the sticks.

It's a bit like all the "resting" players every game. They can't score or defend etc if they are not on the field either. The only reason for this uproar is because he is so good!!!

Other players have seen red cards and it's just unfortunate. Marshall does it and he's a serial monster. Pathetic!!

Best keeper in the division, pure loyalty to CCFC and a great example to all except for a couple of incidents which are hugely regrettable, but hardly capital offences.

Totally disagree.

This is all Marshalls doing. To defend him using players who are resting through no fault of their own or players recovering through injured due to the call of duty is wrong. Marshall was totally responsible for his actions and to make himself unavailable for what is half the present season is unacceptable.

I disagree.

Players who are not in the first XI or subs may need to work harder to put themselves in the frame.

There are plenty of people who, having seen the footage, disagree with the red card too. This isn't as straightforward as you are making out. To turn on a long-standing player for this lets the side down in my opinion. Marshall was swung through virtually a full circle by being held by his shirt. Towards the end of the spin, he unwisely swung his leg (which probably made no contact).

For that, he has let the club down. Get a grip. The ref's decision was flawed in giving a penalty and Moore should be capable of deputising for injuries, resting or any other eventuality. He shouldn't have faced a penalty in the first place.

Like I said on another thread, if he's such a liability, sell him on but I think that would be a disaster.
To say Marshall chose to make himself unavailable is just not true. I've seen a lot worse from Bellers over the years but he wasn't vilified like this.

Well us two are going ot have to agree to disagree.

Well he can't make saves like that if he is not available.

No one is doubting his quality but what's the point having it if he is not between the sticks.

It's a bit like all the "resting" players every game. They can't score or defend etc if they are not on the field either. The only reason for this uproar is because he is so good!!!

Other players have seen red cards and it's just unfortunate. Marshall does it and he's a serial monster. Pathetic!!

Best keeper in the division, pure loyalty to CCFC and a great example to all except for a couple of incidents which are hugely regrettable, but hardly capital offences.

Totally disagree.

This is all Marshalls doing. To defend him using players who are resting through no fault of their own or players recovering through injured due to the call of duty is wrong. Marshall was totally responsible for his actions and to make himself unavailable for what is half the present season is unacceptable.

I disagree.

Players who are not in the first XI or subs may need to work harder to put themselves in the frame.

There are plenty of people who, having seen the footage, disagree with the red card too. This isn't as straightforward as you are making out. To turn on a long-standing player for this lets the side down in my opinion. Marshall was swung through virtually a full circle by being held by his shirt. Towards the end of the spin, he unwisely swung his leg (which probably made no contact).

For that, he has let the club down. Get a grip. The ref's decision was flawed in giving a penalty and Moore should be capable of deputising for injuries, resting or any other eventuality. He shouldn't have faced a penalty in the first place.

Like I said on another thread, if he's such a liability, sell him on but I think that would be a disaster.
To say Marshall chose to make himself unavailable is just not true. I've seen a lot worse from Bellers over the years but he wasn't vilified like this.

Well us two are going ot have to agree to disagree.

Looks like it.

Scotland's number one will be chanted louder than ever at his next game, the fans attending know his importance

I should hope so too - his next game will be for Scotland!

He did feck all wrong, he should have never been sent off, he was pulled around, it was a tiny flick

The referees are getting worse !!!!

He did feck all wrong, he should have never been sent off, he was pulled around, it was a tiny flick

The referees are getting worse !!!!